News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Max du Preez Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Food
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
19-25°C

Durban:
23-30°C

Johannesburg:
17-28°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 9.6300
Rand/£ 14.5000
Rand/€ 13.0900
Gold/oz $837.88
Gold Mining 2277.38
+0.00%
All-share index 22718.97
+0.00%
 
Write what you want to read about
Calling all budding journalists. Want to get published on News24? Find out how to get your articles published on MyNews24!

 
Afrikaans
English
 

Fit to govern?
03/10/2007 09:00  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.

Max du Preez

It seems completely obvious, but in fact far too many South Africans don't get it: it does not matter how popular the ruling party is, its interests should not be mistaken for the interests of the state or the nation.

It has become commonplace for people who voice criticism of the government or of the ANC to be labelled unpatriotic or disloyal to South Africa. (And if the ANC is annoyed enough, the critics will be called racists if they're white and servants of white interests if they're black.)

I have not once heard the present leader of the ANC and president of the country, Thabo Mbeki, distance himself from these types of accusations. In fact, in the recent book that carries his full blessing, Ronald Suresh Roberts's Fit to Govern - The Native Intelligence of Thabo Mbeki, every single Mbeki critic is painted as a disgusting, racist settler or a despicable native servant of these racist settlers. Mbeki sycophants, of course, are noble patriots.

I'm not sure whether the explanation for this blurring of state and party's interests is the extraordinary arrogance of some ANC leaders or simply a very limited understanding of what the concept of a democracy really means. Probably both.

No right to criticise?

It is a fact that the overwhelming majority of South African citizens support the ANC. The ANC got around two-thirds of the vote during the last election and just about three-quarters of the total number of members of Parliament are ANC. (How many times have I heard, in conversations and on talk radio, ANC members saying those outside the ANC have no right to criticise the president or his cabinet, because as ANC leaders they were chosen by the majority of the people, and that is democracy?)

Even if 90% of the voters voted for the ANC it still does not mean what is good for the ANC is necessarily good for the country. Anyway, which ANC are we talking about - the Zuma/Cosatu/SACP ANC or the Thabo Mbeki ANC?

Many suspect that Jacob Zuma was fired as deputy president of the country because of his power struggle with Mbeki inside the party. Persecuting Zuma in this way might have been in the interests of the Mbeki faction of the ANC, but considering what it had led to, it wasn't in the national interest.

It would clearly have been in the national interest to fire the embarrassing Minister of Health, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, and to replace her with her competent former deputy, Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge. But it was in the Mbeki-ANC's interest to protect Tshabalala-Msimang, so she stayed and Madlala-Routledge was fired. When parliamentary Speaker Baleka Mbete refused to entertain questions about Tshabalala-Msimang and kicked out the DA MP who wanted to ask them, she was acting in the interest of the ANC and not of Parliament or the country.

National interest

There is little doubt in my mind that it would have been in the national interest to fire or at least suspend the commissioner of police, Jackie Selebi, after his admissions of close friendships with known criminals and his dealings with assassinated millionaire Brett Kebble.

In fact, there was enough of a prima facie case against him to persuade the Director of National Prosecutions, Vusi Pikoli, that he should be charged and for a prominent High Court Judge to issue a warrant for the commissioner's arrest.

But Selebi, a former operative of Umkhonto we Sizwe, is a powerful man in the ANC with a lot of inside information on many top people. In the end he was kept while Pikoli was fired, because that was what was in the interest of the Mbeki-faction of the ANC. By what stretch of the imagination can it be in South Africa's interest to have a suspected racketeer as the head of its police?

I have a very high regard for the history of the ANC and its leaders over more than 80 years. It was the most mature and democratic of all liberation movements on our continent. It gave us the likes of Albert Luthuli, OR Tambo, Walter Sisulu and Nelson Mandela - leaders any nation on earth would be proud of.

ANC members and leaders should show more respect for their party's legacy and act according to the spirit of our negotiated settlement of 1994 and of our brilliant constitution. They should recognise that the country and the nation come first, party political allegiances second.

They should also remember this when they vote for a new leader at the ANC's elective conference in just over two months' time.

Send your comments to Max.

