News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Jon Qwelane Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Currie Cup game
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
20-26°C

Durban:
21-27°C

Johannesburg:
14-22°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 10.4600
Rand/£ 15.7400
Rand/€ 13.1400
Gold/oz $767.70
Gold Mining 1560.64
+10.22%
All-share index 18143.08
+1.84%
 
How do you rate?
More than 15 000 people filled in the first-ever broad-based online Health of the Nation survey. Here's what we found out...

 
Afrikaans
English
 

In defence of the Prof
02/04/2007 08:52  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.
  • Honour the 'Prof'
  • Jon Qwelane

    I have been taken to task by some readers who, pardon their ignorance, believe the kind of propaganda that was often repeated by the SABC and, even though officially and publicly denied, was nonetheless pushed forward with zeal.

    Last week I wrote about the late great Prof Mangaliso Robert Sobukwe, a man I greatly admired and whose teachings continue to inspire me and a great many other people.

    To me, Sobukwe represented the proverbial "promised Messiah".

    I have neither apology nor misgivings about saying it out loud that I consider myself one of his many loyal and disciplined disciples, and it was a huge pity that death robbed us of him at such an awkward yet crucial moment of our struggle for liberation.

    Some of those who sent me their comments last week demonstrated clearly that the propaganda of particularly the decade preceding the 1990s got thoroughly through to them, and they believed it.

    They wondered why I could sing the praises of "the man who coined the 'one settler-one bullet' slogan".

    As I have stated, I do not owe anyone any apology for being an ardent believer in everything that Prof stood for.

    I will set the record straight by making just three points which will, hopefully, settle this non-matter quickly and for good.

    Don't give him the 'credit'

    Firstly, the slogan was never party policy but was used by guerrillas in the bush, gaining favour with them after they read it in their publication, Azania Combat.

    Secondly, party leaders never debated nor adopted the slogan as the official party line.

    Thirdly, Prof was dead for at least 15 years when the slogan first gained currency. So the claim that he "coined" it is patently false.

    In 1988 I was among a group of people who flew to Harare to meet the exiled PAC leadership during a two-day meeting.

    No one shouted the slogan among the many chants that were often uttered during the gathering.

    Later, over drinks in the evening with the commander of the Apla forces, the late Sabelo Phama, I asked about the slogan because I did not know it among those normally used at rallies and other gatherings, and he told me troops had adopted the phrase after it was first used in a letter written by a reader to the editor of Azania Combat.

    I find it curious yet tragically ironic that among those having the loudest mouths about the slogan are people who never hesitated to support our suppression and dehumanisation by constantly voting for the murderous oppressors.

    Prof mistrusted liberal white politics and loathed communism - in fact, he had no truck with either - but he never coined any slogan calling for the settlers to be given the bullet.

  • Jon Qwelane's column is published each week on News24, courtesy of Jon Qwelane and the editor of Sunday Sun, which originally carried the article.

    Send your comments to Jon.

    Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

    - Sunday Sun



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  
  •  
         
      Silent Answer
    02/04/2007 09:37
    Anyone commenting on slogans like those mentioned (and others) which made headlines in the past few months, are the ones who should be rethinking their motives. Politics have always been a game and those acting on issues like this are feeding exactly what the intentions were in the first place. I am not saying things should always be left unsaid, but rather selectively debated. - ElectroMan
     
      One Settler One Bullet
    02/04/2007 09:40
    In Apla, that slogan was not much shouted as it was in our Azanian Commandoes. Not a single leader of the PAC shouted that slogan in a public podium. We used it to give ourselves courage in fighting the system. Nothing wrong with that. It pisses me off that people still hold grudges against us for using such slogans. There are some who sing the praises of such people as De La Rey without the government banning the damn song. - Malibongwe
     
      Touched a nerve did I? 1
    02/04/2007 10:25
    I do apologise for believing the "propaganda" of the SABC that was somehow published by the editor of Azania Combat, in an issue of Azania Combat. Professor Sobukwe's 'messiah' like teachings obviously never filtered down to the armed men who adopted that slogan. Pardon me for being sarcastic but I struggle to take anything that you write seriously when you contradict yourself. - Geoff
     
      Touched a nerve did I? 2
    02/04/2007 10:28
    Contradiction number 2. "No one shouted the slogan among the many chants that were often uttered during the gathering." The next sentence. "Later, over drinks in the evening with the commander of the Apla forces, the late Sabelo Phama, I asked about the slogan because I did not know it among those normally used at rallies and other gatherings." So which one is it Jon? - Geoff
     
      Propaganda
    02/04/2007 10:29
    When you so graciously "pardon" people of their ignorance. I suppose you do realise that discrediting the views of others in favour of your own is propaganda in itself? - Andrew
     
