News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Arthur Goldstuck Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Food
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
18-23°C

Durban:
24-33°C

Johannesburg:
15-25°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 9.6500
Rand/£ 14.6500
Rand/€ 13.2300
Gold/oz $856.35
Gold Mining 2290.80
+0.59%
All-share index 22241.44
-2.10%
 
Subscribe and win!
Become a Women24 subscriber and get in line to WIN, WIN, WIN!

 
Afrikaans
English
 

The valve-radio days
01/02/2008 11:24  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.

Arthur Goldstuck

Ever wonder why, well into the 21st Century, your internet experience is so frustrating? Why your connection so often falls over or slows to a crawl? Why websites refuse to open or take forever to arrive? Why online services seldom deliver the seamless processes they promise? Why it can be so difficult or so expensive to get a connection when you're away from home base - even in the most connected cities in the world?

The answer is deceptively simple: We are still in the valve-radio days of the internet.

Just as, in the early days of radio, you first had to warm up the valves before you could receive a signal, so you still have to wait for a computer to start up before you can even begin to negotiate your connection to the internet.

Just as the first Marconi radios needed a Marconi-trained and Marconi-employed operator to make them work, so you often need a Helpdesk or support hotline at your Internet Service Provider to sort out the most basic of connectivity issues.

The ideal - and the future promise - is that accessing the internet should be as simple as listening to radio.

A spotty teenager

Switch it on, and it's on. Select a site, and you're on the site. Click on an online video, and you begin watching it, in a high quality transmission with no interruptions. Turn it off, and it's off. No waiting until the computer tells you it's safe to unplug a device; no loss or corruption of files when the power suddenly goes.

The reality is that personal computers as we know them today are less than 30-years-old (give or take a few years of the Apple Macintosh), and the commercial internet no more than 15-years-old. The first commercial activity on the internet was allowed in 1993, and its first graphic interface appeared in 1994, designed by a student.

In the broad sweep of communications history, the internet is still young - a spotty teenager that thinks it has all the answers, but still needs to go round the block a few times.

Continuing the radio metaphor, we are still in the equivalent of the early 1930s, before the invention of FM. Until then, fledgling broadcasters were stuck with AM, a low-power, low-quality signal. Many of its users associated radio with indistinct voices and the hiss and crackle of static underlying their broadcast music.

This is where we are with the internet today.

The good news is that 1935 is almost around the corner. The equivalent of FM, namely high-power, high-quality broadband signals that can be received over a long distance, is almost with us. Why do you think they call it wireless? For our grandparents, "the wireless" was also a revolution.

But "almost here" is still a long time in the transition from adolescence to adulthood.

Broadband held hostage

First, we have to experience the false promise of the next generation of broadband technologies and service providers. Something called WiMAX will threaten to unseat something called 3G as a dominant wireless broadband technology. But both are merely placeholders for future broadband technologies jointly lumped under the label of 4G.

Right now, broadband in South Africa is held hostage by Telkom's control of the single undersea cable network connecting this part of Africa to the world. Starting this year, a number of alternatives will start snaking their way across the seabed to the backbones of global telecommunications. And, if the regulatory authorities do their job, any number of service providers will be slicing and dicing consumers' options of taking advantage of those cables.

We are probably five to ten years away from that FM stage of signal evolution. Meanwhile, settle back and try to tolerate the hiss and crackle of the early 21st Century internet.

  • Arthur Goldstuck is an award-winning author and journalist, and is managing director of World Wide Worx, which leads research into internet and mobile communications in South Africa. Visit his urban legends blog at http://thoselegends.blogspot.com and his business blog at http://www.thebigchange.com

    Send your comments to Arthur.

    Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

    - News24



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


  •  
         
      Goodness Athur is smoking too I.T...
    01/02/2008 12:18
    Arthur what have you been smoking?????all this difficult Information Technology stuff...do you really expect the ordinary News 24 reader to understand your column..come down to our level please. - Confused
     
      Great perspective
    01/02/2008 12:34
    Thank you Arthur, and I thoroughly enjoyed your radio analogies. Although I enjoyed the "olden days" (sans computers and cellphones) more with it's more leisurely pace, we will probably look back in 20 years time from now nodding in sympathy at the way we acquired our information in 2008 via archaic things called broadband and web browsers. Then again, a lot of factors could yet cause technology to slow down too. Maybe we'll even dust off those valve-radio's in our garages soon... - Jaco
     
      IEEE Article
    01/02/2008 12:47
    Great article. If you belong to the IEEE, read the article on pg 8 in the October 2006 communication magazine entitled: "THE NEXT GENERATION NETWORK AND WHY WE?LL NEVER SEE IT" BY G. KEITH CAMBRON,PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER ? AT&T LABS, INC. - Justin
     
