| |
|
|
| |
Agree 100% with your sentiments
25/07/2007 09:26
This guy should have been locked up, or as you rightly said, at least have been forced to work for the SPCA for a considerable amount of time. We do not have a place in our society for scum like this. - J.O |
|
 |
| |
Husky
25/07/2007 09:28
I am a loss for words !! The sentence sucks but then we all knew that this will happen. Matthysen you are scum !!and remember "the wheel turns"......excuse the pun but "every dog has its day" I cant wait for yours..arsehole !! - DENNIS AUSTIN |
|
|
| |
Get a grip on reality ppl
25/07/2007 09:34
While it is true that this person has issues, the fact remains that there are far worse crimes being committed in this country. The rape of babies for example. Perhaps focus should be more on protecting our young and the future generations from a sick society before worrying about some dog.... Just a thought. - Drew |
|
|
| |
Just another example of our inept "justice" system at work!
25/07/2007 09:36
This ruling is simply another slap in the face for animal rights & rights in general in the country.If this thug can afford to travel to London on business than surely R10 000 is pocket change for him? Perhaps a 2nd psychiatric opinion is needed? How can anyone who commits such an act be declared sane? He reminds nme of the freak who stuck a firecracker into his dog's rectum a few years ago,a garden variety sadist,nothing less. - lily-white |
|
|
| |
What will it take
25/07/2007 09:37
How long before this man with his clearly psychopathic tendencies inflicts harm against a child or another person? What will it take for society to realise that anyone capable of this kind of action is dangerous and will not stop at hurting animals? - JM - Janine Marais |
|
|
| |
This is sick!
25/07/2007 09:41
This man is a horrid excuse for a person. Had he decapitated a person he would have been locked up for life. I know there is a difference between a human and a dog, but the dog was still a living, breathing thing. He should be punished FAR FAR more than this. Him and his worker who assisted are disgusting. His picture should be put up everywhere so that when we see this man, we remember who he is and know not to give him any respect. - Gary |
|
|
| |
Bad, but compare it...
25/07/2007 09:42
Yes i fully agree that his sentence is quite lean. But please people, compare it to other crimes. Babies raped, murdered. Hijackings galore, family murders and armed robbery is everyday stories. These sentences are also very light. It probably boils down to our prisons being full so they have no place for these criminals. They should build more prisons and then we would most likely see criminals behind bars again. - Rommel |
|
|
| |
Caption
25/07/2007 09:42
The caption for this letter on the home page is:
"I have, with utter disgust, read of the light sentence handed down to a man who decapitated his young Husky with a chainsaw, writes one animal lover."
I believe you don't need to be an animal lover to be disgusted at Phillips actions; everyone can see that is actions are appalling ? and a R10 000 fine is certainly not punishment enough for a barbaric act such as this. To quote Queen Margaret in Henry VI, part III: ?Off with his head? , figuratively speaking of course. - R Sanders |
|
|
| |
Husky and sentence
25/07/2007 09:44
Ai jai jai! Nou wat nou mense? His suspended sentce for 5 years? Does that means that he MUST NOT BE CAUGT again doing this? In my book it means he can actually still go on Oh, and by the way: I don't think the fine will hurt him, if he could afford expensive parrots (or whatever kind of bird it was) I'm sure that a total of R15 000 won't hurt his pocket. I hope burn in hell! - Me |
|
|
| |
Drew
25/07/2007 09:46
Yes that the otherside of the coin, but I were you, I would rather get off this conversation board with your remarks. The readers are going to crucify you! I agree with you, but isn't that exactly where crime against our childred begins? If you can do that to an animal, can you think what a person like that can do to a bay? - Me |
|
|
| |
No justice for husky
25/07/2007 09:48
Anyone capable of commiting such a heinous crime should be immediately locked up and the key shuold be thrown away. Matthysen is pure evil and the same goes for his scummy gardener who held the poor dog down. And Drew, someone this evil will undoubtedly move on to harming humans given his sick nature. Shame on the Judge. I think a petition to get him booted out of office should be started - i'd be the fisrt to sign up - Vuyo |
|
|
| |
Shame for Drew
25/07/2007 09:53
I feel so sorry for Drew who has no compassion. Sadly the abuse of animals is just the starting point for the abuse of women and children. Also the seriousness of rape etc does not take away the pain and suffering that the animal endured.Have a heart Drew... - K |