      Slavery
    02/04/2007 10:47
    We need SA to look for solutions for the mental slavery that we are in. We are destroying our society by adopting the lewdness of the west. The moral degeneration is proportional the evil spewed out by our westernized leaders and media. Take the best of science and technology from the west and throw away the filthy moral values. We need African morals and any debate that leads us out of that slavery will help. - Sam
     
      ONE BULLET RIDDLES
    02/04/2007 10:52
    How about the support Mbeki is giving the free world... What about the situation in Iran with 15 hostages. And we want to host the world cup, we should definatley do something. As the same we are doing with zimbabwe. The raising the concern about the slogan. It struck fear in those on the recieving end, which could point the finger back (if it needs pointing) to the chanters. Its normal human behavior to protect if a threat is issued. How about them attacking our freedom with chants like those. - Chris
     
      Long live the "prof"
    02/04/2007 11:05
    I am glad you responded to this non-issue.The prog influenced many of us and his legacy will live forever irrespective of wether they name bulidings after him or not, in fact all people who believe in him can name their children after him. My sons name is already Robert Mangaliso and he loves it- Alph Booizen - AlpBooizen
     
      Prof Sobukhwe
    02/04/2007 11:35
    I believe that we all hold views that are diverse and we are entitled to do that. Is'nt what freedom is all about. The fact that not all black people are Robert Sobukhwe praise singers does not mean we are brainwashed by some institutions. Maybe it could be an informed choice. Everyone including yourself has an agenda and a propaganda to spread. If one chooses to follow you and your anti Mbeki stance that is their own choosing. - Ndlovu
     
      enough!!!
    02/04/2007 11:53
    Just the mention of such an evil phrase and your need to clarify who said or not is proof enough that your ideals are warped. Besides, leave the running of SA to the youth who are more educated and understanding about peace and democracy. Enough of your wanting to idealize people who no-one cares to remember! - Themba
     
      Azania
    02/04/2007 12:14
    John, with my little experience in journalism, i have learnt that the truth is not wanted and as it makes us free, it is not wanted. As an upcoming Journalist, I admire Sobukwe a lot. John, keep telling us the truth and leave the chartarists barking. wishing u all the best. Viva the spirit of Robert Mangaliso Sobukwe Viva - Nthambeleni
     
      Prof Sobukhwe
    02/04/2007 12:48
    Jon, you don't have to defend Prof's honour i know some of our leaders who are addicted to your column are angry at right now.The prof is the only man in South Africa whom they name a clause to keep him in custody "The Sobukwe Clause" even how much they are trying to destroy his contribution to our struggle, they won't succeed The Tiger of Azania said once "We are not paper tigers but blood tigers no amount of propaganda would destroy us, We are not builded by the press and it destroy us - Koko Dyasi
     
      "One Settler One Bullet" was proper
    02/04/2007 13:42
    This is rather a plea to current PAC president, Honourable Latlapa Maphahlele to set a programme towards building or launching PAC head office as "The Sobukwe House". Waiting for the charterists (ANC) to do so, will never materialise. Jon, I think lot of people will start doubting you based on your association with PAC. I also think the statement was proper and relevant considering the sufferings (gun-shot as if a black person was an animal) black people were experiencing at that time. - James
     
      Slogan/Sobukwe
    02/04/2007 13:43
    Thanks for explanation Jon.Cheers. - ZORAN
     
      Aknowledge all our heros
    02/04/2007 13:53
    After reading Sobukwe's biography I realised that March 21 was a PAC initiative. I am always perplexed though that when the day is commemorated, Sobukwe is never mentioned (or the PAC's role). Steve Biko died 30 years ago, I am waiting to see if his death will be commemorated come Sept 12th. As for the slogan , I think back then it was relevent. Most white people just stood by and did nothing. They were therefore seen as the enemy! - Olebogeng
     
      Building PAC
    02/04/2007 14:02
    John, I think if you are serious about admiring Sobukwe you should start by enhancing the ideal that he fought for. The PAC is just going to the grave yard day by day. Understanding country's politics and racial demographics, PAC should atleast be official opposition due to its minimal chances of being ruling party. It is parthetic to see DA (white based), enjoying hegemorny in African soil. It is time that PAC should focus in rebuilding the organisation and stop lambasting on unnecessary matters - Sizwe
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     

     

    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Jobs
    Document Process Writer
    Gauteng - Centurion
    IT / Telecomms
    Systems Analyst
    Gauteng - Pretoria
    IT / Telecomms
    Software Developer
    Gauteng
    IT / Telecomms
    1st Line Service Desk Analyst Technician
    Gauteng - Johannesburg
    IT / Telecomms
    DATABASE ADMINISTRATOR
    Gauteng
    IT / Telecomms
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    Best Car Deals
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
    Car Servicing & Repair
    Win up to R1000 free!