Was N Korea nuke test a dud?
2006-10-10 14:57
Paris - Was North Korea's nuclear device a dud, as some Western experts suspect?
More than 60 years after the United States first tested a plutonium weapon - partly because scientists weren't sure that it would work - the technology is still tricky for novices to master.
The apparent low yield of the North's test could signal that its scientists, working largely in isolation, haven't quite perfected the deadly art of efficiently splitting atoms.
'Devil is in the details'
"The devil is in the details," French nuclear proliferation expert Bruno Tertrais said. "It's like cooking. The fact that you have the recipe does not make you a chef."
North Korea is widely thought to have been seeking to make bombs from plutonium, the same material used in the device that the US first tested on July 16, 1945, ushering in the atomic age.
Robert Oppenheimer, who oversaw the US weapons programme, on that historic day lost his $10 bet that the bomb - nicknamed "the Gadget" - would not detonate.
Only the North Koreans likely know what sort of explosion they were hoping for and whether the test was a success, as they claimed.
Fizzle
But there's also a possibility that the device - if it was indeed nuclear - suffered what experts call "a fizzle," when the fissile material that provides the bang, likely plutonium in North Korea's case, detonates only partly.
A key reason for those suspicions was the apparent low intensity of the explosion.
Russia estimated that it was a relatively large - equivalent to the force that would be unleashed by 5 000-15 000 tons of the conventional high-explosive TNT.
'There could have been a failure'
But France and others had far lower estimates, ranging from 500-1 000 tons of TNT, prompting the French defence minister to comment "that there could have been a failure".
South Korea also said that it wasn't certain that the North's test was a success and that resolving that doubt would take about two weeks.
France's atomic energy agency did not want to comment further on Tuesday - partly, a spokesperson said, because it was concerned that discussing where North Korea might have gone wrong could help it fix any problems for next time.
Figuring it out on its own
While there is evidence that North Korea got Pakistani help with its nuclear programme, the isolated, communist country also has had to figure out a lot of technical bomb-making details itself - another likely factor in a possible failed test, said Vladimir Orlov of the PIR Centre, a non-proliferation think-tank.
"Both intellectually, technologically and financially, they are really in practical isolation, which is relatively good news," said Orlov.
The apparent low yield, he added, "indicates that the North Koreans really have trouble making what ordinary people would call a nuclear bomb, they really have a primitive nuclear device."
- AP