News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Chris Moerdyk Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Food
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
18-23°C

Durban:
24-33°C

Johannesburg:
15-25°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 9.6600
Rand/£ 14.6900
Rand/€ 13.2400
Gold/oz $853.93
Gold Mining 2290.80
+0.59%
All-share index 22241.44
-2.10%
 
Subscribe and win!
Become a Women24 subscriber and get in line to WIN, WIN, WIN!

 
Afrikaans
English
 

Making money by selling fear
13/10/2008 12:40  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.

Chris Moerdyk

Now we've all heard a lot about victims of crime. In fact, most of us are victims of crime. But, I'm getting the feeling that I'm a victim of security.

I am paying out so much money to all sorts of people to protect me from being robbed that I am almost at the point where I have nothing left of which to be robbed.

It all started when we moved into a Sandton suburb 18 years or so ago and someone suggested that we should create this superblock thing in which residents coughed up a modest monthly sum to build a police station, buy a few police cars and organise accommodation for the additional constabulary that would come our way.

Up till then I stupidly thought that was what I was paying taxes for.

Then someone, whose brother-in-law was probably in the fencing business, suggested that if we really and truly wanted to make sure that we would be safe and sound we should put a great big fence around the neighbourhood.

More money down the drain as we had to go to court to stop the municipality from tearing it down.

Then came the suggestion that if we wanted to be really, really, REALLY safe and sound we should pay the security company that manned the booms to stick radio transmitters and panic buttons in our houses, plaster signs on our walls and have three or four cars patrol the neighbourhood.

After which my mother-in-law was mugged at gunpoint right outside our house in broad daylight and it took those same patrol cars 20 minutes to drive roughly 600m to our house. Setting what must be a world record for rapid response.

A victim of security

But, undaunted by this complete lack of security when we really needed it, someone suggested that as we were now really, really safe in our houses we should start looking at out safety when we popped down to the local shops to pick up the paper, a loaf of bread and a litre of milk.

So, they got a whole lot of unemployed people, swore them in as "car guards", gave them t-shirts and told them to look after our cars in exchange for tips.

Then it dawned on me that I was well and truly a victim of security. I was being had.

The shopkeepers were telling me that they not only wanted my custom, my money but that they were going to contribute precisely sod-all to ensuring that I could do all this in relative safety.

Retailers, hotel owners, parking garage operators should stop making security on their premises our problem. I say, "if you want our patronage then you are going to have to start assuring us that our cars are not going to get ripped off. YOU are going to have to start paying those t-shirted fellows to look after our cars."

Surely, it is not unreasonable to expect shopkeepers or their landlords to do something about the safety of their customers and not just pass the buck? In Cape Town a while back, I pulled in to the parking lot of a wonderful hotel with equally wonderful service. Everything absolutely perfect.

Except that as I drove in to the parking lot there was a huge sign telling me that if I wanted to be fool enough to park my car there then I should not even dream about whinging if it got broken in to, damaged or stolen.

Well, that's how I read it. What it actually said was that standard; "Management bears no responsibility for loss or theft etc."

On the basis that first impressions are lasting impressions - despite the fact that this was a great hotel - that first impression teed me off no end.

Hopefully, as South Africa moves closer to a free market economy and competition begins to bite we will start seeing some really creative marketing from hotels, shopping centres and parking garages.

Good news

Creative marketing in the form of big signs that say: "Welcome, you car is quite safe with us."

And perhaps; "Please don't tip the parking lot guards, we pay them fat salaries to look after your car."

It's all a huge marketing opportunity when you think about it. Great customer service.

I'm happy to say it has sort of started already. On a visit to Franschhoek a few weeks ago, I was delighted to see notices pasted in all the shops asking visitors not to pay car guards. "Your car is perfectly safe in our streets - please don't turn our people into beggars."

Apparently members of the Franschhoek business community have taken all those self-appointed car guards and are trying to provide them skills and job opportunities.

Now that really is good news. It makes me feel that I am being welcomed and not just warned to keep my trap shut if something goes wrong.

Send your comments to Chris.

