Aids crisis overblown?
Experts are complaining that Aids is eating up funding at the expense of more pressing health needs.
Defined by sexuality
Although she battles to accept her mother as a sex worker, Patrica still wants to make her proud...
Search News24
     South Africa : News Get News24 on your mobile Terms & conditions 
Homepage
South Africa
News
Politics
Aids Focus
Xenophobia
Africa
World
Sport
Entertainment
Sci-Tech
Finance
Health
Galleries
 
SA Politics
Zimbabwe
Aids Focus
More...
 
MyNews24
Columnists
Sports Columnists
Feedback
 
National Lottery
UK Lottery
Travel
Competitions
Horoscopes
TV Guides
Classifieds
Food
 
Sudoku
Aces High
Silly Solitaire
Word Cube
Make 24
Golf Solitaire
Battleship
More games
 
Stidy
The Biggish Five
Treknet
 
Newsletters
Weather

Cape Town:
17-22°C

Durban:
20-25°C

Johannesburg:
16-27°C

Weather Page

Traffic
Gauteng KwaZulu-Natal Eastern Cape Western Cape
All regions
Indicators
Rand/$ 10.2600
Rand/£ 15.1300
Rand/€ 13.0000
Gold/oz $776.82
Gold Mining 1936.67
-1.38%
All-share index 19113.28
-3.05%
 
Jock, Chop or Frock?
Vote in the Wheels24 Alternative Car of the Year Awards and you could win R15 000! Enter now!

 
Afrikaans
English

400 000 SMSs against crime
29/01/2007 23:49  - (SA)  

Want to know more?
Answerit can help.
  • SA denies buying time on crime
  • SA denies buying time on crime
  • Minister moots conscription
  • DA wants crime-specific stats
  • Victim sues crime minister
  • Victim sues crime minister
  • ANC: Help govt to fight crime
  • 'State must reduce crime'
  • 'State must reduce crime'
  • Crime: Mbeki 'out of touch'
  • Mbeki: Crime not out of hand
  • Crime 'is making dogs fat'
  • Crime 'is making dogs fat'
  • Marlise Scheepers, Beeld

    Johannesburg - Several hundred thousand South Africans have spoken out on crime via SMS, and the majority feel that it is plain out of control.

    The SMS poll was launched on SABC2, on Tim Modise's show Lekgotleng le Modise. By early Monday, 400 000 SMS messages had been sent, said the company that provides the service.

    They say it's the biggest poll of its kind so far.

    Viewers are asked each Monday evening to give their views on the subject under discussion on the show.

    On Monday last week, viewers were asked to send an SMS if they thought crime was out of control in South Africa.

    Only those who agreed were to respond.

    Swell of messages

    Since Friday last week, there was a huge swell of messages, and people were SMS-ing each other in order to get the maximum response.

    It spread like wildfire, with even London-based South Africans responding.

    Paulo do Carmo, executive chief of Marketel, the suppliers of the SMS service, said that messages had been pouring in since Friday.

    "Last week, we were getting around 300 to 400 a day, about the usual average, but since Friday the taps have opened.

    "I've never seen such a remarkable knock-on effect. We experienced record feedback, here.'

    He said people could send the SMS more than once, but this could be picked up in the statistics, "and it wasn't really a factor".

    Innovation

    When he announced the results of the poll at 20:00 on Monday night, Modise said that when the production team were transferring the data of the results from Marketel, the system crashed.

    The last officially verifiable figure was 352 000.

    The question put was simple and viewers just had to respond with a "yes", but there was eventually quite a bit of innovation.

    The original SMS message read: "If you think crime is out of control in South Africa, SMS 'Yes' to 33588 - a poll for the Tim Modise programme."

    Later, an SMS was circulated with the expanded message: "Please send to as many people as possible and show Mbeki is wrong. Take a stand against crime."

    People also used e-mail messages to whip up support.

    Result 'not valid'

    Richard Rice of Synovate South Africa, who conducts research on opinion polls and quality, said the result was not valid because the question had become more loaded and emotion had been whipped up.

    "The result will also not reflect the entire population because there are many people who don't have access to cellphones or TV," he said.

    "But there is a clear message in the tempo and the number of people who took part."

    In response, Do Carmo emphasised that the SMS poll had been an instant poll.

    - Beeld



    What is this?
    Yahoo Digg Del.icio.us Facebook Brought to you by OUTsurance Car Insurance
     
    News24 Headlines on your Facebook profile News24 on mobile  
     
         
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 00:12
    I am glad. i can sms 50 sms to my family/friend/collegues. I agree that crime is out of control. DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT! other more people will die every day. - DRP
     
      Crime Out Of Control
    30/01/2007 00:29
    Yes, crime is totally out of control! I am however a bit disturbed to think that maybe somebody made a quick million out of peoples emotions running high at the moment. What was the cost of the SMS Marketel???? - joe
     
      Crime is out of Control
    30/01/2007 00:38
    Mr Richard Rice of Synovate I challenge you to run this poll again if you strongly feel this poll was not accurate I am sure you would definately receive an even more amazing result that one received today.Do it for the 100's of South African's that have lost their lives and let the public know. Cheers - Kasy Aboo
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 01:19
    Maybe now the government will realise that they cannot pull the wool of our eyes and that we are ALL GATVOL! Time for them to wake up and do something already ? CO - Cheryl
     
