News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Colleen Figg Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
Paralympics 2008
US Elections
Zimbabwe
Xenophobia
Aids Focus
Power Crisis
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Currie Cup game
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
14-16°C

Durban:
19-30°C

Johannesburg:
9-29°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 7.8100
Rand/£ 14.0300
Rand/€ 11.2200
Gold/oz $813.82
Gold Mining 1635.63
+0.00%
All-share index 25416.67
+0.00%
 
'Play the Critic'
If you play a Bles Bridges record backwards, will you hear secret potjie kos recipes? If you know the answer to this one - then it's time to "Play the Critic" with Food24.

 
Afrikaans
English
 

'Eating again, are we?'
23/05/2008 09:18  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.

Colleen Figg

The other day a chap she works with asked my cousin why she was "eating again" at the very moment she took her first bite of the piece of toast she eats every morning. He said this at the top of his lungs, in a crowded office and her first reaction was utter humiliation swiftly followed by anger.

She is not overweight at all, but even if she were, in what kind of society is it acceptable to publicly call into question another's eating habits?

Unfortunately it is very common for men (and other women) to criticise women for what they eat, when they eat, and how much they eat. Many men who do this are overweight themselves or are unhealthy eaters but nothing ever gets said to them.

They gleefully sit at their desks stuffing themselves with dagwood burgers, chips and coke while the woman who orders a toasted cheese (no chips and coke) is somehow expected to put up with derogatory remarks if they feel like making them.

I've seen people sniggering when the fattest woman in the company goes down to make her lunch, cruelly wondering aloud why she's eating again (there's that phrase once more). I've rarely heard people saying this about men who are fat, plump or even slightly chubby.

Most weight loss tips, tricks and programmes are firmly aimed at women and you can scarcely open a women's magazine that does not have something to say about weight loss, diet, controlled eating or other matters pertaining to keeping trim.

Pressure is on

As such the pressure is on women from a very young age to maintain a decent weight and to be seen to do so too; to the extent that many people I know no longer eat anything at work or if they do they scoff it down quickly before anyone sees them or actually leave the building to eat somewhere alone.

I've heard men remarking that they don't want wives who "look like the back of a barn door" as though said wives are their chattel, possessions that must meet certain standards or be cast out like inferior farm stock.

There is an almost casual kind of cruelty being perpetrated against larger people or people who may one day become larger (read: women) whereby people seem to feel quite happy about passing the most scathing insults based on a person's appearance.

I once worked for a man who said I should think about becoming less "broad in the beam" if I wanted to go out and see clients. Had I been more experienced then I would have had him severely taken to task, but at the time I was self conscious about my weight and for some reason felt he had the right to make such callous remarks.

But society does not teach or encourage us to stand up against such insults; we are actually expected to swallow them down whole with the sandwiches we should apparently not be eating and take them as our due.

Send your comments to Colleen.

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24. News24 editors reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

What is this?
Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
 
News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  

 
     
  The truth
23/05/2008 09:42
I agree that ones weight should be looked after, but most people out there eat out of sheer gluttony. Yes, some do have genetic problems, but the majority is self-inflcited, this is pure greed They will have anything that is presented to them. The majority of SA women are not overweight because they eat too much, it is because they are lazy and unproductive, and they use fatty foods as their excuse.Men use food as the anti-dote from the constant whinegeing they have put up with!! - Marc
 
  Im sorry
23/05/2008 10:13
But i dont totally agree with you Colleen. I watch what i eat and get in regular exersize. I do this not just for me, but for my girlfriend too. I expect her to do the same. I have many friends who got married, or engaged and their "better halfs" just let go. Didnt care anymore. Im sorry. Unacceptable. I do love her for who she is. But how would i stay attracted to her in that situation? So i have to remind and motivate her all the time..... - Vic
 
  So true
23/05/2008 10:14
The big joke is these men that make these comments are 99% of the time absolutely nothing to look at, yet the expect this high level from women. Ignore them. They like kindergarten boys that do things for a reaction. - Sarah
 
