News24 Columnists
Missed a News24 Column? Click here to read past columns from some of News24's finest.
Sport24 Columnists
Missing your favourite Sport24 Columnists? Click here to read the latest views from Sports24.
Search News24
     Columnists : Tumo Mokone Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Food
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
19-25°C

Durban:
23-30°C

Johannesburg:
17-28°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 9.7000
Rand/£ 14.6700
Rand/€ 13.2500
Gold/oz $843.00
Gold Mining 2277.38
+0.00%
All-share index 22718.97
+0.00%
 
Write what you want to read about
Calling all budding journalists. Want to get published on News24? Find out how to get your articles published on MyNews24!

 
Afrikaans
English
 

Bitter taste to Benni's return
07/09/2007 13:28  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.
  • Bafana want winning ticket
  • Benni has bad news for Zambia
  • Benni: Better late than never?
  • Tumo Mokone

    Benni McCarthy is a shameless glutton for attention.

    His return to the Bafana squad after a 20-month self-imposed exile is more about another opportunity to grease his over-inflated ego, than to help SA win against Zambia on Sunday in Cape Town.

    Excluding cases of match-fixing, every player wants to win a match in which they play.

    So it is sheer arrogance for McCarthy to act like he is back with the national team because he wants to help the country win.

    It is as if other players don't know the importance of winning and that they will discover this desire with his presence in the team.

    Granted, Bafana have struggled scoring goals throughout the Africa Cup of Nations qualifying competition, despite being top of their group.

    In the same period, McCarthy proved his pedigree as a striker by scoring 19 goals in his first season in the English Premiership at Blackburn Rovers. He scored another goal last Sunday as Blackburn defeated Manchester City 1-0.

    It must be noted however that his goalscoring form in the Bafana jersey before his boycott was not up to scratch.

    Apart from behind the scenes matters which irritated him in the 2006 ACN finals in Egypt, Benni was generally out of his depth in that tournament, with his physical conditioning a matter of loud whispers.

    Another point to be noted is that Benni has entered the second phase of his football career as a striker.

    He now thrives as a lurking finisher, with very little contribution to the general creative play in the Blackburn team.

    Carefully considered

    The question is, while his manager at Rovers, Mark Hughes, does not expect the largely melodramatic player to do a lot of graft work but just pounce on stray offers, will Carlos Alberto Parreira be able to field a team that would be able to create opportunities for McCarthy to finish?

    While he must be on a high given his form at Rovers, there are several factors, however, that McCarthy would've carefully considered before returning to the Bafana fold.

    Among others:

    1. The urgent need to get enough game time in national colours to secure an extension to his work permit with the British Home Office.

    2. The presence of CAF executives who will be in Cape Town for the fourth edition of the organisation's 50th anniversary festivities.

    3. The choice of Cape Town, his home town, as the match venue for Bafana Bafana for the first time in two years.

    4. The absence of current chief striker Sibusiso Zuma through suspension.

    5. The possibility of missing out on playing in the ACN finals in Ghana in January.

    The third factor may sound frivolous but returning to national duty on his home turf guarantees him a heroes' welcome, while such a move elsewhere, especially in Gauteng, would have been met with resentment.

    Most soccer fans are still angry with the manner in which McCarthy has shown the national team the middle finger with impunity. He has had other exile moments in the past, and many people thought this time he had gone too far.

    Capacity crowd

    With the suspended German-based Zuma on the sidelines, McCarthy is guaranteed an automatic place in the starting line-up, and the opportunity to be the star attraction.

    What better opportunity to do so in front of the Confederation of African Football bosses and a capacity crowd at Newlands?

    An added spice is that the match will not be solely about Benni's homecoming but also a get-together for five more "brasse vannie Kaap" in the Bafana squad.

    These are defenders Bevan Fransman (Moroka Swallows), Brett Evans (Ajax CT) and Greek-based Nasief Morris (Panathinaikos), midfielder Dillon Sheppard (Sundowns) and striker Thembinkosi Fanteni (Ajax CT).

    With such a healthy representation by Cape boys, Newlands will be swelling with local pride.

    All Bafana need to do on Sunday is to avoid defeat, and automatically qualify for Ghana 2008. (Apologies for jumping the gun in my previous column, which had suggested that SA's qualification was a done deal).

    Not counted

    The worst result possible would be a 2-0 defeat as that would mean Zambia would finish on top by virtue of better head-to-head results against South Africa.

    In such a scenario, SA will then hope to go through as one of the three best runners-up from 11 of the 12 qualifying groups. (Group 12, with three teams, is not counted for the best runner-up scenario.)

    SA look good in all departments, though the strikeforce still looks inefficient, despite Benni's presence.

