News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : George Dearnaley Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Currie Cup game
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
20-26°C

Durban:
21-27°C

Johannesburg:
14-22°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 10.4500
Rand/£ 15.6500
Rand/€ 13.1500
Gold/oz $756.80
Gold Mining 1534.03
+8.34%
All-share index 18057.87
+1.37%
 
How do you rate?
More than 15 000 people filled in the first-ever broad-based online Health of the Nation survey. Here's what we found out...

 
Afrikaans
English
 

Football has lost its soul
09/10/2007 12:48  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.
  • Player incentives for KO Cup
  • 'The Duke' lays down the law
  • PSL: No commision paid...yet?
  • George Dearnaley

    I read an article recently on Roy Keane's thoughts on the game.

    The feisty one was philosophical in his outlook, but believes that football has lost its soul. His main concern, in fact the one that seemed to make his blood boil and his rage manifest, was that there were too many people playing the game who didn't love it. He found it inconceivable that a player could go on to the field and not love what he was doing.

    My thoughts drifted to the local football scene, and I asked the question, "Do we have players in our league who don't love the game?"

    I see the kids on the school fields, and I see how hard so many of our amateurs train for a shot at making it in the PSL.

    Would you train so hard if you didn't love it?

    I've seen players training in the dark, on the side of busy roads, with makeshift goals and an old football. I have to assume that these players love the game.

    I've seen over-age and over-weight has-beens chugging around on cold Wednesday nights trying to string two passes together. They do it because the love it, and they love the team spirit and the banter (and a few ice cold beers in the pub afterwards!)

    I then made a mental note of watching as much PSL football over the week to see what happens at the highest level.

    Positive

    Apart from a lack of real quality, I am confident that the players are passionate about the game, that they put maximum effort into the game, and that they respect what the game is giving them.

    I haven't asked every player in the PSL if they love football, but I'm sure that the majority will answer in the positive.

    I know that I love football. I loved playing it, and I still enjoy kicking a ball around with mates, and I love watching it. I loved training and I loved learning the game. I didn't love being injured, and after six knee operations I have suffered more than most, but I know it was all part of the game.

    There are some things you don't have to love, but the 'concept' of football, the tactical and technical battles, the glory of a well struck shot, or fantastic flying save, a great last gasp sliding tackle, a 40m diagonal pass that splits a defence, a small one-on-one duel between a small fast skilful winger and a big lumbering giant defender, these are the things that all make the game great.

    So I asked myself, "If all these things make football great, why do we only have 200 people watching Thanda Royal Zulu versus Ajax in a PSL match?

    Top flight

    Why were there only 20 people at a local first division match between Ikapa Sporting FC and Maritzburg United? 20 people!

    That's less than the number of players on the field in a match only one division lower than our top flight!

    I think the reason is similar to Keano's, but different.

    I think the sad truth about local football is that there are too many officials who love the money of football, but who don't care about the game.

    They are too busy earning their massive commissions to care that no-one goes to games anymore. They don't care that the fields are in poor condition, that the toilets at some stadiums don't work and that supporters would rather stay in the comfort of their homes and watch the game on TV.

    No footballer can perform at his best in front of an empty stadium. So their performance drops, the entertainment level drops, fewer people go to the matches and the cycle repeats itself.

    Overhaul

    We need a complete overhaul of the people responsible for the well-being of the game in South Africa. We need a combination of football lovers and clever business people. We need to focus on development and football education. We have a great opportunity to get things right using the 2010 tournament as a launch pad, but we will have lost the soul of the game if we don't make changes soon.

    I was impressed that Minister Trevor Manuel had a go at some of our soccer officials.

    It's high time some "heavyweight" senior people had a go, and even better that it is the one in the country with the best business brain.

    But we need action not words.

    I'm tired of being called "unpatriotic" by ignorant local football fans who couldn't tell the difference between Vosloorus and Princess Magogo stadiums, because my columns focus on English Premiership football.

    Perhaps I am losing my love of local football because I see too many of the problems on a day to day basis.

    It's time for change.

  • George is the associate publisher of Kick Off magazine and represented South Africa during the 1994 World Cup qualifiers.