  Truth hurts
23/05/2008 10:17
While some people do have genetics to blame, the majority don't. Have to agree with Marc, most people are overweight out of sheer laziness and extreme eating. I like eating healthy and can say no to burgers, coke, cake, chocolate, liquorice all sorts etc. Fries, I don't try to resist. But I have been scorned for the amount I can eat...without putting on weight...sorry, lucky me I guess! - Anoerixic-look-a-like
 
  Never going to get it right.
23/05/2008 10:20
The reality is that people are often cruel - they pick on the weak, whether overweight, underweight, short, have glasses etc. You would think that they would grow out of their cruel streak once they move from school into the working world, but no - the cruelty continues. I think it might be a way of deflecting from their own inadequate little lives. I love working for myself, I have no office politics or bullying. - Sarah
 
  The truth Marc?
23/05/2008 10:21
Overweight people can be beutifull while as snotty people like you can never be. Live and let live I say. See the person on the inside and not the outside. If people judged you on how you look Marc, you will never get any....lol. Men assume its their right to make rude remarks as they forever consider themselves perfect. Men here is a bit of advise for you. Do you know that most women prefer to be single, and not becuase they have to be. The men today are nothing to write home about. - Jessie
 
  Awww.. Come on Colleen
23/05/2008 10:22
Don't be so harsh on men its Friday.You know there are guys out there who love a little plump.There are even some that feed their wives and girlfriends continously in order for them to get uber large and find it really sexy,they're called "feeders" - psycobabble
 
  It's not fair
23/05/2008 10:25
that only women as subjected to this. Guys say they love women who can eat, but immediately when you gain weight you become unattractive.In the black culture, a round woman is considered healthy, whereas a skinny one is considered unhappy & unhealthy. And don't forget our beautiful behinds. They are meant to be round, and they stand-out.What do we do then? It's about self love, and how much I eat should be no one's business, as long I'm happy about it. Let's stop being shallow. - NM
 
  Harassment?
23/05/2008 10:34
Any comment pertaining to a personal issue, whether it be weight or say, hairstyle, has no place in the work environment. You wouldn't go around telling somebody with a disfigured face that they should consider plastic surgery. Leave people alone, if they want to eat, let them. Nothing to do with you. - Petra
 
  True
23/05/2008 10:36
The quality of men these days in the looks department that make these scathing comments, really aren't anything to write home about. I have a friend who is overweight and she is the best programmer in the office. - Jen
 
  Weight..
23/05/2008 10:36
I agree with you Colleen. Noone has the right to make hurtful remarks to others about their weight. But I agree with Marc as well - many people are inactive and do not eat to suit their lifestyles. However - noone has the right to judge another person.There are many who try to lose weight but never succeed. - Amazed
 
  Same here
23/05/2008 10:38
We have a colleague who weighs 50 kg and for some reason the people comment about her eating. Freakin hell. She has a high metabolism. It's no one's business what she eats. - Emma
 
  Yip, so true
23/05/2008 10:40
I wear a size 32, so I'm not fat, even if I don't qualify for the "stick insect of the year" awards Still, some guy hung out of his car at the shopping centre the other day to shout at me "You're so fat girl! Sies!" Now, unfortunately he drove off or I could have clobbered him with my hockey stick! On the other hand, me going on a diet is still going to be way cheaper than the plastic surgery he needs to become anything worth looking at! Cuz you can lose weight, but there's no losing ugly! - Bridget
 
  Marc
23/05/2008 10:40
Marc, whilst you bitching, a woman is busy proving how incapable you are at your own job. Move a side boy. - S
 
  Five small meals...
23/05/2008 10:42
We also have a smart alec in the office, who comments each time you put something to your mouth, which I might add are 5 small servings per day, includes fruit and raw vegies. NB: He is a blob of note,,,,,,,so act deaf darling. - NED
 
  reasonable
23/05/2008 10:43
one has to be reasonable...being to thin or fat is not good. - uber
 
  Are they blind?
23/05/2008 10:51
I have often heard men, who look like they are about to give birth to triplets, remark on a woman's weight. Are they blind or is their mirror broken? Its funny how they expect us to be supermodels but they don't really deserve one. I suggest we all start making comments about their receding hairlines and kept reminding them to get hair plugs. - Karen
 
  Lighten Up
23/05/2008 10:57
Chicks are faaaar too sensitive about stuff like this. That's why guys abuse them about it. If a guy is overweight and a girl had a go at him about it, 9 times out of 10 the guy will laugh it off and move on... not chicks though! - Bob
 
