MyNews24 is a user-generated section of The stories here come from users.

Comments: 24
Article views: 527
Latest Badges:

View all Licence's badges.

Eliminative Materialism and the reality of Belief

29 April 2013, 09:00

Sean (a) claims that strong atheism is incoherent, because strong atheists are materialists, and intentional states are immaterial. Therefore, strong atheism is self-refuting.

My suspicion is that Sean is paraphrasing a similar argument made by Edward Feser, the Catholic philosopher of religion (b). Let me propose a more formal, and less easily rejected expression of Sean's argument:

  1. Eliminative materialists hold the view that we can only accept as real that which can be shown to be ultimately determined by physics.

  2. Strong atheism leads to eliminative materialism.

  3. Beliefs, desires and other propositional attitudes have non-material existence.

  4. Because of 1, eliminative materialists do not consider beliefs, desires and other propositional attitudes to have real existence.

  5. But, eliminative materialists have beliefs (for example, as in 1).

  6. Eliminative materialism, and hence strong atheism, is self-refuting on the grounds that in order for it to be true, you have to believe it, but they reject the reality of beliefs.

Most atheist commentators on his article have pointed out the problem with step 2. It is of course not true that strong atheism leads to eliminative materialism. But as it turns out, I hold the view that strong atheism together with scientific realism do ultimately lead to some form of eliminative materialism. This view can be rightfully challenged, but it is not my intention with this article to elaborate on that specific point. So let's move on.

Point 3 is probably true. This claim was first made by Franz Brentano (c), who claimed that propositional attitudes cannot be reduced to material processes. I am not aware of any serious challenge to Brentano's irreducibility claim.

Point 4 is true, according to the eliminative materialist - they deny the real existence of propositional attitudes. They claim that our experience of beliefs and desires are illusory.

Initially, this sounds shocking. How can anyone claim that a common sense, everyday concept such as having a belief is not real? To follow this argument, we must look at the ontology of belief – does holding a belief have some kind of real meaning? If we say somebody holds a belief, is there some deeper fact of the matter that we can obtain knowledge of?

Putnam (d) came up with an interesting thought experiment, of which I will help myself with a simplified version from Dennet's “The Intentional Stance” (e) to illustrate the point. Imagine a chain of bars called Sharky's. Every Sharky's bar looks exactly the same inside, as specified by strict franchise rules – it has a bar area, a few pool tables and some bathrooms at the back. There are tens of these Sharky's bars all over Gauteng.

Three friends (John, Jack and Pete) go out to the Sharky's in Randburg. While busy consuming their first beer, John goes to the rest rooms. In a moment of delinquency, he decides to scratch his initials on the back of the toilet door.

While he is busy vandalising the rest rooms, Jack and Pete, equally delinquent, decide to play a trick. They add a sleeping drug to John's unfinished beer. John comes back, takes a big swig and immediately falls into a deep sleep. Jack and Pete quickly settles the bill, drags the sleeping John to their car, and drive off to the Sharky's in Midrand. There they put the sleeping John back in the same seat, with an unfinished beer of the same level as it was when they left Randburg.

John wakes up, and still thinking that he is Randburg, tells Pete and Jack that he has scratched his initials on the back of the toilet door. Pete and Jack shake their heads deviously, not believing that John is telling the truth. To settle the issue, they decide to make a wager – they will go with John back into the rest rooms, and if John cannot produce the initials, then all drinks are on him.

Now let's pause everything at this point. Let's evaluate John's belief at this point in time. Can we say his belief, that he scratched his initials on to the toilet door at Sharky's, is true or false? That depends. If John's belief is that he scratched his initials on the door at Sharky's in Randburg, it is true. If John's belief is that he scratched his initials on the door of the Sharky's he is in right now, then it is false. But in John's head, that is exactly the very same belief. He has no inclination or clue that he is not where he thinks he is. Even though we know all the facts of the situation, we cannot determine the value of the belief in John's head - it has no deeper fact of the matter.

A similar problem with propositional attitudes is called the opacity problem. You cannot simply replace the objects of which the proposition is about, with different terms, even if they have the same numerical identity, and still maintain the value of the original attitude. Sherlock Holmes thinks Catherine's mother is the murderer. Sherlock Holmes do not think the countess of Devon is the murder. But Sherlock Holmes is unaware that Catherine's mother is the countess of Devon. Once again, there is no deeper factual meaning to Sherlock's Holmes' belief as to who the murderer is.

That is why beliefs, desires and propositional attitudes cannot be merely physical brain states. They do not exist independently of the bigger environment. They require contextual information, to which the holder of the belief is not necessarily privy to, to be evaluated.

