24.comcares
MyNews24 bloggers have organised a charity event in the Midrand area. See how you can help.
VIDEO: The future of news
Online media guru Dan Gillmor tells us how citizen journalism is changing the news as we know it.
Search News24
     MyNews24 : Your story Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
News24 turns 10
US Elections
Zimbabwe
Xenophobia
Aids Focus
Power Crisis
More...
 
MyNews24
Letters
Your story
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Currie Cup game
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
14-20°C

Durban:
18-26°C

Johannesburg:
10-30°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 9.3800
Rand/£ 16.0800
Rand/€ 12.7600
Gold/oz $847.40
Gold Mining 1898.59
+0.00%
All-share index 20595.23
+0.00%
 
Nerve-wracked
A psychologist and a psychiatrist answered users? questions on anxiety disorders on World Mental Health Day.

 
Afrikaans
English
Your Story
 

YOUR STORY
Energy wasting 'criminal'
11/06/2007 12:28  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.
  • The winter of our discontent
  • Koeberg unit shuts down
  • Mom dies after electricity cut
  • Barking up the wrong tree
  • Eskom stole my mother!
  • SA reviews electricity supply
  •  Get Published on MyNews24
  •  Send us your Story
  •  Send us your Letters
  •  Send us your Videos
  • Andrew Perkin, News24 User

    With reference to your correspondent's letter regarding Noelene's electricity saving tips, permit me to respond.

    I am a professional electrical engineer, and feel compelled to back up the statements made on TV. In particular, geyser management through application of a programmable digital timer outstrips the energy savings afforded by commercial or residential lighting management, by factor ten or more.

    The modern residential geyser with a properly set thermostat (60 degrees, maximum) takes approximately 30 to 45 minutes to heat the volume of water, from cold to working temperature. It is unlike a kettle, which has to heat the water to boiling point, and thus works in accordance with the laws of diminishing returns.

    During the eight or nine hours away from home, and the eight or nine in the evenings during which no hot water is used, the geyser continues to cycle, operating for roughly ten minutes out of every sixty (and slightly less during the day, or during summer, when ambient temperatures are higher).

    This energy wasted is, frankly, criminal. It can be shown that using the timer to switch on the geyser at 05:00 in advance of the morning shower period, switch if off between 08:00 and 16:00, switch it on at 16:00 in advance of the nighttime bathing and cooking period and switch it off for the night at 20:00, has the potential to realise a water heating energy (and thus monetary) savings of 40%.

    During the warmer daylight hours, the water retains some heat for general use. This phenomenon is improved if the geyser is well insulated.

    A ripple effect

    This technique should not be confused with municipal ripple control, an inelegant technique of peak lopping, applied by supply authorities, which only leaves consumers frustrated, as their geysers are switched off en-bloc at precisely the time they need hot water!

    It is my view that the random coincidence of geysers being in the "managed on" position would far outstrip any peak demand benefit currently obtained through ripple control. In my opinion, geyser management could be used to strip 10% off this country's peak demand.

    Unfortunately the technique I espouse is not universally applicable, since programmable timers require a degree of consumer sophistication, and a great number of households have totally random lifestyles, not suited to a timer working to a more or less consistent routine.

    However I believe significant penetration into the population of geysers in service an be achieved, and with it, energy and peak demand savings.

    In closing, a word regarding such a timer. Such a device needs to be sufficiently robust, to handle the operating current of the geyser. The device should be of the appropriate quality, and installed by a suitably qualified electrician, in order to comply with the national code for the wiring of premises. It should also come equipped with a manual override facility, in order to switch on the geyser for hot water required at odd times, or completely, over weekends.

    Get published on News24 by sending your article, story or column to us

    See who has had a say on News24.