|
|
| |
Cruelty is cruelty
25/07/2007 09:54
I don't think it is valid to argue about "worse" crimes. The message is clear - one can get away with cruelty. It's hardly a stretch of the imagination that perpetrators of cruel acts against animals are more likely to commit acts of violence against people as well. To the best of my knowledge this has been researched, and indeed found to be the case. We either tolerate cruelty or we don't. In this case, cruelty has been tolerated. Sad. - Charles |
|
|
| |
Its a dog
25/07/2007 09:56
I think what the he done to the dog is hars and cruel but its just a dog, why don't they spend their time looking for people who kill endangered animals im pretty sure my kid will know what a dog is one day. I am not defending what he done i think it is wrong but come on lets spend our time worrying about people who kill endangered animals and make a big scene like you did with the puppy. i know of a girl that got raped the other day that didn't even make the news but a puppy getting killed is? - spazman |
|
|
| |
Agreeing with Janine Marais
25/07/2007 09:57
I'm sure he wouldn't like it if we put a chainsaw to his head... - MP3 |
|
|
| |
A joke
25/07/2007 09:59
His sentance is a joke an insult to people.
Drew just because we are upset aout does not mean that we put this crime above any other heinous crime. This behaviour was just sickening and should be punished accordingly.
I cant believe they also letting him keep his other dog. He should be banned from owning any pets. Aswell as serving jail time. How is paying a fine punishment? - Natalie |
|
|
| |
To Drew and other comparisons
25/07/2007 09:59
The human race has appointed itself as more valuable than animals, God knows why, because the human race is singularly the most destructive and selfish species on the planet. There are over 6 billion of us pointless beings on earth, and all we do is suck it dry to satisfy our wants. The fact that we rape murder and mame our own and other species even further points out what a disgusting lot we are, but yes lets put animal rights on the back burner because they are inferior?? - Tennille |
|
|
| |
Get a grip on reality Drew
25/07/2007 10:00
"Just a thought"? "Worrying about some dog"? Are you so short sighted as to not put 2 and 2 together? If you are sick enough to hurt an animal then you are sick enough to hurt humans! Where is the love in humans gone to ... the same unconditional love animals have? I am truly sickened to my stomach to hear comments about how "some dog" doesn't matter. This is where the cruelty starts. This guy (and those who have acted out any form of cruelty to another living thing) have big time karma to pay. - AS |
|
|
| |
what about the bird?
25/07/2007 10:01
If that mutt killed my parrot I would not even take the trouble to start a chainsaw, I would ring his neck with my bare hands. I ask again, what about the bird! The dog killed first.
- Gerry |
|
|
| |
I feel sick thinking about this
25/07/2007 10:02
There is a special place in hell reserved for people who are cruel to animals. It is absolutely inexcusable that someone who has done something so purely evil isn't punished more severely, and I find it sickening that an educated person in a position of authority doesn't view this in a more serious light.
If someone could do this to a harmless, loving and friendly animal, what's to stop them moving on to people.
I hope the people involved are torn to shreds by a pack of wolves.
- Helen |
|
|
| |
All Husky Owners
25/07/2007 10:03
All husky owners should be decapitated for animal cruelty, because a husky is a animal that loves cold and is bred for that purpose and SA's weather is to hot for this kind of breed. He actualy saved the dog from years and years hell in sunny SA. - JJ |
|
|
| |
Shame on you judge...
25/07/2007 10:05
A life is a life be it dog or human and to take it willfully is murder. The Justice system fails yet again!!!! Do we have to now wonder why crime levels are so high??? You can kill at will (or in the killer's case if your stress levels are high and you are tired) and the most you will get is a suspended sentence. To the killer I hope he is savagely torn apart by some animal somewhere and is left to suffer for a long while. - Sharon |
|
|
| |
Drew's reality
25/07/2007 10:06
Whilst we are about it lets just forget all crime except what is important to you Drew. Obviously animals are there to be abused and exploited in your world. Lets also forget to worry about other irrelevant stuff. Shall we add traffic violations? What about fraud. Add your list. Whilst you are about it, please define sick, because I can see that you and I differ on that definition, as I would have put you under that heading. - Edna |
|
|
| |
So Drew...