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

- News24



What is this?
Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
 
News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


 
     
  You make alot of sense.
03/10/2007 09:23
Your article makes alot of sense, but, there is always a but, because you are white, and not pro-ANC, you will be labelled a racist. Finish and klaar. The leaders of our country are so blindly committed to their "struggle buddies", that the country can burn, as long as they have their friends and their travel budgets. Voters need to open their eyes... - Villian
 
  Constructive Crit.
03/10/2007 09:29
Hard to disagree when you put it like that. Eish man, i still want to have a stable majority/black govornment in South africa for my children. The ANC will not die overnight, so their is no need to be so secretive and defensive. My party needs to do the right thing for its public, black and white regardless, and we will ride out the african civil crisis storm to be be united african leaders. When it is finished raining, maybe their will be a rainbow ne? - Khaya
 
  fir to govern?
03/10/2007 09:32
You will soon realize that the negotiated settlement of 1994 and our constitution is not worth the paper it's written on for the ANC. I mean, it should be obvious to anyone with half an IQ that these people only have honour for themselfs. - AJ
 
  politics
03/10/2007 09:40
Well said!About time as well - gerhard
 
  Excellent
03/10/2007 09:44
Excellent piece Max!!! - Mac
 
  Too Logical
03/10/2007 09:46
Hi Max, intelligent comments, but too logical. Don't count on those who need to read this most to pay attention. Mbeki and Co. are like George Bush: calling critics unpatriotic. Mbeki's speech at the UN recently was a good one, but hypocritical coming from him. I can't get over the fact that he lived for years & had a great education in a 1st world country, yet he thinks like a backward ignoramous regarding Aids and democracy. How is that possible? Perhaps he's wilfully blind. We're screwed. - Saffa
 
  African politicians
03/10/2007 09:51
Excellent article and so very true. Unfortunately, South Africa and the rest of Africa will never change because these so-called politicians are crazy, power hungry, money grabbing savages. They fight many years for for their own "freedom" but as soon as they get it, they try so hard to destroy it. - DHV
 
  Wise Words
03/10/2007 10:17
I am trying so hard to find the words for the complete disgust, mistrust, anger and heartache I feel for the ANC clan. Their decline in morals and values is a disgrace. I quote Martin Luther King Jr. "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere"; "A lie cannot live"; "Every man must decide whether he will walk in the light of creative altruism or in the darkness of destructive selfishness". HOW THE MIGHTY HAVE FALLEN! You have plundered our country. The populous must vote you out. - Alicia
 
  ANC Definitely Fit To Govern
03/10/2007 10:26
Of course the ANC is fit to govern. SA is an African country trying hard to conform to African Third World standards and has a backward Third World governing party voted for by people with a Third World mentality. So what's the problem? - Brenda
 
  ANC
03/10/2007 10:26
I will admit to not knowing a whole lot about the history of the ANC (in the 80's, repeated lessons on the Great Trek seemed to be of more importance) however, I would seriously doubt that they (Luthuli, Sisulu and even Govan) behaved the way the current 'leaders' are behaving. Infact I would go so far as to say they are probably turning in their graves at what has become of the ANC today. - AS
 
  Required reading
03/10/2007 10:28
Great article, Max. This should be required reading for all blindly loyal, sycophantic ANC followers. Don't expect too much, though, as this would require the readers to think,analyse and make independent decisions....something the party faithful seem incapable of doing. - jonno
 
  I can't understand
03/10/2007 10:32
It boggles my mind how ANYONE can still vote for this party! Can someone PLEASE explain? - Juan
 
  Ironic
03/10/2007 10:40
Funny thing is that 66% of the country will continue to support the ANC irrespective of how immoral it operates. This echoes the action of white voters pre-94. It seems that all people find it very hard to see the fault in their own kind. - Wilhelm Kuys
 
  Brilliant !!
03/10/2007 10:44
Finally! Someone with some logic and common sense. Pity our so-called leaders will probably never grasp the concept of either. Lets hope that the few remaining people in government who actually do have the best interests of the public at heart, stay there and arent 'evicted' by their incompetent peers! - I.S
 
  Fit to criticise??
03/10/2007 10:46
The only problem with critics is that they don?t want to be criticized. Max just like you have the right to label them (ANC lot) as drunkards, thieves, denialists etc, they also have the right to label you. Isn?t that what democracy is??? The second problem with analysts is that they assume their opinion is the public opinion and represents the majority of SA which is unfortunately not true. I think the political analysts and media must also be more tolerant accept their racist tendencies, political interests etc. - Mlu
 