    Disclaimer: This article was submitted by a News24 user. News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of users published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

    - News24



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  


     
         
      nice one!
    11/06/2007 12:51
    Any waste is bad, i agree. How is our elec overload going to cure itself while our government "grows" the economy. 5% per year, means the load grows by 5%! Build those powerstations already! - tom
     
      Energy wasting criminals.
    11/06/2007 13:09
    Sir, Andrew Perkins comments re saving Electricity are correct. In exactly the same manner as it would be possible to avoid rape by forcing all women to have a sex change operation. Both ideas are completely unneccesary. The Electricity problem can be solved by employing qualified people at Escom and the rape pandemic can be solved by SA employing Policemen instead of the keystone cops. Regards Chris Goddard - Chris Goddard
     
      Energy wasting 'criminal'
    11/06/2007 13:13
    I agree with Andrew Perkin that careful management of a household's biggest electricity consumer (the geyser) can save and benefit everyone all round. It's a question of who is interested, and who will do something about it. I do not use a timer, but switch off the geyser about 6 in the evening, and switch it on again about 5.30 in the morning. My shower is as hot as normal, and my electricity usage has gone down considerably. On a prepaid meter, I save about 3 units a day. - Robert Kay
     
     
    11/06/2007 13:35
    i like the option and really give my all to saving electricity and wanted to know that if i opted for switching my geyser on and off, will it effect or damange the geyser in any way if it is done consistently. - blonde
     
      Thanks
    11/06/2007 13:37
    Thank you for the tip. I guess every bit helps hey? I will be trying this one. - Peter
     
      Timers
    11/06/2007 13:37
    I use timers on all my geysers, and certainely agree, they save us a lot of money, and by programming them cleverly, we always have hot water when needed. Just a further tip - get a type of timer that has a capacitor built in. This acts like a battery, which means that during power outages, the programming is not lost, and it simply continues working afterwards. - CalliedJ
     
      Energy wasting criminal
    11/06/2007 13:37
    What a well written and thought out article. It's nice to see someone who really cares. Well done! - ak
     
      industrial enery saving
    11/06/2007 13:43
    Yes, I also agree, waste is bad. But surely the wastage in the industrial sector is larger than that in the domestic sector? What action is being taken in industry locally to trim down energy usage? - Sarah
     
      stop die klok... hou die horlosie
    11/06/2007 13:45
    Uh yeah, like why not just get solar panels? no need to switch anything off. Maybe it's just me but switching it off and on... Logic would imply that once water has cooled off it would take a considerable amount of power to re-heat water from scratch. 3 Units a day? compared to the inconvienence of having to follow Mr Kay's example. I'll pay for those 3 units thanks... - MP3
     
      USEFUL INFORMATION
    11/06/2007 13:46
    Thanks for this useful information. I have two geysers in my house, one which is normally always off(guests). I have found that if I have heated this one geyser up and switched it off and not use it for say three days, that I still get fair warm water from it for a shower. - Christiaan
     
      Petrol
    11/06/2007 13:51
    Petrol is also energy. Driving big engine SUV s/cars during rush hour traffic is also a huge waste. All forms of energy wastage must be criticized. - wastewatch
     
      INCREASE HYSTERESIS
    11/06/2007 13:51
    Andrew, maybe you can also tell us about hysteresis! I assume that if you don't use a geaser that your hysteresis will be longer and if you swing say between 50 and 60 degrees you may even find you geyser stay off for a few days! By the way, some guys up here doesn't get the message yet! Forget ESCOM, get the CO2 out of the air! - Christiaan
     
      Energy saving
    11/06/2007 13:56
    Clever tips but somewhat invasive. Why do consumers have to do anything else but simply bye a solar panel geyser? Are South Africans so poor not to be able to aford one for each family? - Foreigner
     
      ISOLATE MP3
    11/06/2007 14:00
    MP3, geysers are isolated and cool down very slowly! Like a flask, get it! Instead of keeping it optimum all the time, give it slight room to move. Logic says you will save provided you know your physics and mathematics. Solar panels are very costly (infrastructure) to justify but will save the environment! - Christiaan
     
      Energy wasting 'criminal'
    11/06/2007 14:04
    Thank you for clearing up something I have tried to instill on friends for years. - Jenny
     
      Money for nothing
    11/06/2007 14:14
    I must agree with Chris Goddard. Eskom is the only company in the world that ask people NOT to use their product. If I am willing to pay, sure they must deliver? - Jas
     
      energy saving?
    11/06/2007 14:29
    How does wrapping a blanket on a geyser save energy?Raping a woman is criminal Mr Perkin,your wisdomness.Although i do not doubt credentials i find your linear thinking insulting to the greater public.1stly why did`nt the govt provide these timers you speak of instead they distribute blankets? - jp
     