  • Send George your thoughts

    Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

    - Kickoff



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


  •  
         
      soccer
    09/10/2007 13:43
    You offer no solutions??? No use just complaning - Soccer lover
     
      football has lost its soul
    09/10/2007 13:54
    Stick to commenting about english football.Leave our local football alone and go and live in England. - 2las
     
      Very true
    09/10/2007 13:54
    For a change I have to agree with you, It is very effident in our natioanl side as well when they rather play for the sake for their careers than for the sake of the country. Nice one George - Doorboot
     
      Football Lover
    09/10/2007 13:59
    Hi George, You have hit the nail on the head. The officials are in the various positions for the love of money; more indirectly (via commissions and tenders) than directly. I'll be surprised if you don't get hate phone calls from some of the bigwigs esp the A-List club managers. The major reason for the dwindling crowds is that their is more better entertainment all around us. - muk
     
      Geoger forver criticizing!
    09/10/2007 14:01
    Hey my man you are forever criticizing everything to do with Football in SA.What is you problem,you are act like all people who benefited from apartheid who are alwayscomplaining about the current ANC goverment.What great thing did you do as a player?.You had little skills,in fact if you played in todays game you wouldnt even have made pro....so give constructive critisism or shut up! - sipho
     
      I Thought...
    09/10/2007 14:08
    Oh and I really thought the officials were there for the game...!? - Martin
     
      George
    09/10/2007 14:09
    I completely agree with your observations regarding our officials in SA soccer. There are too many back-slapping pals and I honestly fear that nothing can be done to unseat and remove them from power. - VLS
     
      intersting
    09/10/2007 14:22
    from what i understand, the home team earns the money that is paid for tickets at their home ground?,explain how a team like black leopards or platinum stars get more votes in the telkom chariy cup, than chiefs or pirates,but you see no more than 200 fans at the stadium. well a team will not perform, if their own fans don't attend games. for bloemontein celtics, the fans have brought the soul of football for the club and their area. i love their spirit - DAN
     
      Who Cares??
    09/10/2007 14:31
    Well then..Finally I got the answer why u always negative towards SA Football, but who cares really?? Stick to England footabll reporting coz that where your passion really lies!! Too bad u couldnt play there though!! - Ringomania
     
      To True
    09/10/2007 15:45
    Football is not a SA passion anymore, many players, managers, owners and sponsors are in it for the money. I take my hat off to those who are not and to the 20/200 supporters who pitch up to watch African Subbuteo. - Nick
     
      George is right... for once
    09/10/2007 15:56
    George is right. Supersport and Absa have paid a combined R1.5 billion to the PSL for broadcasting and sponsorship. But what have they paid for? You watch PSL and outside of the top 5 teams there is no support in the stands. The stadiums and playing fields are well below par and the quality of football is seriously lacking. I'm not unpatriotic but the PSL is certainly over valued. Once 2010 is over, what will it be worth then? - Quin
     
      No more shibobo's
    09/10/2007 16:01
    SA is playing the football they used to play like in the day of Doctor Khumalo, John Shoe & Fani Madida I can name all those yesterdays stars & I thing tha passion is not there anymore! - Biggs
     
      unbelievable
    09/10/2007 16:12
    i cant believe the result of this article is a personal attack on the writer.unbelievable.its really disturbing that safa officials reason for being there is the commisions.did they get paid the commissions for the supersport deal allready? whats even more disturbing is the fact that soccer fans accuse u of complaining when u point it out! i watch junior soccer instead of psl..more entertainment..i can handle juniors bad control but not pros bad control... - akescpt
     
      George is Right
    09/10/2007 16:14
    George may be commenting too much on English soccer, but there is really no quality in local soccer anymore! It pains me having to switch channels from the local game to the english game week-in and week-out. Other than the greedy executives, we have buffoons like Dipela who schedule a knock-out competition on the same day that the national team is playing!! - rams
     
      Spot on
    09/10/2007 17:37
    100% right George. I was a die-hard local soccer fanatic, but nowadays I even forget to check the scores. The reason: the quality of our soccer is so low! Statistics don't lie, 10 years ago SA was in the world's top 20, today it's number 70-something. Look at the greedy, selfish, know-all, bigmouth, power hungry Irvin Khoza's team - they are currently last on the log, yet he's busy arguing about commissions. He should be developing his team and not playing Mr BigShot everywhere. - Mnguni
     
      You sound like them
    09/10/2007 18:02
    All u said is right, but not new.U want action and not words, but u r giving words. wat r u doing 2 show ur patriocism?Do u, urself,have any plan in mind or r u one of those who critisis without offering any suggestions?It does not need a Rocket scientist to see the status and affairs of ur football,but someone with brains to resolve the situation and quite frankly, ur r not offering any. - aubrey
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     

     

    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Jobs
    Operations Senior Specialist
    Western Cape - Cape Town
    IT / Telecomms
    Team Leader: Intel Tier 3
    Western Cape - Cape Town
    IT / Telecomms
    Tier 2 Wintel Team Lead (x2)
    Western Cape - Cape Town
    IT / Telecomms
    2nd Line Support Wintel (x2 Jan)
    Western Cape - Cape Town
    IT / Telecomms
    Support Engineer
    Western Cape
    IT / Telecomms
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    Best Car Deals
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
    Car Servicing & Repair
    Win up to R1000 free!