Cape Town - There are no plans to legally challenge
Public Protector Thuli Madonsela
's report on Nkandla, ANC national chairperson
said on Thursday.
"We have not taken such a decision," she told
reporters in Cape Town.
There were also no plans to take action against Police
Minister Nathi Mthethwa for his role in the security upgrades at President
Jacob Zuma's private Nkandla homestead in KwaZulu-Natal.
"Again, we have taken no such decision."
Madonsela found that Mthethwa's declaration of the
homestead as a national key point amounted to improper conduct and
This finding formed part of her final report, released
last month, on the security upgrades totalling R246m.
She found that Zuma and his family unduly benefited from
the upgrades, and said Zuma should pay back a portion of the cost.
Mbete said Madonsela's report and a report released by
government's task team were largely similar in context, and that Zuma was found
to have not lied to Parliament.
The ANC agreed that the escalating cost of Nkandla had to
be probed because there was "too much of this culture" in government,
and the public works department in particular.
However, it believed some of Madonsela's remarks amounted
to interference in terms of African tradition.
"A lot was clarified, in fact, by Thuli's report.
She then goes on to say a few things which, in our view, are actually debatable
because in the African tradition you don't interfere with a man's kraal.
"The issue of a man's kraal or a kraal of a family
is a holy space."
She said security experts had looked at his KwaZulu-Natal
home from a security perspective and shifted it in such a way that did not
benefit the family.
"And Thuli says: 'No, they benefited and, therefore,
President Zuma ought to think of paying some money'. We beg to differ very
strongly, very, very strongly."
The tuckshop of Zuma's first wife, Ma Khumalo, had to be
moved from where it had been for many years to an inconvenient spot far away
because of security considerations.
Mbete questioned how this could have benefited the
"It's a longer distance that she now has to walk.
It's a tinier space and those who have seen it say it doesn't look like a
five-star shop or anything."
Public urged to calm
She said visitors to Nkandla had noted Ma Khumalo's
negative feelings about the "attention, noise and intrusion into their
private family space".
Mbete asked the public to "calm down" until the
Special Investigating Unit (SIU) had released its report on the matter because
it would reveal who was responsible.
National Assembly speaker Max Sisulu announced last week
that an ad hoc Parliamentary committee on Nkandla would be set up.
Its mandate is to consider Zuma's response to Madonsela's
report and make recommendations, where applicable.
Zuma reacted to Madonsela's report earlier this month,
saying he would give a substantive response once the SIU had completed its
On Monday, DA parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko
accused the ANC of deliberately trying to delay the committee's work by not
submitting the names of its members who would serve on it.
But Mbete said choosing the best qualified people took
"I can tell you my personal experience of getting
names from the ANC. It's a pain... the ANC is a huge monster," she said.
"It takes forever... because you often have to
convene the appropriate structure that is supposed to take such a
She said it was not a deliberate move and one had to keep
in mind that people were campaigning all over the country.
"However, I would also maybe dare to comment that at
this point, that committee would have very little to consider.
"It would be best when finally the SIU report is on
the table and the president has actually given us a comprehensive response,
then it would be in a much better space for such a committee to look at
something more substantive."