      It is not about deliveyr or non delivery
    11/06/2007 14:29
    Jas, MP3 and those answering in similar lines It is not about ESCOM's ability to deliver enough electricity. It is about doing (indirectly) your bit for the environment. Or can your money, which you obviously enjoy wasting, buy the environment back once it is destroyed as well? - Tongue in Cheek
     
      put it into practice how?
    11/06/2007 14:40
    I live in an old block of flats- recently converted to prepaid- very low consumption- but pay high consumption rates- R3.10 a day before using any current!How do I fit a timer in when my landlord wont even convert my 3phase meter?I pay average R350 a month- no heaters, cook once a day and cannot switch the geyser off because the box is still wrought iron with bolts!We want to save but it means moving house to do so. - Fiona
     
      Who responds?
    11/06/2007 14:42
    I would like to know, who responds to the Power Alert messages on television and if you indeed do respond, what do you actually switch off? I've replaced all my 60W lamps with CFLs. But ito switching off, my munic installed a relay on my geyser so switching off the geyser during peak times would not reduce the geyser-load in any way. Heater, don't have one, only a wood fire in my kaggel. - CEM
     
      More wear and tear?
    11/06/2007 14:42
    Like "Blonde" before me, I would also like to know whether this constant on-and-off-switching would actually increase the wear and tear on the geyser. Does anyone know? - Mark
     
      Geyser Elictricty Saving
    11/06/2007 14:56
    I must agree with Andrew. I have manually managed my geyser usage (i.e. switch on for max 2 hours per day)for the past 12 months and changed all light bulbs in my house to low-energy. After correcting for rate increases, my average Eskom consumption and bill have decreased by over 38%. If for no other reason, in this time of increasing lending rates one would assume that the monthly saving of between R150 and R250 on electricity should be incentive enough to cut back on electricity. - David Claase
     
      Wear and Tear
    11/06/2007 14:59
    The On Off factor would actually be decreased should you make use of a managament system. When one considers a geyser on permanently it will be switched on for 10 mins out of 60(See article) by the thermostat. this means that for the period 5am to 8pm it will turn on and off 15 times versus just 4 using a geyser managament system. The only difference is what would trigger the geyser thermostat or managament system. - Craig
     
      Wear and tear : Mark and Blonde
    11/06/2007 15:01
    To my knowledge no, it won't. A geyser is designed to switch on-and-off constantly during a day. Like Andrew said, about 10minutes every hour (but might even be less). So for this argument that is 24 times during a day. But if you switch your geyser manually on-and-off 2 times a day; that's only 2 times a day - 22 times less! So you are actually reducing the times the geyser switches on-and-off during a day! - Answer
     
      my bad
    11/06/2007 15:25
    Pardon my uneducated comment. I am much wiser now, thank you! I would like to try this wonderful saving suggestion but sadly I can't. I live in a complex. Perhaps this type of information you are all giving out needs to be channelled to body corporates where the savings would be far more effective. Also could possibly afford solar heating? - MP3
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     
    VEHICLE SEARCH
    TOYOTA
    2007
    Yaris 1.3 T3 Plus 5-dr
    R119990
    PEUGEOT
    2003
    206 SW XS 1.6 Estate
    R89995
    NISSAN
    2006
    Almera 160 Luxury
    R79990
    PEUGEOT
    2005
    407 ST Comfort 2.0 HDi Dsl
    R159200
    BMW
    2007
    X3 2.0d E83 4x4 Dsl
    R335000
    JAGUAR
    2005
    X-Type 2.0 V6 SE AT
    R169900
    FORD
    2007
    Fiesta 1.4 Base 5-dr MY06
    R98900
    FORD
    2002
    FIESTA FLAIR 1.3i 5Dr
    R49900
    BMW
    2008
    750Li E65 AT
    R785000

     

    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    SA TV Online
    Best Car Deals
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Car Servicing & Repair
    Piggs Peak Casino