Does this mean that it is impossible to provide an account for how we experience propositional attitudes using our brains? No, not at all. One way to overcome this is to adopt notional attitudes. Simply put, notional attitudes are those part of belief states that do exist in the brain. John, in Sharky's, have a notional attitude that he both scratched his initials on the bathroom in Randburg and in the bathroom of the Sharky's he is in right now. There is no psychological paradox here – we can easily put our shoes in John's and understand what he is thinking, even if we understand the evaluation of that thought to have different meanings in different contexts.

So now that we have this technical matter out of the way, we can re-evaluate Sean's claim. Yes, eliminative materialists acknowledge that beliefs have non-material existence – but they don't need beliefs to exist in this fashion in order for their view to be coherent.

It is also now obvious that 4 and 5 begs the question. These statements presuppose the reality of belief, without providing an account for how eliminative materialists consider belief ontology. It presupposes that our common sense attributions of beliefs are real and correct.

Paul Churchland addresses this same argument (f). In the Middle Ages, alchemists believed that living matter was separate from non-living matter due to the presence of vital forces. Now, if a modern chemist were to go back in time and stumble on an alchemist and claim that there is no such thing as vital forces, the alchemist could easily respond:

“Well, that's just silly. You can't claim that you don't have vital forces, because then you would be dead.”

Hopefully, I have shown here that eliminative materialism is not at all refuted by this line of attack. I also hoped to have shown that the ontology of belief is a more complex topic than what our common sense tells us it is.






f) Eliminative Materialism and the propositional attitudes:

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
The pearls of an Atheist Easter

I have an extended family that are Christian, and we are not talking the love they neighbour, forgive your mates and do the right thing, of the good old bishop Tutu kind. Read more...

155 comments 1465 views
Submitted by
Makate Rapulana
The colour of corruption

The word "corruption" is without doubt the most (ab)used and politicised word in South Africa.  Read more...

37 comments 771 views
Submitted by
Makate Rapulana
Who is watching the watchdog?

The late chief justice Pius Langa once averred: “I think judges should have a thick skin. We work in public, we give our judgments in public, and we give reasons for those judgments." Read more...

6 comments 258 views
Submitted by
Narian Chengiah Naidoo
A Civilized Society

Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. said, "Taxes are what we pay for a civilized society." Those words carry value and meaning only if "civilized" is understood as being good, happy and beneficial to all citizens. Read more...

8 comments 560 views
Submitted by
Rodney Bevan
SA under Zuma

Jacob Zuma, along with a handful of cronies has single handedly almost destroyed the country, its people and its economy. Read more...

38 comments 2964 views
Submitted by
The Fox 5366
Illegal Miners: Voiceless Prostit...

There's been a lot said about legalising prostitution so that prostitutes can be protected, receive healthcare and not be victimised. Read more...

11 comments 711 views

Jobs in Cape Town [change area]

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Escape winter, head to Mauritius

Escape winter by spending 7 nights in Mauritius' tropical bliss from R13 215 per person sharing. Includes return flights, airport transfers and accommodation. Book now! - shop online today

Get many eggs in one basket!

Gaming bundles: 2 Super Hits games for R99, 3 Disney games for R99 and more + exclusive accessory bundles only available on While stocks last. Shop now!

25% off bestselling books!

The Real Meal Revolution by Tim Noakes, Jeffrey Archer’s Be Careful What You Wish for, Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor E. Frank and many more titles. Shop now!

Up to 25% off electronics

Buy top electronics and save up to 25%. Such as’s 1# selling product the gobii eReader, Patriot X Porter flash drive, Asus Nexus 7” 3G tablet, Samsung Galaxy SIII, Lenovo G580 Notebook and many more. Shop now!

DStv HD PVR Decoder now R949

The DStv HD PVR Decoder has further revolutionised the television experience with lifelike viewing, sharper images, more vibrant colours and precision picture quality. Now R949, save R550. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

Up to 30% off appliances & homeware

Save up to 30% on appliances and homeware this Easter! Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now.

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Samsung Galaxy s4

Mobile, Cell Phones in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 24

Best bargain in big bay

Real Estate, Houses - Apartments for Sale in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

VW Golf 6, 1.6 Trendline (Excellent condition)

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25



E-mail Alerts The latest headlines in your inbox

RSS feeds News delivered really simply.

Mobile News24 on your mobile or PDA

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on your iPhone Get News24 headlines on your iPhone.

SMS Alerts Get breaking news stories via SMS.

Blogs Your opinion on you, me and everyone.

Calais Website keywords automated by OpenCalais.

Digital Media & Marketing Association
© 2014 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.