MyNews24 is a user-generated section of The stories here come from users.

Comments: 60
Article views: 4027
Latest Badges:

View all GaryWatson's badges.

The Diet wars are over!

28 March 2014, 14:06

For those that are connected to the right sources, it’s incredible how much robust evidence is emerging of just how wrong we’ve been about nutrition.   Everyday a new, well-designed, large-cohort, longitudinal study seems to confirm that the conventionally trained ‘low-fat, whole-grain’ dietary establishment is really an industry built on the sands of theory, hypothesis and vested agro-industry interests. 

From one day to next we learn that saturated fat cannot be linked to any increased health risks, dietary cholesterol has no bearing on blood cholesterol and that people eating 4000-calories a day on high-fat, low-carb Ketogenic diets are still losing weight.  I can attest to that last point, but yes n=1 is hardly power.  As more and more evidence emerges, it’s starting to get rather embarrassing for the Association of Dietetics and other detractors of the LCHF lifestyle.  For years, and in the last few years in particular, many registered dieticians have publicly and vociferously campaigned against a low-carb lifestyle; and now the public are asking on what basis did they do so?   Do they feel threatened by all this emerging science, like creationists do in the face of emerging evidence that the world is not in fact only 6000 years old, nor was it started by a man, a women and a talking snake.    

This is a serious issue.   If doctors held out against evidence in this manner they would potentially open themselves up to serious malpractice liability.  Imagine your doctor kept on prescribing a medication that had been on the market for years, but that recent studies had shown to have potentially serious side effects.  It happens.  If you ended up injured as a result of these side-effects, don’t you think a legal settlement of some sort would be a distinct possibility? Why would a health care provider such as a dietician, or a doctor giving dietary advice be any different?   I mean they are required by law (and oath) to provide their patients with the best & most-up-to-date care.  In fact it goes further, they are supposed to discuss various alternative treatments with their patients so that informed choices can be made.   So why do so many dieticians not do just that?  I know diabetics, who's doctors and dieticians have not discussed a LCHF diet with them, despite overwhelming evidence of the efficacy of reduced carb consumption on T2DM.  Why do they recommend eating plans that we now know are not supported by real science?  How can ‘professionals’ make such declarative statements about cause and effect in human nutrition, that when tested under intense scientific and independent scrutiny often turn out to be nonsense?  There is something wrong with an entire industry here; and perhaps this explains the vitriolic defensiveness of the establishment in recent years. 

I often wonder just on what basis the conventionally trained dietary community think they are able to denigrate and diminish the choices and experiences of the thousands and thousands of people who choose a LCHF lifestyle?   I wonder more every day, especially when it is becoming apparent, their theoretical frameworks are no more valid than conjecture we’re likely to hear at a Star-Trek convention?

I think the big LCHF mistake the ‘registered, conventionally trained dietetics community’ made was to underestimate the nature of the LCHF beast; and to overestimate their perceived authority on nutritional matters in today’s instant access technological age. 

By the LCHF beast, I mean the contrarian sub-culture that defines the low carb community.  Low carb has always been a kind of anti-establishment movement; scorning the now-defunct food pyramid by eating it upside down.   To eat low-carb, one had to go against the grain (yes..I know); you had to adopt a middle-finger attitude to what the good doctors (and politicians who paid the good doctors, who were paid by the agro-industrial complex lobbyists) told us to eat.

Yet one of the consequences of this contrarian approach meant you had to take a keen and personally accountable interest in your diet.   In other words RD’s, LCHFers tend to actually care very deeply about their health.  Embarking on a blind swim against the nutritional current (and primarily through self-experimentation) would seem like madness; yet when people found that they lost weight, felt great, performed better at work and on the sports field, had more energy and reported an improved sense of control in their lives, they really started to question the authority of the so-called nutritional experts.  Scepticism and distrust grew into a full-blown rebellion.  People grew, and still are, justifiably angry at learning that most of what they were told by people calling themselves 'experts' (and are still being told) is actually complete bollocks.   On top of it, we have an industry hell bent on telling us that our overwhelmingly positive experiences (and the emerging evidence) are all wrong.  No wonder this LCHF revolution took on almost evangelical proportions.  The parallels between dogma and evidence are numerous, and like all other 'earth revolves around the sun' moments, yours is the choice of what side of history you find yourself on. 

Yes, it must be tough watching everything you thought you knew with such certainty being eroded by the relentless pursuit of truth that is the scientific method.    

LCHFers probably research diets and the concomitant emerging evidence far more than any other dietary lifestyle group does.  The foundation of the LCHF movement is Evidence. It had to be.  Personal experience and robust science.  It’s always been the only tool the LCHFers had in the Diet Wars all these years – the fact that it works, and works better than anything else, emboldened a public rebellion against the bullshit were told is good for us.   If new evidence emerged that saturated fat was in fact bad for you, LCHF numbers would plummet. because LCHFers take such a keen interest in evidence.  Each day, as the evidence mounts, more and more people join the fight.   

It is hardly surprising then that the old model of a subservient client, gullibly following the advice of their registered dietician doesn’t work anymore - especially not for someone with a real interest in the truth and an internet connection.   

As with everything I write, I always think it best for the reader to take what I say with a healthy dose of scepticism.  That only leads to more robust knowledge in society as a whole.   Rather read additional info for yourself – like Joanna Blythman’s opinion on why almost everything you have ever been told about unhealthy food is wrong.  I’m quite sure you’ll find that most of what I have to say makes sense, and even if you don't who cares at least we're creating knowledge.

All the best

DISCLOSURE:  I am 100% committed to a LCHF lifestyle.   I have lost 15kg in 5 months, every single measure of disease risk (LDL, HDL. Triglycerides, Blood pressure, etc.) has improved markedly.  I eat as much as I want to when I feel like it, no portion control, never count calories and I haven’t been hungry in 5 months.  I also run marathons on LCHF – so no, I don’t believe ‘you need carbs’ to run marathons – and at 15kg lighter you can imagine how much easier (and faster) running is.

Disclaimer: All articles and letters published on MyNews24 have been independently written by members of News24's community. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Submitted by
Thandolwethu Mene
Stop the right-wing boycott of Sp...

We all need to stop this racist nonsense before we reach a point of no return to self destruction. Because no matter how you look at it, we all lose. Read more...

0 comments 1223 views
Submitted by
Julian Edward Frost
The ANC can't and won't self-corr...

Until the ANC can acknowledge where it got it wrong and take steps to rectify, it will remain on a downward spiral and will ultimately dissolve. Read more...

0 comments 201 views
Submitted by
Jan Badenhorst
What can I study without matric?

Some people still think you cannot further your education if you don't have a matric certificate. They are wrong. You have many choices. Read more...

0 comments 186 views
Submitted by
No Ohno
GM: The big business exodus is st...

No matter how anyone spins it, the departure of General Motors is a huge loss for SA, huge investment loss, and will definitely be a huge employment loss. Read more...

0 comments 392 views
Submitted by
Lisa Marcelle Hold
Mr Zuma, do you know how it feels...

Mr Zuma, do you know how it feels to worry about how you are going to feed your wife (sorry wives) and children when you only have R150.00 in your account on the 20th of the month? Read more...

0 comments 1784 views


E-mail Alerts The latest headlines in your inbox

RSS feeds News delivered really simply.

Mobile News24 on your mobile or PDA

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

SMS Alerts Get breaking news stories via SMS.

TV Get us in your home, on your television.

Interactive Advertising Bureau
© 2017 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.