    But losing to Zambia is certainly not on the cards.

    Otherwise that will mark the biggest upset since the Ted Dumitru-led shenanigans in the 2006 ACN finals in Egypt, where Bafana returned without a point - or even a goal.

  • Tumo writes exclusively for News24.

  • Send Tumo your thoughts

    Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

    - News24



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


  •  
         
      Spoilt brat Benni
    07/09/2007 13:47
    Well said Tumo. We have seen how other countries, including African countries, have dealt with spoilt brats like Benni. It's good that Benni has never and will never win the African Footballer of the Year Award. This guy and his attitude does not deserve a place in the SA squad. It's such that SAFA is led by myoptic people. This country is much bigger than this guy. - Nick
     
      BM is an Opportunist!!
    07/09/2007 14:05
    I strongly agree with you on the points above, on why BM is back with Bafana Bafana.Especially point 1.He desparately need that 75%, hence it took him 5min to decide on his return.We been fed with lies on the real issues he couldn't move to UK.BUT on the other hand some people have created that opportunity for BM to abuse.Poeple, inclduing the coach have been saying we need BM.So while people cry over him, I say BM abuse us and dump us after getting 75%!! - Fella, Cape Town
     
      Benni
    07/09/2007 14:05
    If it were up to me, Benni would have long lost his citizenship by now, let alone a spot in the Bafana team.I hate poeple who think they are better than others,just because they have more money, than an everage South African. Please make him sit in the bench until the last 5 minutes of the game, pleeeeease - Just me
     
      It takes one to know one
    07/09/2007 14:15
    He's just like you for writting this article. He's a player, let him play. Just like the S.A media has a bad name, and maybe even you, but we're all with you, still reading your article becuase media24 hired you and you're here to do your thing and get paid. We don't expect anything more from you but this. - unknown
     
      Benni McCarthy is a shameless glutton for attention.
    07/09/2007 14:29
    He is good anyway - The O' JAYS
     
      benni's return
    07/09/2007 14:37
    Every word in Tumo's article may be accurate, for all I know, but I suspect that he may be missing the point. Which is surely that Benni is now a top-rated player in the best domestic league in the world and he's tired of SAFA's offhand incompetence, poor communication and inability to organise basics such as flights and hotel bookings. Presumably that's why he's pledged allegiance to Carlos Parreira and Bafana Bafana rather than SAFA. - jeremy
     
      Are you also angry for Benni.......?
    07/09/2007 14:38
    Tumo!You are one of the angry fans who is still not welcoming Benni.You really want to bite Benni's head off with your article.You should welcome this man & respect his talent. He's not arrogant SAFA is arrogant!! - Biggs
     
      benni
    07/09/2007 14:39
    firstly you have no idea what you talking abot.zuma said himself he wants to play with benni again.maybe his return is in front of his home grawd but look at the scotland's game.the strikers were terrible.benni is the best we have at thyis point and i support hime all the way to break bartletts record.you do bot see this happening in europe or anywhere alse in the worls but what if it was zuma doing this.would your comments still be the same. - ralton maart
     
      opportunistic
    07/09/2007 15:13
    Tumo is correct to highlight Beni;s opportunistic behaviour. The boy left us stranded in times of need. He better scores lot of goals to win back our hearts. - g-man
     
      Bitter Taste to Tumos comments
    07/09/2007 15:26
    It sounds more like you have some persoal issues with Benni! While I was not amused by his antics regarding playing for Bafana - I think Tumo's diatribe smacks more off disliking Benni because he is a Cape Town boy! To suggest that his goal prowness is only dependent on his "lurking" is laughable - when was the last time you watch a Blackburn match? He doe not have to be creative -Blackburn pay others to do that! - Vanniekaap
     
      Mccarthy's 'arrogance'
    07/09/2007 16:06
    I completely disagree with this artical. Benni has gone overseas and really made a name for himself there. He's done really well for his circumstances, and quite frankly owes us nothing. In fact, we need him for our national team more than he needs us for his career - if at all. Unfortunately a team of PSL players, contrary to popular belief, will not win us the world cup - we need more players such as Mccarthy to want to play for Bafana Bafana. - Adam
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     
     
     


    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Jobs
    Snr Microsoft Programmer
    Gauteng - Centurion
    IT / Telecomms
    Accountant
    Gauteng - North/Sandton
    Medical / Healthcare
    Accountant
    Gauteng - North/Sandton
    Mining / Geology
    Financial Manager
    Africa (excl. SA)
    IT / Telecomms
    Financial Accountant
    Gauteng - Johannesburg
    Medical / Healthcare
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Car Servicing & Repair