News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Chris Moerdyk Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
News24 turns 10
US Elections
Zimbabwe
Xenophobia
Aids Focus
Power Crisis
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Currie Cup game
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
15-21°C

Durban:
17-25°C

Johannesburg:
9-26°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 8.8200
Rand/£ 15.3200
Rand/€ 12.0400
Gold/oz $880.95
Gold Mining 1569.22
-1.87%
All-share index 21133.94
+0.53%
 
House prices getting you down?
Register with Property24 today and buy an affordable online Sold Price Index (SPI) report to find out what other houses in your area have sold for.

 
Afrikaans
English
 

No 'I' in teamwork...
22/07/2008 08:36  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.

Chris Moerdyk

Remember that old joke about business partners? Fellow on the phone says "Sorry my partner can't come to the phone, he's tied up right now... I always tie him up when I go out..."

Partnerships are a lot more serious these days and on a far more massive scale. Added value strategic alliances. Teamwork at top level.

But, like many other life skills, such as dealing with bank managers and preventing plumbers from helping themselves to your life savings by the simple extraction of a foreign object from a U-Bend, our schools don't teach kids about partnerships or teamwork.

In fact, they just confuse the daylights out of them.

Picture the scene. There's little Kobus sitting in grade five and battling with a spelling test. No problem, he just leans over to have a look at what Sipho is doing.

Their teacher comes screaming across the classroom like a banshee, yelling at Kobus to stop his dirty low-down cheating and to do his test by himself.

Three hours later they are on the soccer field and there's little Kobus flying down the wing with the ball and Sipho at centre forward pleading with him to pass. Kobus decides to go it alone and cuts in towards the goal. He falls over his feet, loses the ball and the opposition scores.

Then, the same teacher who blitzed him only hours earlier for trying to team up with Sipho on the spelling test, chews his ear off for going it alone when he should have passed the ball to Sipho.

By nightfall poor little Kobus is so confused he wets his bed and declares jihad on all teachers.

Musical chairs

It all reminds him of his fifth birthday party when he and eight of his buddies were persuaded by the clown his mom hired, to play musical chairs. Nine of them started with only eight chairs and one by one they were eliminated and the number of chairs reduced.

Fat Louis had won that game and poor little Kobus couldn't understand the point. All nine of them were supposed to be having fun at his party, he thought. And all that game did was make eight of them very unhappy while that smug little so-and-so, Louis, was the only one with a smile on his face.

Surely, thought Kobus, it would have been a lot more fun if there had only been one chair and the game was to see how many kids could all get onto it at the same time. Wasn't that the team work adults kept going on about?

So, it is no surprise that kids leave school with a completely warped idea of partnerships and teamwork. They're taught about the principles but not about the side effects.

Like competition. Kids are told that this is something in business that brings out the best in products. But, they're not taught that competition also brings out the worst in people.

There is no doubt that when the children of today leave school and go to university or start out on their careers, they are going to be continuously reminded by lecturers and managers that life is all about pulling together. About teamwork.

It beats me how kids can be expected to believe in sharing when they have been so thoroughly confused.

It is small wonder that when you look at all the world's wars and other problems you find that it all boils down to mankind's instinctive inability to share.

Send your comments to Chris.

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

- News24



What is this?
Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
 
News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


 
     
  Kobus
22/07/2008 09:06
Should stop being such a wimp and realise that different responses and strategies are required for different situations. Some situations require teamwork and others require that you help yourself. In the situations above he should try using his brain to determine what is appropriate. - veritas
 
  I think the columnist has a warped idea of teamwork
22/07/2008 09:12
Even challenged little Cobus would understand the differences between the situations. - kwk
 
  What absolute nonsense!!!
22/07/2008 09:16
When we were at school we worked alone, did projects on our own etc etc. Team sports taught us team work but that was it. These days the stronger students are teamed up with the weaker students, their marks on their reports are not just reflecting their last exam results, its a reflection of their work done during the term/year and most of that is spent dragging along the weaker pupil or doing all the work and somebody else gets half the credit. New age team work - the strong are handicapped. - Karen
 
  Paradoxical
22/07/2008 09:19
There is an "I" in the word win! It's about coaching (the critical skill lacking in today's business environment), and ensuring that teams win! What or who creates winning teams? - GKT
 
  Teamwork verses Cheating
22/07/2008 09:42
Strange, this is exactly how we grew up in my day and I don't have a warped sense of sharing. It's statements like these that are resulting in the kids of today not being able to think for themselves and make rational decisions. In my day you knew when you had to work alone and when to work as a team. Especially if you were TOLD not to look at somebody else?s answers, that?s called cheating, not teamwork. - KG
 
  I liked it
22/07/2008 09:45
Thanks for writing the article, I liked. - A Non-e-moose
 
  Utter rubbish...
22/07/2008 09:49
Chris, you don't get it at all. The ability to master your own skils, work alone and then team as appropriate to circumstance is what Kobus is learning. He'll end up with a sound sense of what behaviour to deploy and when... he'll learn how to surround himself with those who will add value and win and avoid those who won't. He'll have confidence in his own abilities and how to master them. Somehow Chris, you missed it all... - Alex
 
  An Education?
22/07/2008 09:49
I think Chris has hit on a very important point: namely, that educators are simply adults, educated to a point, uncritised by their students, sometimes ignorantly opinionated, and for the most part, underpaid, marginalised, confused, and irresponsible. Kobus is a kid. They really don't know these things, they're in school to learn about these situations, and the appropriate responses, etc. - CrisisOfFaith
 
  sharing
22/07/2008 09:53
You're right sharing is so simple; look at marriage: What's hers is hers and what's your's is also hers. Simple as long as she does what you tell her? - infoguru
 