25/07/2007 10:13
Just a thought - the next time he wields a chainsaw it may be a human head! The judge should have made an example of him! He should be locked behind bars. - MM |
|
|
| |
What about his other pets?
25/07/2007 10:16
What an absolutely ludicrous idea to let him keep his other animals! If he can do this once "in a fit of rage",he will do it again (& yet again he will get off lightly).What frustrates the hell out me is that we have no mass demonstrations in this country against crime etc.(the masses only tend to show themselves when it is time for strike action).1000 protesting against crime is nothing,100000 & the government will start taking notice. - lily-white |
|
|
| |
That was a sad day in South Africa
25/07/2007 10:16
..when this utterly unacceptable judgement was passed. Suffice to say, his turn will come. Hope he is ostracised by his community. - Peter |
|
|
| |
How a nation treats its animals
25/07/2007 10:16
?The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.. I hold that, the more helpless a creature, the more entitled it is to protection by man from the cruelty of man" M.Ghandi
South Africa shows its colours daily in how it treats its citizens nevermind cruelty towards animals.
Violence violence violence, remove the savages and let the rest of us live in peace.
And lock this guy up, inexcusable what he did. - Juan |
|
|
| |
Monster
25/07/2007 10:18
Drew ...what do you mean "some dog" do you not understand that a animal has just as much right to be on this planet as does humans, that just some dog also had a soul .... and feelings ....and no way of protecting itself from the absolute monster freak of a human that murdered it !!!! the thing is if this freak had been caught raping a child he wouldave been put away for life ..... Animals have no rights in this country and your comment just goes to prove were your loyalty and heart lies !!!! - Cola |
|
|
| |
Injustice does not begin to explain
25/07/2007 10:18
For the very na? people that have written on this forum regarding bigger crimes i.e. Baby rape etc that requires more attention ? don?t you understand that people who are capable of doing this to a defenseless animal who can?t speak for himself, are exactly the type of people who rape defenseless little babies? The plain fact that this murderer is allowed to keep his animals, is just astounding and once again, the likes of Animal Welfare, SPCA and the PDSA, don?t have a leg to stand on, as one silly, ill informed judge can?t think further?
I put this man in exactly the same category as rapists and murderers, and should be put in a cell alongside them!
To say that this entire ruling is an injustice is a joke.
- R |
|
|
| |
Justice, NOT
25/07/2007 10:20
Drew, once we sort out the relatively small crimes, like this psychopath committed, the "far worse crimes" will reduce. You have to sort out the small stuff first, and then go after what is considered the more serious crimes. Take Singapore, for example.
Unfortunately the dog-killer is not going to stop at this, and will probably move on to people eventually. It is a common pattern of psychopathic tendencies. - Bob |
|
|
| |
Drew
25/07/2007 10:23
Drew, I fully agree with you. If this much publicity, time and effort was given to real crimes with human victims we may just see a drop in the crime rate here. Crucify me all you want people, what he did was bad, but the crimes committed against humans are far worse and deserve more attention. I find it sad that you ppl get so worked up over an animal yet say nothing about the human victims. - AS |
|
|
| |
DREW
25/07/2007 10:24
Yes drew we are ALL in unison that the other crimes in our country are despicable and the people commiting then should be shot,hanged,carstratted but the forum here is about a pet,defenceles dog reliant on the owner for love and care but was butchered by same owner. - DENNIS |
|
|
| |
What comparison.