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

- News24



What is this?
Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
 
News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


 
     
  ditto
13/10/2008 13:01
and that is exactly how the security industry became a multi million rand business. and guess what, u can never hold them responsible if someone breaks into ur house. so what are they getting paid for? - ike
 
  Liability cannot be an empty word
13/10/2008 13:10
I totally agree with Chris. More than that, how can so many shopping centers, hotels and other public facilities charge a parking fee (sometimes an expensive one) and still displaying signs warning you that they are not liable for theft, fire, damage, whatsoever, of your vehicle??? Simply outrageous! - Antonio Pina
 
  Well done...
13/10/2008 13:18
Chris for president... Going where our esteemed leaders fear to go... - Clayton
 
  I hear you
13/10/2008 13:18
Plus all the other stuff - Insurance costs, personal security costs, medical aid, life insurance and disability, school fees, text books, I could go on... Most of which should be covered by the taxes I pay. So half my salary to tax, the other half of my salary to the above. Its got so - I have to tip the car guards by credit card. - Sandra
 
  Hear hear!!!
13/10/2008 13:18
I have been doing this for a while now. I refuse to pay for security at a parkinglot... The idea started when I got to a parking area and a guard refused to take a tip... "Sorry sir I can not take your money i am being paid to be here..." If I hade not moved out of the area I would still be a regular at that specific mall. Thank you to all the business owners that look after their customers... - Werner
 
  Security costs
13/10/2008 13:20
Chris - it is high time that the community brought shopping centres etc to book on this. We make their businesses successful and pay heavily to park whilst we do so. latest statement from a supermarket robbed for the third time in as many years (the gang appear to diarise them for October) - it's too expensive to put film in our CCTV cameras! The staff recognise the perpetrators - if only our detectives had footage! Soon I will start to name and shame shopping centres who do not take action - Judith Taylor
 
  I agree!!
13/10/2008 13:20
Yip! You have said it all! We have friends in the security industry. Wealthy beyond words - because of crime. - Anna-marie Joubert
 
  Paid parking
13/10/2008 13:26
I also believe that the psychological side of crime is harder to defeat than the actual physical crime. It's called trauma... However, with regards to the parking at Hotels and other paid for parking spots, I do believe the law should provide some assistance to protect you even if some sign reads that management are not responsible for theft or any loss, especially after you paid for the spot. - ElectroMan
 
  Glad somebody sees it the same as me
13/10/2008 13:30
I agree. The same applies to insurance companies. They always concentrate on the bad side of life getting out of pay-outs due to forever changing technical wording. the person how pays a car guard, pays to little tax! - Derick
 
  just living in fear
13/10/2008 13:32
i agree chris, it cost so much to protect oneself that you eventually have nothing to protect bcos you have used all the money for protection - prinze
 
  How about
13/10/2008 13:42
Equally annoying is the outrageous parking fees some 'shopping malls' charge. If I drive 50km there and spend an afternoon spending wads of my money I can't help but feel ripped of if I'm charged R25 just to park there. Really doesn't make me feel very welcome. (Referring to Canal Walk by the way) - Andre
 
  victim of security
13/10/2008 13:45
i hear you chris. insurance companies have now also gotten onto this bandwagon - you can buy life or disability insurance from most anyone - just in case something happens to you - laverne
 
  stop 'tipping' them
13/10/2008 13:45
The people that give car guards R5 or R10 to 'look after' their car while they pop in and out for a loaf of bread are as much to blame. Car guards are glorified beggars. You really believe that for an average of R10 an uneducated person is going to put himself in danger if an armed person is stealing your car? I don't think so. - Terra
 
  Agree
13/10/2008 13:49
Every square inch in CT is covered by a car guard. Even in the remotest of places. Quite honestly I am getting highly p*ssed off. I have travelled extensively and never seen anything like it. Say NO! - Agree
 
  What really gets to me...
13/10/2008 13:49
is having to pay 'car guards' out of fear...I'm talking about the unofficial, suspicious car guards who adopt any area and if you don't pay them it's quite possible they will arrange for your car to be stolen. Just the other night we saw from a restaurant balcony as they scrambled around a 'client'; then, a short while later the window had been smashed, alarm blaring, and suddenly not one of the 10-20 'car guards' who constantly fight to 'watch' people's cars there was anywhere to be seen! - dh
 
  Simple security System
13/10/2008 13:55
I have seen many houses in the surbub where i live with not even a fence,yet they've never been burgled.I mean you get out of the house straight on to the street.On the other hand i've seen houses with very high security being burgled. - Godfrey
 
  Tipping Car Guards...
13/10/2008 13:57
What for? I pay a fortune for insurance and vehicle tracking. Why should I now have to pay someone to watch my car while I am shopping? Are they really a deterrent to criminals? I think not. - BigGC
 
  Canal Walk
13/10/2008 14:01
Andre, get 1.5 hours off at canal walk by stamping your ticket at Pick & Pay, or do what I do, follow the car in front of me out when im expected to pay more than R6 for parking. I'd rather steal from them than letting them rip me off... - Shani
 