  Welcome to the real world
03/10/2007 10:48
Max, it's nice to see you have woken up and seen the ANC for what it is and not blindly following them because you thought it atoned for your heritage - the truth is, it's too little too late. South Africa is finished and in a very few years it will be "Zim II" - you will have plenty of time to think about it when you are waiting in the bread queue! - Erix
 
  The blurring of the line . . .
03/10/2007 10:49
Excellent column Max. The ANC have shown an increasing blurred line between party & state interest. The ANC have clearly not grasped some fundamental concepts about democracy: checks & balances & criticism are part & parcel of the open & transparent (words the ANC once used then forgot about) process of an elected form of government - anything less is a Zanufication of politiek. - Dee
 
  Masses
03/10/2007 11:13
Unfortunately the masses are blinded by the fact that these leaders "led them to freedom" and so will blindly vote them in again. The truth is, what real alternative do they have? For South Africa to be a true democracy, the ANC needs to split along the lines of all these divisions and then the people can vote for the party they really believe in. At least that way they are unlikely to have a 67% majority enabling them to change our hardwon constitution at will.... - DW
 
  Standards
03/10/2007 11:20
Some interestinf insight, however i think the problem is that the majority of thinking people do not understand the Standards of the Present ANC. I am sure the Party would agree that if the present ANC did not have DOUBLE STANDARDS, They would have NO STANDARDS at ALL - Paul
 
  ability to govern
03/10/2007 11:20
Somewhat starrey-eyed about previous ANC leaders. Apart from Mandela, none of them was tested in the real world of governing and even Mandela was president during an extraordinary time. Is Mbeki not just a typical of the inadequacies of politicians through the ages? - Niel
 
  Fit to govern
03/10/2007 11:24
Well said Max! Unfortunately, it seems that all freedom movements which eventually get into Government forget about democracy in their endeavours to keep the "party" in power. Our Government is perhaps not as violent or zealous as other governments in this regard but they definitely carry on the trend. Sometimes ruling parties must take decisions that are hurtful to them and their party but are in the interests of the country. I don't believe this lot are capable of doing so. - Malcolm
 
  zuma must go
03/10/2007 11:26
i think this country will suffer and crime will prevail should zuma become president. this must not be allowed to happen. - MrT
 
  Best column
03/10/2007 11:27
Hi Max you are a true south african and a great african indeed,We should embrace one another as to create a good multicultural and a democratized envy nation of africa and the whole world as well.I believe that is what Madiba and Mr De-Klerk agreed upon. - Benny
 
  Fit to govern.....
03/10/2007 11:29
Max, thank you for this. Once again an excellent colomn. - JB
 
  Fit to govern
03/10/2007 11:30
I agree with you Max.I am alarmed at how quickly the ANC has changed from a caring party to a party where everyone wants to be king.I often wonder whether the ANC is aware that not everyone who vote for them are card carrying members.So they should be careful how they conduct themselves, it is not only about themselves but the whole country.Max you are one of the few analysts in this country who always try and give a fair comment without taking anyone's side. - Godfrey
 
  no majority
03/10/2007 11:31
40 million South Africans of which 40 percent or 16 million voted of which 75 percent or 12 million voted ANC. It boils down to a mere 30 percent of people voted for the ruling party and definitely not the majority. But this is politics ........ - MARIO
 
  United opposition
03/10/2007 11:33
The ANC has too much support and will probably rule for the next 100 years if we all dont melt with global warming by then . So what can we do ?All the opposition parties must unite to have a powerful opposition and can keep the ANC in check. In this way they cant just get away with anything. Mbeki you are not fit to do anything!!! - Zee
 
  bit of ANCstory
03/10/2007 11:53
hmm... given that any suggestion that the ANC has *anything whatsoever* in common with the Nats is normally greeted (at the very least) with splutterings and frothing at the mouth, I don't suppose this is a good time to point out that they did exactly the same thing for 40 years? (who knows - it maight make them change their ways a bit...nope, sorry, don't think so...) - phil
 