25/07/2007 10:26
Did you know that in the US people who abuse animals are locked up and watched if they are released therafter. It has been proven that people who abuse animals are just ''practising'' for when they start on children, woman etc... Also, there is no comparison and its not a ''light'' crime as some so ignorantly put it, they are not just dogs or animals they are all beings that deserve a good life and if you choose to have a pet in your life they are your responsibility to care for and protect. - Nadine |
|
|
| |
Justice
25/07/2007 10:28
If our justice system cannot even protect humans where do you think they will protect a dog. - dawn |
|
|
| |
Drew, I think you need a grip on reality
25/07/2007 10:31
Drew,I find it enlighting that mental institutions now have internet access.You're clearly trying to make it back into civilized society.But with a remark like that,I'm afraid you still have a long way to go.Yes,there are babies raped and people murdered.The outcry from the public against those crimes are just as intense.Why should we only focus on those crimes? Can't we as a public be disgusted by other inhumane crimes as well?Or just ignore it because there are "more important crimes"? - CJ |
|
|
| |
NO JUSTICE
25/07/2007 10:32
Drew,
Crimes against children will stop when crimes against animals stop. Why can't this country ammend it's laws so that these people can pay for what they do? Then they ask why our nation is in such shambles as it is. It's true what Ghandi said: The greatness of a nation is measured against the way they treat their animals.... Need I say more. - Suzz |
|
|
| |
Justice.
25/07/2007 10:33
The low outcome of this horrific act just goes to show what a useless law system we have in this country, and that criminals are free to roam and do as they please! You can kill someone and have a minimal sentence handed to you, it's rather ridiculous and embaressing but its gonna remain this way till this country gets the changes it needs. Just remember, that this freak of nature, needs to answer to the big man one day, and by G#d is my witness, i hope he has the same done to him!!! - Wes |
|
|
| |
"gerry" & "jj"
25/07/2007 10:33
How unfortunate that we have individuals such as you inhabiting this planet with us.Your argumenst bear no relavance here (especially yours "Gerry").Perhaps you should try keeping your exotic parrots in large cages so your dog/s can't get to them.As for "jj",perhaps you would like to send all the animals in zoos back to their original places of origin as well?. - lily-white |
|
|
| |
Where's the justice???
25/07/2007 10:34
I totally agree with Anne - he should've been given a much heftier fine along with some serious community service time to be carried out at an SPCA. What is R10 000 to this man and as for the suspended sentence? I do not see any justice here - Bailey's mom - Bailey's mom |
|
|
| |
"What about the bird ... the dog killed first"
25/07/2007 10:39
What about the bird, Gerry? Is this a case of an eye-for-an-eye? Have you never heard of natural animal instincts? Seems you have the potential of being just as bad as Phillip Matthysen? People like you, Drew and the other AS (25/07/2007 10:23) need to wake up and smell the roses. - AS |
|
|
| |
Is he evil?
25/07/2007 10:40
what if this guy showed real remorse and is truly sorry for his actions?
murderers in this country walk free all the time, i cannot understand this outburst over a dog when children get raped , ppl murdered etc etc and no one gets brought to book.
i do not condone this guy's actions just trying to get some perspective on the issue. - IceCreamMan |
|
|
| |
Husky-sentence
25/07/2007 10:42
Hi,I think the judges judgement "stinks". in the first place all the other animals, dogs, birds etc. must be taken away from such a "decpicable" excuse for a man. If he can to this to a innocent animal he is capable to do that to a human being.Lock him away and throw the key away, even better, saw of his hand with a chainsaw and the lock him up, without any medical care and through away the key! He is a menace to society! the same should be done to a anyone else that commits the same crime! - carissima |
|
|
| |
Husky-sentence
25/07/2007 10:46
Hi Gerry, if you had expensive birds, etc. Are you not suppose to keep them in a cage - maybe they are illegally imported birds? nature is nature, so decide what you want, birds or dogs or cats? Stuff that in you pipe and smoke it!!!!! - carissima |
|
|
| |
Drew and like minded individuals
25/07/2007 10:49
You are clearly missing the bigger picture here as there is more to this than just an animal being killed. A very wise person once said that you can judge a society by the way it treats it's infirm, aged and animals and in this case the logic would dictate that we are a VERY sick society. We treat our infirm, aged and animals appallingly and just deflect from the issue by making comments like "but there are worse crimes to worry about" and that is sickening!!!
- Shane |
|
|
| |
To the Geniuses Gerry and Spazman
25/07/2007 10:50
First off Gerry, exotic animals like parrots belong in the wild, and were not created to be used as live ornamentation for our amusement and second the dog killed to eat and acted as dogs do. To Spazman how the hell do you think certain species become endangered? By their lives being undervalued by mankind, like the case is with this husky. - Tennille |
|
|
| |
Drew and Co.