  I eat six big meals a day...
23/05/2008 10:57
...but I'm also stronger and fitter that 90% of the people I know. People have made comments about the amount of food I eat, and I honestly don't care. People need to stop giving a damn about what other people say. On the other hand, proper diet and regular exercise won't kill anyone. - Sean
 
  Fat is not lekker
23/05/2008 11:00
It is often an indicaton of one's lifestyle (the degree of one's fatness). Fat people are perceived to be lazy, slobby and greedy, and I think this perception rings true most of the time. That is not to say that skinny people are not lazy, etc. However, fat is unappealing on men and women. Women exacerbate this because their self esteem plummets and they exude their lack of confidence, also unappealing. - Eduardo
 
  Yes, but
23/05/2008 11:03
I agree that people should look after themselves, staying fit and eating healthy not only keeps the body trim, but its also HEALTHY. But the comment the man in question made had nothing to do with staying healthy. What the cousin should have done is give a great comeback..like "well eating sure beats having sex with guys that look like you." Think on your feet girls! People will treat you the way you ALLOW them to treat you. - Chris
 
  Re: Marc
23/05/2008 11:05
I take it you are single Marc... Heaven knows it would take a woman with the utmost patience and a heart of gold to put up with someone such as yourself. Only your mother could love you, and even then I wonder! - Lauren
 
  Marc
23/05/2008 11:07
Maybe some can not handle the truth, the truth is, the majority of woman actually do have a healthy weight, but men?s judgement cloud their vision and they can?t see it. You have a false expectation of woman (all men), that we all should be Jodie Kid, Paris Hilton look a likes, and when in bed be as kinky, horny and trashy as the pornstars you watch. Well catch a wake up bro?! I get up every morning, dress sensibly, put make-up on,go to a full days work, eat very healthy, in the evening go to gym, come home do the washing, make dinner, take a quick shower, and then when I?m dead tired and want to go to bed, my dear ?frisky? non-tired (but tired of playing NFS on pc) husband, wants ravishing, sexy fun, with (which I have to add) I wish you would lose 10kg?s, it will make me so horny for you, you will look so sexy! Now that my dear Mark, I call arrogant from men?s point of view. Men make lousy jokes and degrade woman, say all woman whine, yada yada, but truth is over centuries you became so self involved in what YOU want, that all men forgot, woman are actually humans with needs too....We?re not here on earth to give sex whenever you want, be sexy when you want, be a showpiece to suite you! That is the reason for so many divorces and why woman prefer to live alone! Ga! - A woman!
 
  Attractive
23/05/2008 11:12
Women are attractive while they look feminine. You lose that feminine look when too fat or too thin. However, I find amongst my friends that the guys generally take better care of themselves than their wives/girlfriends when it comes to exercise and eating right and the girls fluctuate. In the younger generation that seems to be something developing, from what I have seen. - MJ
 
  Not always a 'condition'
23/05/2008 11:15
Some people have conditions that make it hard to lose weight, but when I see fat people scoffing chips and using the lift to go one floor, I lose all understanding. - Mj
 
  Like yourself
23/05/2008 11:16
Be happy with who you are and make peace with your body. This way, no insensitive idiot will ever cause humiliation. You must only diet to improve health or because you yourself feel you need to change. STOP BEING SHEEP - we do not have to all look, act and dress the same! - MJS
 
  Give as good as you get...
23/05/2008 11:19
Instead of taking offense and getting upset, why not reverse the tactic. If someone had asked why I'm eating again, my immediate response would be 'Because I'm depressed from having to look at your ugly mug all day'. Guaranteed you won't get those stupid comments again. Works well with mother-in-laws as well. ;-) - Sasha
 
  Weight
23/05/2008 11:20
I am overweight not because of bad eating and lack of exercise but of medication i have to drink. I still do thirty minutes on my bike everyday. I have not have these comments but from my mother who actually told me one day "you will never get a man and get married if you keep looking at that". - Cynthia
 
  I don't know which side to choose
23/05/2008 11:22
Both side speak some truth. I have a slow metabolism and are using chronic medicine, but have managed to loose 20 kg's since August last year and are now weighing 53 kg's. This I managed without exercise, but by having had the determination to do research on internet and seeing a dietician. Now I'm just eating right. So you see I do think there is no excuse for men and women to be over their weight limit just as there is no excuse from rude comments. - Afroupean
 
  Stop complaining .....
23/05/2008 11:27
....about the remarks people make about your weight & rather use it as motivation to lose the weight & show everyone what you are made of.Fat is & will always be UNATTRACTIVE,no matter what anyone says.Make your choice!! - Stop moaning!!
 
