CAPE TOWN Showers early. Morning clouds. Cool.

MIN8
MAX13
7 day
  • Wednesday 10-14°c Sunny. Cool. Sunny. Cool.
    Thursday 10-14°c Afternoon clouds. Cool. Afternoon clouds. Cool.
    Friday 11-14°c Rain showers. More clouds than sun. Cool. Rain showers. More clouds than sun. Cool.
    Saturday 10-14°c Mostly sunny. Cool. Mostly sunny. Cool.
    Sunday 8-15°c Sunny. Cool. Sunny. Cool.
    Monday 12-16°c Sunny. Cool. Sunny. Cool.
More News

Court reserves judgment in SMS appeal

2014-04-25 22:31
DA march
Bloemfontein - The Electoral Court reserved judgment on Friday on an appeal against a ruling that a DA SMS about President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead was fair comment.

Supreme Court of Appeal deputy president Judge Kenneth Mthiyane said judgment would be delivered in a few days.

On 4 April in the South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg, acting Judge Mike Hellens dismissed the ANC's application to stop the distribution of the SMS, saying it was fair comment.

The SMS, sent by the DA to over 1.5 million voters in Gauteng, reads in part: "The Nkandla report shows how Zuma stole your money to build his R246m home."

The SMS followed findings by Public Protector Thuli Madonsela that Zuma and his family unduly benefited from R246m in security upgrades to his KwaZulu-Natal residence.

The DA's legal counsel Ismail Jamie argued on Friday the SMS did not fall foul of the Electoral Code of Conduct.

The ANC contended the issue fell within the Electoral Commission Act, which stipulates no person may publish false information with the intent of influencing the conduct or outcome of an election. It further submitted the Electoral Code of Conduct stipulates that no party or candidate may publish false or defamatory allegations in respect of a party, candidate, or representative of a party or a member.

Jamie submitted that according to Madonsela's report on Nkandla, entitled "Secure in Comfort", Zuma benefited and benefited improperly.

"He permitted that. Too much is made that 'licence to loot' refers to officials."

He argued it was not the officials who benefited from the upgrades. Jamie argued the conclusion that Zuma stole public money, as stated in the SMS, followed from a fair reading of the report.

"The DA cannot be found guilty of violating the code."

Publishing ‘false allegations’

Jamie said a reasonable person could reach the conclusion that "the report shows", as stated in the SMS. He further submitted the SMS should be seen as a "view" and not as a stated fact, which was the ANC's argument.

The ANC argued the DA violated the code with the SMS.

"No one can publish false allegations of a party, a candidate or a representative of the party or members," submitted Gcina Malindi, for the ANC.

He argued that Madonsela's findings did not amount to a finding that Zuma stole.

"The court below also stated that it was not what the protector had found, but it went on to find a justification for the publication on fair comment."

Malindi argued the word "stole" was not in the report. He said the phrase "licence to loot" in the report referred to administrative lapses in government departments. Zuma was only referred to in the report in terms of lapses in ethical obligations.

"Which is far removed from the issue of licence to loot," he argued.

He said the SMS as it stood made a clear allegation that the president had stolen. There were no facts a reasonable reader could consider to decide whether the statement was fair, Malindi submitted.

- SAPA
Read more on: da  |  anc  |  johannesburg  |  politics  |  elections 2014

More In This Category
Catholic bishops condemn election violence

Young people should not let politicians use them in the build-up to the elections, the Southern African Catholic Bishops' Conference and the Justice and Peace Commission says.

Violence doesn't help anyone, Maimane tells Tshwane residents

DA leader Mmusi Maimane has pleaded with residents of Tshwane not to engage in violent protests, saying they will not bring about any solutions.

Zuma's silence on Tshwane violence shameful – Maimane

President Jacob Zuma should come out of hiding and speak out against the violent protests in Tshwane in which five people died, the DA has said after its federal council held in eThekwini.

SACP suspends 5 district members implicated in Tshwane unrest

The South African Communist Party in Gauteng has resolved to suspend with immediate effect five District Executive Committee members implicated in the Tshwane unrest.

Comments
Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
15 comments
Comments have been closed for this article.
News24 |   OLX  |  Property24  |  Careers24  |  Spree  |