25/07/2007 10:54
There is a direct link between the abuse and torture of animals and psychopathic tendencies yet these types of CRIMINALS are let off lightly yet they are potential time bombs.
Einstein once said "there are 2 thins that are infinite..the universe and human stupidity and I'm not so sure about the universe" and in situations like this i can't help but to agree. - Shane |
|
|
| |
Indicative of Societies Moral Decline
25/07/2007 10:54
What has transpired here is indicative of the moral decline of society. We have individuals who state that this is not worthy of a harsh sentence due to it being only a dog and that crimes committed against children and humans take precedence. ALL crimes of this nature should be viewed in a severe and harsh light, regardless of the victim. The punishment should not be passed on whether it was an animal or a human as both should be just as deplorable. - Craig J. King |
|
|
| |
Newsworthy?
25/07/2007 10:57
AS, you state that all those in support of a harsher sentence should spend more time commenting on crimes against humans and that no-one here makes any remarks on these. On what are you basing that statement? I am sure that all so far who have commented would have done so if it had been done to a human. So your argument is flawed. - Craig J. King |
|
|
| |
IceCreamMan ...
25/07/2007 10:57
What "perspective" are you trying to reach on this issue? Cruelty is cruelty... what do you not understand about that. Maybe you should start taking note of "outbursts" against all injustices. - AS |
|
|
| |
No Joke...
25/07/2007 11:02
If everyone is so up in arms about crime then why arent you taking action by doing something real about it???? Lets all go to his house and have a braai - Matthys and Vleis! - Grapjas |
|
|
| |
"Spazman"
25/07/2007 11:11
"It's a dog" - what is wrong with you? I do agree that they need to catch whom ever is killing endangered animals, however, this bastard admitted to torturing his animal who was totally dependent on him. It was not just a dog, it was a soul who died in absolute agony. CE - CE |
|
|
| |
Justice
25/07/2007 11:11
Yet again, the helpless, weak and innocent suffer. Is life only for the strong and wicked who rob others of their right to live, whether it be human or animal. There is no justice! - Lesley |
|
|
| |
Perspective
25/07/2007 11:14
I think the biggest crime is the injustice of the whole situation. "The Chainsaw Killer of Delmas" is a monster. Killing an innocent being is, I think, the worst crime to be committed. A being that trusts you, who think the sun dawns ad sets by you, and now you go and hurt it, be it a baby, a child or a pet. Injustice reigns in South Africa. And once in a blue moon, a case like this comes around, we'll shout. Raping babies and murder is in the news everyday. Ek is al lankal al hees daarvan!!! - Brenda |
|
|
| |
Typical
25/07/2007 11:15
Its just so typical of the laws and incompitent judges in south africa. Life means nothing in this country anymore, be it an animal or human.
- GetSum |
|
|
| |
Comparing Animal Cruelty to Other Crimes
25/07/2007 11:23
I agree with CJ - why should we turn a blind eye to animal cruelty because there are worse crimes being commited to humans.
The FBI has found that a history of cruelty to animals is one of the traits that regularly appears in its computer records of serial rapists and murderers, and the standard diagnostic and treatment manual for psychiatric and emotional disorders lists cruelty to animals as a diagnostic criterion for conduct disorders. - Jason |
|
|
| |
"Is he evil?"
25/07/2007 11:27
You still ask? Are you for real? What do you call it then? Yes, murderers walk free. They should not nor should anyone walk free who kills, hurts, rapes etc etc. This is the whole point of this letter ... the punishment is not meeting the crime! This goes for humans and animals. - AS |
|
|
| |
Who cares
25/07/2007 11:35
Who cares, its just a frigging dog. There are millions were that came from. Even if the puppy wasn't categorically replaceable, its not like it contributed anything whatsoever to the world. The really irritating bit is that, inevitably, many of you who have been expressing such outrage are all too happy to eat all kinds of meat, for which animals were pretty mercilessly butchered. You're all (well mostly) hypocrites :) - Sigh |
|
|
| |
Get a grip
25/07/2007 11:35
Dear comfortable middle class pet owners. The cuter and cuddlier an animal the more easily you personify it, think only of seals. Four working for water labourers beat to death a recently released porcupine in the Tokai forest. Should they also be tried? This was surely a crueler and less motivated act? Is it simply that you identify with the cute and cuddly and this determines the extent of your outrage? - steve |
|
|
| |
puppy.