  Thats it,
13/10/2008 14:02
I love South Africans. You always bring humour to everything. I found this story very funny but true. - Indy
 
  It's a complex life
13/10/2008 14:07
10 years ago, I took a look at Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, noted that 'safety/security' was one of the foundations and moved into a complex with 24-hour guarding. Cancelled my householder's insurance 5 years ago (after finding in the small print that they paid out 0NE THIRD only on electronics items (what gets stolen?)and have saved a packet. No problems ever.PS - Question to ponder: why don't car guards ever go on strike? - doug
 
  We SA'ns are so gullible.
13/10/2008 14:14
The security companies probably pay the criminals. Imagine govt actually get crime under control: Thousands of bankrupt security firms! Suppose all and sundry will then bitch about our stupid govt robbing jobs from the poor! I have no 6ft fences, no alarm, no vicious dogs, no security company looking after my property. On the other hand, maybe I am just lucky to stay in a city where the police actually do their job. - TB
 
  Andre
13/10/2008 14:17
i agree with you fully as far as Canal Walk is concerned. there parking tariffs are outrageous. i feel that if you go to a restaurant or movies they should subsidise your parking ticket as you are supporting them. i sometimes wish i could just have one days parking fees, i am sure i would beable to do a world cruise with the money have still have some left over. - just me
 
  Paying for fear
13/10/2008 14:23
I thought I was the only one who felt the same. Security companies are making fortunes out of our fear. - Lungig
 
  I refuse to be gullible
13/10/2008 14:33
Most companies in the security industry are responsible for selling fear in this country. Yes, there is crime but sometimes it is exaggerated because it is such a sensitive, political and personal thing, and it is easy to play on people's fears.I take sensible precautions when it comes to safety, but I don't have an alarm and all these security gadgets and subscriptions sold to people.I refuse to live in fear.I don't want to worry about something that might never happen. - mkabayi
 
  Alarms
13/10/2008 14:34
Phoned my insurance company to ask if I can get discount because I have alarm/armed response at my house. Can save about R9 a month on the premium, but if they break in and I had forgotten to set the alarm, they don't pay out. I told them what they can do with their R9... - Elmar Matthee
 
  AGREE, AGREE, AGREE, and by the way ...
13/10/2008 14:42
While we're on this subject. The idea of "selling fear" in any form is just wrong. It's called exploitation. I despise the same commercials coming from life insurance, medical aids, death/funeral plan ads. etc. It's all based on fear. Fear can be a terrible product in the hands of greedy capitalists ... - White_African
 
  Security guards
13/10/2008 14:43
Something I find hilariously illogical is the fact that security guards at complexes and boom gates are paid a measly salary. These are the people who are supposed to be protecting us. I want these guys to earn 10 grand a month and be highly skilled. Otherwise, what's stopping them letting in criminals or even assisting them? Most security guards i see can barely speak english or even write properly. They are basically only useful when you forget your remote at home. - gazmic
 
  The thing is
13/10/2008 14:57
I despise the businesses who charges you for parking or do not want to share responsibility for your vehicles safety. Unnecessary 'car guards' come a close second - however I cannot help but feel that if I see the same guy on the same spot week after week come rain or shine that perhaps he's at least trying to put a honest day of work in. I'm privileged compared to that guy and I would rather give him my five bucks than pay through my neck for parking at a mall. - Andre again
 
  Fear created by corporates - Tracker
13/10/2008 16:06
Isn't it funny how Tracker plays both sides of the coin. Next time listen carefully to their advert on TV, stamping out theft. Why stop car theft if it is your income. It's all about kick-backs from insurance companies and having your money in their bank accounts. Insurance companies do stats on deaths, motor accidents, disabilities. Actuaries calculate the risk of you claiming, create the fear, ask you a huge premium and there you have it. A nice profit! Who owns the high buildings in JHB CBD? - Derick again
 
     
This comments facility is now closed.
 
 
 


About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

Back to top
 Jobs
Financial Manager (CA) SA
South Africa
Accounting / Finance / Auditing
Financial Manager (CA) SA
South Africa
Accounting / Finance / Auditing
Audit Manager (Chartered Accountant)
South Africa
Accounting / Finance / Auditing
Senior C# Developer
Gauteng - Centurion
IT / Telecomms
Tester
Gauteng - Centurion
IT / Telecomms
 Sponsored links
Life Insurance
Car Insurance
UK Lottery
First for Women
Your Homeloan
Bid or Buy
Medical Aid
Education
Loans & Credit Cards
Compare Quotes
Life Insurance for Women
Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
Car Servicing & Repair
Win up to R1000 free!