CAPE TOWN More sun than clouds. Mild.

MIN16
MAX21
7 day
  • Sunday 15-21°c High level clouds. Mild. High level clouds. Mild.
    Monday 16-20°c More sun than clouds. Mild. More sun than clouds. Mild.
    Tuesday 16-19°c Morning clouds. Mild. Morning clouds. Mild.
    Wednesday 16-20°c Mostly sunny. Mild. Mostly sunny. Mild.
    Thursday 16-18°c Morning clouds. Mild. Morning clouds. Mild.
    Friday 14-18°c High level clouds. Mild. High level clouds. Mild.
More News

Report: Does the DA deliver?

2014-03-25 17:46
(via Twitter)
Bloemfontein - Africa Check published a report which questions the pre-election claims being made on Twitter by the DA.

The report investigates the DA's claims relating to its performance in the Western Cape, the only province in the country that is not held by the ANC. It evaluates a number of key claims made by the party on the social network using the hashtag #DADelivers.

According to their website Africa Check is a non-partisan fact-checking website, based in African journalism schools, using journalistic skills and crowd-sourced info, to hold leaders to account.

Claim

In the 2nd half of 2012/13, the WC Provincial Govt. created 60 000 work opportunities via the Expanded Public Works Projects. #DAdelivers

Fact

According to Africa Check the DA’s former social media manager, Alex Molteno, said the claim was based on the Expanded Public Works Programme’s second quarterly report for 2012/13. But according to that report, 68 044 work opportunities were created in the Western Cape in the first half of 2012/13, not the second half as stated in the DA’s tweet.

According to the report, if the claim was based on the first half of the year, then it understated performance.

The third and fourth quarterly reports - which cover the second half of the year - have yet to be released and it is unclear how many work opportunities were created then.

Claim

@DA_News municipalities have created 31 000 job opportunities in the past year. #DAdelivers

Fact

This claim appears to have first been tweeted by Gavin Davis, the DA’s communications director. It was then recycled by the DA which tweeted it on several different dates including 18 September, 2 October, 18 November and 30 December 2013. The claim was also included in the party’s 2014 election manifesto, the report states.

It questions whether the claim refers to a calendar year, a financial year or a specific 12 month period. If it was the latter, then - given the fact that the tweet was used on several different dates - which 12 month period did it refer to?

According to the DA, the claim is supported by the Expanded Public Works Programme's second quarterly report for 2012/13.  But that report states that 18 104 work opportunities were created in Western Cape district and metropolitan municipalities between 1 April 2012 and 30 September 2013. A further 7 491 work opportunities were created during the same period in Western Cape local municipalities - which totals to 25 595.

Claim

W Cape has best delivery record in SA: 99.1% of households access piped water, 93.4% electricity & 96.9% have toilet facilities. #DAdelivers

Fact

According to the DA, the claim is supported by data collected during South Africa's 2011 national census.

The census found that 99.1% of households in the Western Cape had access to piped water and 93.4% of households used electricity for lighting. It is in second place, after Gauteng, with 96.9% having access to toilets.

Claim

The City of Cape Town delivers more to poor residents than any other city in the country. #DAdelivers

Fact

The DA says the claim is supported by a 2011 report on household access to basic services which was compiled by the national government’s department of co-operative government and traditional affairs, Africa Check reports.

The report, which in fact used data from 2009, ranked the City of Cape Town first in the country for providing services to households. It stated that 90% of households there had achieved basic service levels and 88% had achieved higher service levels. It’s important to note that the report referred to “the levels of household access to basic service” throughout the city and did not refer specifically to poor residents.

Claim

8 of the top 10 South African municipalities in the Municipal IQ’s Productivity Index are governed by @DA_News. #DAdelivers

Fact

This claim has been tweeted a number of times since November 2013 and is said to have been taken from Municipal IQ’s 2013 Productivity Index. Municipal IQ is an independent data service that monitors and assesses South Africa municipalities.

The claim is not strictly correct (though it is close) as the index states that seven, not eight, of the 10 top-performing local municipalities are in the Western Cape.

Claim

76% of the Western Cape Government's budget is redistributed to poor communities. #DAdelivers

Fact

Bothma referred Africa Check to a presentation compiled by Western Cape Premier Helen Zille’s office on provincial "expenditure on the poor". However, the source provided does not support the claim.

Only the departments of health, education, human settlements, social development and cultural affairs and sport were considered in the analysis. Expenditure in eight other provincial departments was not analysed.

For the full report, visit Africa Check here. You can also follow them on Twitter.
Read more on: helen zille  |  western cape  |  politics  |  social networks  |  service delivery  |  elections 2014

More In This Category
KZN ANC plans to win all wards, municipalities

The ANC in KwaZulu-Natal says it plans to win all wards and municipalities in the province in the upcoming local government elections.

I haven't sold out – DA's Cachalia

DA mayoral candidate for Ekhurleni, Ghaleb Cachalia, says while the EFF's membership is 'visible and vocal', it is also the ordinary people who go to work every day who will vote in large numbers in the upcoming local government elections.

Sanity must prevail at ConCourt over elections - Van Rooyen

It is hoped that “sanity will prevail” in the Constitutional Court next week, as postponing the elections is not an option, Co-operative Governance Minister Des van Rooyen says.

EFF must produce evidence of IEC vote rigging - dept

The EFF has still not produced evidence to back up its renewed claims that the IEC "stole" its votes during the 2014 elections, the Co-operative Governance Department says.

Comments
Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
115 comments
Comments have been closed for this article.
News24 |   OLX  |  Property24  |  Careers24  |  Spree  |