Beyond reasonable greed
2009-06-18 10:35
In 2002, I co-authored a book with Wayne Visser entitled Beyond Reasonable Greed: Why Sustainable Business is a Much Better Idea. Wayne at the time was Director of Sustainability Services at KPMG in South Africa. He now lives in Cambridge, England where he has made a name in the corporate social responsibility field.
"Greed is good." Remember the phrase immortalised by Michael Douglas who played Gordon Gekko in the 1987 movie Wall Street? Well, Wayne and I argued that the world has more than lived up to these words by pursuing the principle that excessive greed is even better. This is what we said in the book:
"Each day, the turnover in the world's financial markets is now in excess of $1.5 trillion. It is at least twenty times more than it was in 1980. The explosive growth of this global casino is largely as a result of introducing two new games: futures and derivatives trading. It all began on the Philadelphia Stock exchange in 1971 and has escalated to a level where only around two percent of capital outflows are backed by trade in real goods.
"One of the worrying side effects of speculative trading is an increase in the volatility and instability of financial markets. In turn, by making real economies more unpredictable, these roller-coaster fluctuations destroy the livelihoods of small traders and farmers, increase business bankruptcies and disrupt the plans of supposedly sovereign governments to provide a better life for all."
Five years after we wrote these words, the Crash began in the middle of 2007. The derivatives market peaked at $532 trillion but nobody can put a value on it today. Its fall has led to the biggest decline in the global economy since the 1930s and the biggest bailout of banks ever seen. Even we are gobsmacked by the magnitude of the disaster.
We argued at the time that companies had to move away from the predatory tooth-and-claw logic of the lion to the more caring, holistic philosophy of the elephant. We called the process "shapeshifting" since it involves a shift in the basic paradigm underlying all large-scale commercial activity. In particular, we needed to strive for a proper balance between co-operation and competition and a continuing diversity of business species, large and small, strong and weak.
Moreover, we urged readers of our book to beware of "leophants" who "want to be all things to all people - sucking up to shareholders when it suits them and rolling over for the 'greenies' when circumstances demand. They have recognised that some of their lion traits are going to get them into trouble sooner or later and that elephants are beginning to gain favour in the world.
"As a result, they are just starting to test the water - introducing an environmental policy here, adopting a corporate governance code there, adding a few nonfinancial performance measures, setting up community forums. They are not yet bold enough to whip off their lion suits and dive right into the refreshing pool of sustainability. After all, there may be sharp objects lurking beneath the surface; besides other lions might laugh if they discover that their roar is bigger than their...well, you know!"
As such, it was a genuine change of heart that Wayne and I were calling for - a revolution of the corporate mind. Keep your trunks crossed because maybe the Crash will turn out to be the most effective shapeshifter we've had in a long time. The only difference between a plundering dictator and a plundering director is technique. Both have to go.
Welcome to the world of the elephant where natural self-interest never spills over into unreasonable greed.
Send your comments to Clem
Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.
- News24