25/07/2007 11:39
Yes, the sentence for killing the puppy is disturbing, but this is South Africa.. all our sentences are pretty lenient: Murder, rape, robbery etc.. THAT IS EXACTLY WHY WE HAVE SUCH A HIGH CRIME RATE AND VIGILANTE JUSTICE as our pathetic pathetic PATHETIC justice system has collapsed. We are closer to anarchy than you think. - Juan |
|
|
| |
be afarid be very afarid
25/07/2007 11:43
I am sure that I have read of credible research which could have been produced in court to show that these types of savages inevitably abuse humans. That scumbag is a menace to society and needs to be removed from society i.e jail .As a Christian I do find comfort in the words of Jesus who said words to the effect that insofar as you have done it to one of the least of His Kingdom you have done it to Him.He was referring to children in the direct context but animals are his creation . - grant |
|
|
| |
Justice?
25/07/2007 11:44
With the death penalty comes place for people like this in prison. If you can do this to animals you can do this to any kind of living creature. Humans included. JJ, Gerry, you both probably also killed puppies before? Sickos!!! Start with the small crime and there will be no big crime. We (or the judge) cannot even give a crime like this the punishment it deserves. Give him to the public sector. We'll deal with him! Justice for ALL!!! (animals included) - Rey |
|
|
| |
tenille
25/07/2007 11:46
I could not agree with you more Tenille! the human race was put on this earth to look after its inhabitants as well as the planet itself,but we take the gift we have been given and rape,murder,burn,destroy,maim,consume and obliterate anything we come in contact with. The human race is doomed. - Robert |
|
|
| |
The real issue
25/07/2007 12:00
The point here is not whether a puppy died, or a parrot, or a baby for that matter; and speculating that Matthysen might turn on women and/or children next is conjecture. Don?t lose focus in a futile debate over which is more valuable ? animal versus human life, because all life is precious.
The crux of this matter is a moral one. Phillip Matthysen acted immorally and his action should carry a consequence. What sets humans apart is their ability to decide between right and wrong. Obviously that doesn?t apply to him ...
- Diego |
|
|
| |
what did you expect?
25/07/2007 12:02
What punishment did you expect? Do you think that he would get a harsh punishment? In a country where murderers of people get lighter sentences that thieves in the Arab states? Where bail for murder suspects is less than a speed fine? I hope you are not emotional about it.... - Devil's Advocate |
|
|
| |
Animal Cruelty
25/07/2007 12:04
I just wonder where all you animal lovers are when humans abort their babies, or drown them in toilets or hit their heads agianst walls. Where is the public outcry, the tears? Says a lot about we humans I think! MC
- MC |
|
|
| |
philip the killer-cut his hand off !!
25/07/2007 12:07
As far as im concerned his right hand should be cut off with the same saw,while he`s concious,then he can keep it in a jar in his kitchen - the bastard is a coward. - Lee Andrews |
|
|
| |
Hold your horses
25/07/2007 12:15
Yes, what he did was gruesome and terrible and cruel. He killed an innocent animal. The uproar about this is out of proportion though as people have become desensitised to the daily violent crimes against PEOPLE in this country. The sentence could have been much harsher, but let's face it: cows that get slaughtered for your yummy steak don't exactly die peaceful deaths either. Remember that before you go off on a crusade claiming to be oh so humane. - Yawn |
|
|
| |
Re: Who cares
25/07/2007 12:24
So the puppy made no contribution to society? What about the 9 month old babies that were raped/upducted/abused by their parents? What more of a contribution can they offer us? Grow up to be like Matthuysen? Just like that babies brought love and joy to her parents, so do some animals to childless parents. In this messed up world of ours, any sunshine is wonderfull sunshine.(matephorically speaking of course) - Brenda |
|
|
| |
Oh please
25/07/2007 12:24
What do u people want, should he get the death penalty... it was a dog - not a human being, the sentence was fair. in some countries they eat dogs, i guess thats barbaric right??? - skarr.. |
|
|
| |
|
|
| This comments facility is now closed. |
