CAPE TOWN Morning clouds. Mild.

7 day
  • Wednesday 16-25°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Thursday 16-22°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Friday 17-23°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Saturday 16-21°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Sunday 15-20°c Sunny. Mild. Sunny. Mild.
    Monday 15-21°c High level clouds. Mild. High level clouds. Mild.
More News

Ombudsman: DA ‘Twitter race war’ story misleading

2014-05-19 12:11

Cape Town - The Press Ombudsman has upheld a complaint by the DA that a report in the Sunday Independent over a "Twitter race war" was inaccurate and misleading.

Ombudsman Johan Retief, in a ruling released on Monday, said the Democratic Alliance's complaint was about a story published on 20 April headlined DA digs in amid Twitter race war.

The Democratic Alliance's communications head Gavin Davis complained that the headline and several statements about the party and leader Helen Zille were incorrect and misleading.

Election campaign

"The story, written by Shanti Aboobaker, said that, as political parties ratchet up their election rhetoric, supporters of Zille have taken to twitter to liken ANC politicians to the Nazis," said Retief.

Aboobaker mentioned a tweet by the user @Blow_Back_Time, who addressed a message to Zille and Davis saying: "This [Adolf Hitler] is the real face of Gwede Mantashe".

The tweet contained a picture of Nazi leader Hitler, complete with a swastika band, next to African National Congress secretary general Gwede Mantashe. A swastika had been photo-shopped onto the lapel of his jacket.

The journalist wrote in the story that although the comments violated the Electoral Code of Conduct and skirted the boundaries of hate speech, the DA refused to condemn or distance Zille from them.

Aboobaker added that Zille and Davis "seemed to see nothing wrong with likening a black South African politician to a genocidal white supremacist, and refused to condemn the tweet despite a storm of protests from many of their own followers".

Aboobaker continued that Zille seemed to encourage the tweeter by calling the message "ironic" because she said the ANC called her Hitler or a Nazi. The journalist said Zille produced no evidence to support her claim.

Exaggeration and omission

Davis complained the entire story had been concocted by resorting to exaggeration and omission.

"Overall, the net effect of these inaccuracies is that the reader is left with the impression that the DA condones racism and Nazism. Nothing could be further from the truth," he said.

Sunday Independent executive editor Janet Smith said she disagreed that the story effectively accused the DA of Nazism.

"Our story grew out of a debate which our reporter followed which played out on a public twitter feed. Miss Aboobaker is our designated reporter to follow the DA throughout its campaign."

Smith added that the story only showed that Zille and her party had themselves attempted to liken the ANC to the Nazis, but not in terms of anti-Semitism.

"This contention is supported in repeated comments which Ms Zille and the DA had previously made about, for example, 'Gestapo-like crackdowns' by the 'Zuma SABC' on freedom of speech.

"However, we understand that rhetoric is a major part of electioneering, and that this so-called negative campaigning was part of the DA's strategy, as it also was for some other parties," Smith concluded.

Headline ‘misleading’

Retief said the journalist firstly assumed the person who tweeted was a DA supporter, which was quite innocent.

"However, from there the reporter not only erroneously stated that tweet users broke the Electoral Code, but she also explicitly stated that the DA refused to condemn this or to distance itself from such transgressions," he said.

It was his view that one could not distance oneself from a transgression that did not even take place.

He said the journalist hinted at possible hate speech, whatever its definition, and again directly linked the DA to it.

Thus, Retief found that the electoral code and hate speech mentions were both in breach of the Press Code.

The code stipulated that the press had to take care to report news truthfully, accurately and fairly, only present what may reasonably be true as fact, and exercise care and consideration in matters involving reputation.

Retief found the headline misleading.

"Although the headline was not of Aboobaker's making, it served to fuel the non-existent fire the reporter had, evidently, attempted to light," he said.

The net effect of the story was in breach of section 2.2 of the Press Code, which stated that news should be presented in context and in a balanced manner.

The section also stipulated that there should be no intentional or negligent departure from the facts whether by distortion, exaggeration or misrepresentation, material omissions or summarisation.

The Sunday Independent was ordered to apologise to the DA, Zille, and Davis. The paper was directed to publish the sanction and the finding. It had seven working days to appeal.

Read more on: da  |  press ombudsman  |  helen zille  |  politics  |  racism  |  media  |  elections 2014

More In This Category
IEC announces by-election date

The IEC has announced a date for municipal ward by-elections.

ANC Limpopo urges party to rebuild, dismisses early conference talk

The ANC in Limpopo has vowed to reform itself and has urged branches to focus on rebuilding instead of holding an early special conference or consultative conference.

3 more arrests for slain DA councillor, partner

Three more people have appeared in court in connection with the murders of DA councillor Johannes Baatjies and his business partner, the Northern Cape Hawks have said.

ANC 'colluding' MEC in hung councils hits back at IFP

KwaZulu-Natal Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs MEC Nomusa Dube-Ncube has hit back at the Inkatha Freedom Party which has accused her of working with the ANC to stall processes in hung municipalities.

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
News24 |   OLX  |  PROPERTY24  |  CAREERS24  |  SPREE  |