      Only here in darkest Telkom
    01/02/2008 13:12
    There is only one reference to the real cause of our "valve radio days" in the article - that is Telkom holding broadband hostage. Fact is, the infrastructure has been in place to supply more and faster bandwidth for a long time, but for reasons known only to those highly-paid executives in charge of Telkom who took a national asset and have made it worthless - they can't even sell it. They have put the country back at least 20 years - similar to Eskom. Otherwise a great article. - Dave
     
      Brillig Arthur,
    01/02/2008 13:38
    an excellent article. By the way, Dave, have a look at who is on the Telkom Board of Directors. It is not about accessability or better technology - all they are interested in is profit. For more detail on how the puplic is being done over, go to http://www.hellkom.co.za/ - saliem
     
      Wimax will suck in future
    01/02/2008 13:56
    Wimax is such a wasteful technology. Its speed and bandwidth will be surpassed by the next generation Mobile networks. The only problem is that Wimax is gobbling up valuable frequency ranges required by the next gen mobile networks. Did you know that in Wimax, Out of 1024 subcarriers, 184 is wasted on guards, 280 is wasted on pilot subcarriers, which means that only 560 is available for data! HSPA also has a 7-10db coverage advantage over Wimax. 16d and 16e are also incompatible! - dude
     
      Milking us
    01/02/2008 13:58
    Its computer manufacturers, Telco companies that hold technology back. They bring out new pcs, new line speeds all the time that are a little faster than the previous generation, they milk the profit from the sales then give us a little more pc speed, and we buy again. We could be years ahead of ourselves if we got rid of the salesmen and let the inventors go mad providing us with the best in technological breakthroughs. Instead we wait for the likes of Intel and Telkom to spoon feed us. - Jim
     
      Oh, I see.
    01/02/2008 14:03
    So, you have the luxury of browsing internet all day? You are a lucky fish, we hardly have electricity for 2 consecutive hours here. I am told there is some load-shedding going on and my neighbour just told me that apparently we must switch off our geysers. - Sello
     
      Patent nonsense.
    01/02/2008 14:05
    Arthur, indeed what are you smoking, or are you on Telkom's payroll. The broadband bandwidth limits imposed by service providers Telkom et al are artificial and have nothing to do with physical constraints here in SA, and what about the exorbitant costs? You didn't even touch on this. Hell, MWeb even throttled my dial-up after they took over Tiscali, and shut down the cache server which speeded things up to no end. You're too embedded in the industry Arthur to be truly objective. - manicm
     
      "Valve radio days?"
    01/02/2008 14:16
    Well during those "valve radio days" radio amateur operators still sent signals that spanned the globe. The development of both radio and wireless technology known in the commercial world today can be attributed to some extent on the experimentation of said amateurs. Professional people doing it for fun and for free. Evolution takes time so we will hang in there and wait. What else do we have to do, this is Africa after all. For more info on amateur radio look up the South African Radio League - Kevin
     
      The valve-radio days
    01/02/2008 14:20
    I have owned a valve radio many, many years ago so I related very well to this story. A most enjoyable article. A note to "confused" if you couldn't understand this article, I am afraid a computer is way over your head. - Danie
     
      Our cellphone operators are in it too they have formed a Cartel
    01/02/2008 14:25
    . Cell C has all these Gimmicks such as HAMMER HAMMER, WOZA WEEKEND,ETC.They use these gimmicks to cover up the fact that their products are useless, the service offered is worse than eskom it takes you 15-30 minutes to get through to their call centre, and then when you do speak to someone they are not helpful at all, they just refer you to someone else. If you are not a Cell C customer don't make the same mistake I made I think relocating to Zim is better option Than being a Cell C customer.T - Gilbert
     
      Consumer
    01/02/2008 15:23
    Large companies that provide goods to consumers should really broaden their views by looking at the international community. They are so narrow minded and profit driven that they try to sell their products to a very small percentage of the market at a highly inflated price. It's simple: Sell 10 items for R100 or sell R100 items for R10. You still make the same profits, but by doing the latter the consumers win as well. - Johan
     
      Someone is smoking cables, but is it not Arthur
    01/02/2008 15:38
    Manicm, you really need to read what Arthur wrote. He clearly blames Telkom for much of this lack of development. However, Telkom is not the only bottle neck. Manufacturers, software producers, etc are keen to cash in, and end up giving you bits by bits which ends up clogging your computer. If you install McAfee and uninstall, see what happens to Outlook. Microsoft is another culprit, not to mention the service providers in this country and as mentioned, the cellular networks - Len
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     
     
     


    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Jobs
    Financial Manager (CA) SA
    South Africa
    Accounting / Finance / Auditing
    Financial Manager (CA) SA
    South Africa
    Accounting / Finance / Auditing
    Audit Manager (Chartered Accountant)
    South Africa
    Accounting / Finance / Auditing
    Senior C# Developer
    Gauteng - Centurion
    IT / Telecomms
    Tester
    Gauteng - Centurion
    IT / Telecomms
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
    Car Servicing & Repair
    Win up to R1000 free!