China skirts Africa corruption
2012-02-09 18:50
Kampala - China last month sent a senior official to symbolically hand over the keys to a nine-story twin tower to house Uganda's president and prime minister, a gift from Beijing.
The white structures with a sloping roof cost China $27m to build. But - in a strategy that China is increasingly employing around Africa - Beijing didn't just deliver the money and let Ugandan officials see the project through.
It was built by Chinese workers in what aid watchdogs applaud as a model to help defeat the inefficiencies and cash-pocketing corruption associated with other systems of foreign aid delivery.
China has a growing economic footprint in Uganda and much of the rest of Africa, and some Ugandans natives complain of the rising number of Chinese arriving to set up shop. China's strategic interest in this East African country has deepened at a time when Uganda hopes to become an oil producer.
But the completion of projects like a modern hospital complex has softened China's reputation, while Beijing's efforts to produce turn-key projects are winning fans among Ugandans tired of seeing their officials ripping off foreign aid projects with impunity.
Instead of giving cash, the Chinese government prefers to pay Chinese companies to build roads and structures, bypassing local politicians, power brokers and construction crews, and to deliver them completed.
The China model is "more effective. It's less prone to corruption," said Sven Grimm, the executive director of the Centre for Chinese Studies at Stellenbosch University in South Africa.
He said the approach also bolsters China's economy, because "Chinese enterprises... go out and gain international experience."
$50m aid stolen
Experts say China's model of donating buildings and roads might help it cut the risk of aid scandals like the one that rocked the $22.6bn Global Fund to Fight Aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria over the past year. The Geneva-based financier gets donations from wealthy donor nations and private sources like Bill Gates.
But donors recoiled after the fund's internal watchdog documented more than $50m in losses due to corruption and other misuse and unauthorised spending, affecting much of Africa, including Uganda.
Western donors routinely threaten to cut aid to Uganda over corruption, which registers in millions of dollars every year.
In February 2010, in the aftermath of scandals that shook the faith of donors in the government's ability to cut wasteful spending and corruption, a World Bank official warned that corruption had become "endemic."
But Western nations keep giving aid to Uganda, infuriating anti-corruption activists.
"If I have abused your money and you give me more, it's like you are applauding me," Cissy Kagaba, who heads a watchdog called the Anti-Corruption Coalition of Uganda, said.
Transparency International ranks Uganda among the most corrupt nations, at 143 out of 182 countries in its most recent survey. Public officials in high and low places are constantly looking for opportunities to steal or be bribed and the offerings of foreign governments and agencies have traditionally been easy to abuse, critics say.
US and European aid money, for example, frequently funds workshops at expensive hotels. Participants of the "capacity building" programmes are given free travel to the sites along with per diems and accommodation.
Concrete things
"Capacity building ... is the easiest to steal because the only evidence is paper accountability," said Augustine Ruzindana, Uganda's former anti-corruption chief.
"The people who pay also know what they are doing, and so it's self-perpetuating. With the Chinese method it's easier to show that something has been done. They do concrete things which can be seen by several generations."
China's aid is not always welcomed. Last month new headquarters paid for by China for the African Union were unveiled in Ethiopia. Rwandan President Paul Kagame called it "pathetic" that Africa accepted such a donation and asked whether Africa couldn't afford to pay for such a building itself.
In Uganda, as in other African countries where it has strategic interests, China has polished its reputation with muscular projects which it then hands over as gifts. Prominent donations to Uganda include the headquarters of the ministry of foreign affairs and a sports stadium.
Even when the projects are tied to loans, such as in the planned construction of a four-lane express way from the capital to Uganda's international airport in nearby Entebbe, the Chinese insist on taking full charge.
This has shut down avenues traditionally used by public officials to inflate costs while doing shoddy work, to get paid for work not done or to insist on bribes before endorsing certain projects, anti-corruption officials say.
"The Chinese model is better," said Fred Guweddeko, a research fellow at the Makerere University Institute of Social Research in Kampala.
- AP