  Stop paying taxes by leaving...
03/10/2007 12:02
The only way to make the government listen - is not to pay taxes. The only way to do this legally is to go and work in another country (it is easier than you think). Why keep paying high taxes to a government who does not protect or care about the tax payers? With a vote of no confidence to our president and his government, I will (God-willing) be leaving this beloved blood-stained country soon. This government does not deserve a law-abiding taxpayer like me, nor does I, my wife or my children deserve a government like this. Should there be serious efforts and results by government to better this country for all ? I?ll be one of the first to come back and pay taxes? - JFK
 
  Read a good dictionary lately
03/10/2007 12:05
I would invite everybody out there to look in their dictionary/ies. (hopefully a good one) The word "democracy" comes from two greek words: DEMOS meaning PEOPLE and KRATIA meaning POWER/RULE. So democracy means "the people rule" - Annie Mouse
 
  Mlu
03/10/2007 12:07
Mlu - have you actually read the content of this article, or simply the author's name? Do you feel there is no truth in what is said, or are you simply side-stepping the issues mentioned? I find your comments bizarre at best. - MJ
 
  Mlu
03/10/2007 12:08
Blinded loyalty my friend. Political analysts must accept their racist tendencies??? If you cannot see where the ANC are heading you are blind, there is sooo much in house fighting it is so blatantly clear that there is a power struggle which WILL have negative consequences for this country. The rainbow nation has dissipated in the storm cloud of power-mongers. - A DJ
 
  Thabo Mbeki
03/10/2007 12:12
President Mbeki is a very clever man, always two or three steps ahead of opponents. Read the book,"Thabo Mbeki and the battle for the soul of the ANC." Thabo is working his way and entreching himself in our future for many years to come.Watch how the power is shifting, future presidents of this country will become a mere puppet to the ruling ANC. Bad times ahead in my eyes with regard to our shaky democracy. - Glenn
 
  All is not lost...
03/10/2007 12:26
The current politicians carry a lot of baggage due to past injustices - maybe the responsibilities of freedom, fair governance & accountability are much more tricky than they thought along with overcoming resentment for all those years of apartheid. However, the next generation of politicians might have integrity due to equal opportunities, world travel & through watching the current lot's questionable governance. Let's hope so. - Saffa
 
  People still struggling
03/10/2007 12:32
Hi, Last night I came across an old man 60+ had nothing under NP has nothing under the ANC. Now he probably has to work through the pain barrier every day to make min. wage. Now my point is it would cost how much to feed a elderly man or how many people could have been fed with the money Monto spend on the personal add. Politicians travel costs 300k for 1 trip overseas. Surely this money could be put to better use. Our politicians are not accountable for their actions. - Jason Marriott
 
  Patriotic
03/10/2007 12:36
Max have these people forgotten so soon about your contribition in defeating APARTHEID.They should remember thet it was trough your efforts that PRIME EVIL himself and aparthied DEATH SQUARTS where exposed.I will never forget you broer.Sabelo-Klerksdorp - MICHAEL
 
  well said but................
03/10/2007 12:40
Hi Max,i agree with most of what you said except the issue of the negotiated settlement. Most people are Landless,Jobless and live in the most harzadous environment whilst a vast track of land is empty an idle and there's nothing the goverment can do because of these. the only people benefitting from these so called "negotiated settlements" are whites and a few politically conected blacks. - Wonder
 
  Max and Khaya
03/10/2007 12:48
Goeie artikel Max - jy's skerp soos n skeer lem my ou perd. Khaya, I applaud your honesty ("I still want to have a stable majority/black govornment in South africa"). Too often we don't say what we want to not take sides or to be politically correct. I'll be happy with a black government (they can be pink for all I care) as long as they have the interests of all SA'ns at heart. You and I both suffer from hidden agendas and you and I will both benefit from a Gov that puts all of it's people first. - Moto
 
     
This comments facility is now closed.
 
 
 


About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

Back to top
 Jobs
Snr Microsoft Programmer
Gauteng - Centurion
IT / Telecomms
Accountant
Gauteng - North/Sandton
Medical / Healthcare
Accountant
Gauteng - North/Sandton
Mining / Geology
Financial Manager
Africa (excl. SA)
IT / Telecomms
Financial Accountant
Gauteng - Johannesburg
Medical / Healthcare
 Sponsored links
Life Insurance
Car Insurance
UK Lottery
First for Women
Your Homeloan
Bid or Buy
Medical Aid
Education
Loans & Credit Cards
Compare Quotes
Life Insurance for Women
Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
Car Servicing & Repair
Win up to R1000 free!