  Another scenario & fact of life in the new SA
22/07/2008 09:55
Work situation where an AA employee is assigned to you to train. You train the person, then you are retrenched & the AA employee takes over. Teamwork? NO! Since 1994 it is everyone for themselves and is a matter of survival. The symptom of renewed reverse rasism. - Matrix
 
  Life Orientation, Moerdyk - ever heard of it?
22/07/2008 09:57
Not only are children being taught essential life skills through this compulsory subject at school, it is also mandatory nowadays for University admission. I'm surprised you haven't heard of it. But then, that's another topic kids are being taught nowadays - research. - Graham
 
  @GKT, agreed.
22/07/2008 10:01
Strong leaders make for a strong team. Team members will follow a strong leader. Also agree with Karen. When you got to work, you work to get an income to sustain yourself and dependants. It is NOT the team that rewards & remunerates you. Business dictates that YOU MUST HAVE THE COMPETENCY to employable. You contribute to the team because of your skill, not because the team has your skill. Everyone in a team also have to contribute to make the project succeed. Teamwork is a myth. - Matrix
 
  @ Veritas
22/07/2008 10:02
Perfectly correct, but bulldust would have sounded so much better. Chris is there no body part on you that you can play with instead of writing such uninspired hogwash? - Chris
 
  And teachers are to blame?
22/07/2008 10:08
Wow, teachers 'blitz' their students, yelling like banshees? And they're 'educated to a point, uncritised by their students, sometimes ignorantly opinionated, and for the most part, underpaid, marginalised, confused, and irresponsible'? I guess neither of you have ever been a teacher then... Convenient to blame teachers, yes, when your children spend more time with us in a day than they ever will with you. - Les
 
  Both sides buttered
22/07/2008 10:10
All our measurements for reward are based on individual performance, exams, school projects, performance appraisals. The team components are completely left out or minute incomparison to the individual measures. If you want team work then reward team performance equally or over individual contribution; which sounds like communism. I'm a liberal socialist, or pragmatic socialist AND believe individualism is ultimately the only workable ideal. Teamwork is a bullsh*t word used by people with agendas - Lou
 
  NO 'I' IN TEAM
22/07/2008 10:14
Chris - there's no fairness in teamwork. Management is all for teamwork - but when it comes to salary increases only the management gets a huge slice of the pie and the rest of workforce must be humble about the scraps they get. So no to TEAMWORK! Management do your own work! - ANTI-TEAMPLAYER
 
  Missing the Point
22/07/2008 10:31
This article was not about Team Work but about Partnerships. Being able to work together with one or more partners. Can you contribute positively and expect your partner/s to do the same as team players. Or did we not acquire that skill at school. - Johnny
 
  There is no I in team...
22/07/2008 10:39
...but there is a M and an E. - foobar
 
  No 'I' in teamwork
22/07/2008 10:46
but there is a 'm' and an 'e' (me) - Mark
 
  Jihad??
22/07/2008 10:46
Again you just had to insult religion, because of your lack of it?? What an utter rubbish column. I get the feeling Chris was the "poor bullied snotty" kid on the playground, afraid to stand up to Fat Louis. Hating his parents for inviting Fat Louis to the party. Correct, teamwork starts in the home just as all other morals and civilities are taught by our parents...at home. Go see a therapist before you go postal on your colleaugues, Chris! - gummibear
 
  TEAMWORK
22/07/2008 11:15
It is patently clear from most of the infantile comments that the majority of those commenting haven't spent time within a team environment and most males continue to think with the wrong head, relying on their bloated egos. Gents - wake, zip up and join the future...you've got a long way to catch up! - Teambuilder
 
  Survivor's guilt...
22/07/2008 11:41
Why is there this view that being a winner at the cost of someone else is a bad thing? That's the way the world works. I think this politically correct idea of dragging the losers up and the winners down is helping nobody; all it's achieving is creating this broad gray swath of contemptible mediocrity in our society. The only things those children will be good for, are civil service and middle management. The Dilbert principle applies: Everyone rises to their own level of incompetence. - Memetix
 
  Respect and responsibility
22/07/2008 12:55
The issues you raise are not about teamwork vs the individual. They are about respect and responsibility. Respect for what belongs to others (ie not trying to steal their hard work) and respecting the ability of others (ie trusting the other to pass the ball to him). Responsibility to do what we need to do. Yes, our education does need to do more to teach our kids about respect and responsibility, but I also think much of the problem lies with parents who fail in their responsibilities too... - L Savage
 
     
This comments facility is now closed.
 
VEHICLE SEARCH
TOYOTA
2003
Carri 1300 P-Van
R51754
FORD
2000
Bantam 1600 PU MY92
R44990
LAND ROVER
2005
Discovery 3 4.4 V8 SE 4x4 AT
R399570
CITROEN
2003
Picasso SX 1.6 MPV
R78700
RENAULT
2004
SCENIC 2.0 DYNAMIQUE
R69900
BMW
2005
320i E90
R199000
BMW
2008
325i SPORT (E90)
R214474
NISSAN
2007
Hardbody 2700D Dsl PU
R95990
FORD
2006
Ranger 2.5 TD Hi-Trail XL Super Cab Dsl
R146800

 

About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

Back to top
 Sponsored links
Life Insurance
Car Insurance
UK Lottery
First for Women
Your Homeloan
Bid or Buy
Medical Aid
Education
SA TV Online
Best Car Deals
Loans & Credit Cards
Compare Quotes
Life Insurance for Women
Car Servicing & Repair
Piggs Peak Casino