  @ Bob
23/05/2008 11:35
Chicks are "faaaaar too sensitive" to it because guys continually hammer them for it. It is cruel, insensitive and unnecessary far as I am conerned. What on earth kind of guy would want to hurt or humiliate someone for his own amusement? Good Lawd?:!?! - Colleen Figg
 
  Issues
23/05/2008 11:36
Seems some women really have issues with their weight. If its a problem/issue do something about it if not don't be oversensitive about it. Funny as someone here said how picky people can be about the opposite sex when they themselves aren't something to look at at all and im talking about men and women. - H
 
  You go girl
23/05/2008 11:38
Why are all the girls that are complaining about the guys insults say the guys making the comments are nothing to look at? If it was a good looking guy making the remark would it be acceptable to you?? Why not just ignore the idiots and carry on with your life. Old nursery school rhyme comes to mind : 'Sticks and stones can break my bones but names will never hurt me.' But agree with Marc, your body is sacred and you need to make an effort to maintain it in a healthy condition. - Not so thin
 
  look around
23/05/2008 11:43
If somebody were to tell me I was fat I would feel bad but how can you blame all men when those twiggy models still grace our lives wherever we look. Sanity and charity begin at home with the backbone of good parents who teach us real values. TV teaches us anything but yet modern society uses this great time waster as a guide to life.Is it any wonder the family is disintegrating and humans are loosing the plot. Please get off the lets bash men wagon in doing so you give up responsibility. - green goblin
 
  true that!
23/05/2008 11:44
I agree 100%. And judging at some of the comments above, most still believe it's right to tell other people how and what they must eat. That's for them and their doctors to decide, wise guy! Stop watching other people's eating habits and weight and mind your own business!!! - I agree
 
  Re: eating again are we?
23/05/2008 11:52
First of all, its nobody's business what you eat or why you eat whatever it is that enjoy eating and secondly a woman with a nicely rounded figure is very appealing to me as long as such figure is not overly so. People who pass such comments should expect all the disrespect, disdain etc that they are tendering for without crying foul. - Dangerman
 
  Laughable
23/05/2008 11:56
Quite honestly, I would rather eat 5 small meals a day and maintain a healthy weight and body image and even be above todays average body size, than someone who is afraid to put something to her lips for fear of humiliation or nasty comments made by others, I prefer to be a shapely woman and not a bag of bones and to all those nasty peeps out there who find it amusing to be derrogatory to a larger person male or female, go screw yourselves you probably all need a frontal labotomy ! - Panda
 
  :(
23/05/2008 11:57
I'm not severely overweight, just a bit chubby. I'm constantly on some or other bloody diet. I'm so sick of being made to feel self-conscious. And the biggest culprit is my husband. I can't eat ANYTHING without immediately feeling guilty. God, I wish it would stop. - T
 
  Shame...
23/05/2008 12:05
Feeling sorry for ourselves ladies? Nasty men! Would it make the world all better if it was a woman who told you to stop stuffing your face? Would it be better if the cruel and vicious remarks were made by women? Or do you girls just need some-one to blame and vent your anger on? - sias
 
  You are so right
23/05/2008 12:05
Im tired of the way people treat woman. They insult everything from our weight to our intelligence to our ability to do our jobs or even to just look after ourselves, just because we are women. I feel like giving up sometimes. - E
 
  I did not like being fat. . . .
23/05/2008 12:08
So I received this very good advice from somebody long long ago: Eat to live, don't live to eat. So I followed it. Whenever I feel the urge to indulge in food for whatever reason, I rather find something else to occupy my mind, hands & mounth with. Works like a charm. - TB
 
  Dont they get it
23/05/2008 12:09
I work with men I'm the only lady in the office,they are all married their wives prepare breakfast in the morning,Im single and i dont hv tym to prepare breakfast for myself they always complain about me eating a lot and dat I'll get fat. I am even scared to go grab a sanguage at the canteen bcos their stupid remarks irritates me to bits...I so wish they can just stop, im even losing weight dis days...... - khokho
 
  Unhealthy as smoking
23/05/2008 12:16
Being overweight causes as many health problems as smoking, yet we don't hesitate to tell friends, collegues and loved to stop or make snide remarks... These are deemed acceptable. Yet telling an overweight person (man or woman) that they should lose weight is frowned upon. Same thing to me. However, stupid or insulting comments are just that regardless of the cause or reason. Its not limited to just eating. - Me
 
  If I can stay in shape, so can you
23/05/2008 12:16
People always envy models for their looks but never enquirer to what lengths they go to look good (I'm talking about healthy ones, not the drugged up, zero-eating ones).They gym regularly, watch what they eat,i.e. live a healthy lifestyle. Those that are constantly one a "diet" of some sort are on the wrong track right from the start. Having a healthy weight just reflects a healthy lifestyle, while an overweight persons image doesn't.They want help,but stuff their faces every 5 min with junk - M
 
  Fatism
23/05/2008 12:21
I am guilty, as a boyfriend, of making an issue of my lady's weight/ what she eats. She is overweight and, like me, enjoys her food, I know it is insensitive and often regret the obvious pain it causes her, but i exercise and am terrified that this is only the start. As other posters have said, a full feminine figure is beautiful but push that fullness too far and the rolls and dimples begin to lose their appeal. This has absolutely no bearing on feelings of affection but rather attraction. - Oracle
 
  Grow some skin...
23/05/2008 12:24
Many people make remarks about heavy men, but they stop once they get the feeling they are being ignored. If women could grow thicker skin together with the layers of fat they shouldn't feel so insulted when someone passes a remark. Learn a few comebacks and learn to laugh at yourself. Better still, check the commentators for some flaws of their own and lunge for the jugular when the time is right. I don't like my girls fat, but that doesn't give me the right to insult them...Me 122kg, 1,82m - Kenko
 
  To all those women attacking Marc
23/05/2008 12:24
See, point proven. He makes an effort and you don't so now you have to get nasty. So who exactly discriminates against whom?I fully agree with Marc,if I can make the CONSIDERABLE effort of working out and eating right, so can women (unless you are mother and have really very little time to yourself) - M
 
  @khokho
23/05/2008 12:30
You are single (children?) and have no time? I have a high-stress job, long hours, no maid, no gardner,nothing, I do everything myself AND I GYM 5 times a week! - M
 
     
This comments facility is now closed.
 
JOBS
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - Johannesburg
FMCG / Retail / Wholesale
SENIOR ACCOUNTANT
Limpopo
Accounting / Finance / Auditing
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - Johannesburg
Property / Development / Real Estate
SENIOR ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - East Rand
Accounting / Finance / Auditing
ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - Johannesburg
Mining / Geology
ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - Pretoria
Engineering
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTANT
Gauteng - Pretoria
Engineering
SENIOR ACCOUNT MANAGER / SALES
Gauteng - North/Sandton
IT / Telecomms
A C# DEVELOPER (C ASP.NET VB.NET SHARP DEVELOPER)
Gauteng - Johannesburg
IT / Telecomms

 

About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

Back to top
 Vehicle Search
NISSAN
2006
Hardbody 2400i D-Cab Hi-Rider PU
R154990
ISUZU
2003
KB300 TDi D-Cab LX AT Dsl
R79900
VOLKSWAGEN
2005
Golf 5 1.6 Comfortline 5-dr
R135900
VOLVO
2007
C30 2.0 3-dr
R184900
LEXUS
2001
GS 300 AT MY06
R112139
 Sponsored links
Life Insurance
Car Insurance
UK Lottery
First for Women
Your Homeloan
Bid or Buy
Medical Aid
Education
SA TV online
Best Car Deals
Loans & Credit Cards
Compare Quotes
Nike's Bad Listener
Life Insurance for Women
Car Servicing & Repair
Piggs Peak Casino