      Yes
    30/01/2007 07:22
    YES!!!! Of course it will raise many emotions, doesn't matter how the question is asked. The People voted and the People are right. - Ange
     
      The poll was a rhetorical question...
    30/01/2007 07:36
    Of course crime is out of control! Not a single morning goes by that my inbox does not have a News24 headline on farm murders, rape, torture or hijacking. Next the government will tell us these stories are fabrications?! Wake up, Mr Mbeki. - Andries
     
      Crime
    30/01/2007 07:37
    What are they talking about the results not being valid? Show me one person older than 18 that does not have a cellphone in this country! - Herman
     
      400 000 sms against crime
    30/01/2007 07:42
    As this is a SMS numer that levies a charge where is the money going ? Also it would ne noce to see if the President took the time to send an sms. - Pearl
     
      Crime is ridiculous!
    30/01/2007 08:06
    Is Mbeki blind AND deaf??? Does he read the news? Does he watch TV? Can he not really see what is going on in SA!?? Thousands of people are being killed, raped and attacked, while he sits on his throne and dares to tell normal South Africans like you and me that crime is not bad!!?? Wake up Mr President - no matter how much you would like to believe that your country is riddled with crime, it's the number one factor why everyone's leaving!! Do you want to leave a legacy of being ignorant? - Disappointed
     
      Crime
    30/01/2007 08:07
    Why is it that only when a celebrity is a victim that SA wants to take a stand? What about all the other celebrities in their own house? The best dad, the most wonderful mom, the most talented son and/or daughter, killed, slaughtered, mugged, attacked and raped on a daily base, but that is nothing compared to a celebrity???!!!! Crime is out of control. Face it!!! Only then can we do something about it. - yvt
     
      Invalid
    30/01/2007 08:10
    I heard Tim Modise on 702 on Monday morning and he denied that he or his show or the SABC had anything to do with the poll. Now he is announcing the results on his TV show. Who knows who to believe these days. I do agree though that crime is killing our country and Thabo Mbeki must be look at SA through some extremely rose tinted glasses. - SF
     
      Crime - Challenge Richard Rice
    30/01/2007 08:12
    I challenge Richard Rice of Synovate South Africa to launch a poll which is acceptable to him and he will receive the same results if not more. Then he can have a 'VALID POLL' - Louiza Frohlich
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 08:18
    "The result will also not reflect the entire population because there are many people who don't have access to cellphones or TV,". I don't agree, because even the lowest income earner owns a sellphone. Wake up and smell reality - crime is way out of control! - HB
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 08:24
    To say that the result is not valid because emotions came into it is unbelievable. It is because crime is being ignored and people are feeling helpless, that emotions have become a huge driving force in our society. It would be prudent not to ignore this fact. Regardless of color or race, there are a multitude of people in this country who just cannot stomach this crime wave any longer. Something has to be done. - Hannelie van Heerden
     
      Where are the race card players now?
    30/01/2007 08:34
    To those who always play the race card. Where are you now? This poll is a general question to all South Aricans. Is this reaction going to polarise the nation? NO! All of us are now getting to a point where we cannot take it anymore. - LM
     
      CRIME OUT OF CONTROL
    30/01/2007 08:44
    Violent crimes are way out of control and it is about time SANDF get involved, these criminals are getting ruthless so we have to fight fire with fire. - Sydney Ludere
     
      Crime
    30/01/2007 08:45
    Silence on crime is silent terrorism, look it is happening! - MS
     
      Cry the beloved country
    30/01/2007 08:46
    In the USA 11000.00 people are murdered every year (one of the worst in the world) Canada average 670 murders (90% family or friends) South Africa 46 000 and that's if we are being given all the stats. Rape: 1 in 3 women in south africa, car accidents deaths one of the worst in the world. Wow if that's under control, then i guess HIV does not cause Aids and showers and beetroot do cure Aids. MORONS RUN THIS COUNTRY - Alfred Shelver
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 08:51
    My three-year-old nephew was driving with me in my car a week ago when I got pulled over by a traffic officer. As soon as he saw the officer's pistol he looked terrified and asked whether the man is going to kill us now. Please wake up Mr Mbeki, you are killing this wonderful country by ignoring a problem that a three-year-old can see. - Disappointed
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 08:53
    What do you mean is crime out of control. Crime is in control just look at the reception Yengeni got, our deputy vice president's actions and how about the travelgate MPs who are still in office! To mention a few. - Russell
     
      Crime
    30/01/2007 08:55
    I think the government wants the crime to stay like this. But one cannot help wondering when people are going to take the law into their own hands... I wonder what they will do if all the educated people leave the country because of all the crime - try hosting 2010 then? - Ice
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 09:00
    If a snap survey is not unacceptable, then perhaps they should ask "Who has been robbed, hijacked, raped, mugged and attacked in the last 12 months?" Sadly we cannot ask the nearly 20 000 that were murdered! - RS
     
      Tell us where the sms money went to - else we're victims of a scam
    30/01/2007 09:05
    I challenge the Beeld to find out on behalf of 400 000 of us, where over half a million rands worth of the sms generated money is going? I made a few calls but can't find out who the 33588 number belongs to. - NAW
     
      Racist Campaign
    30/01/2007 09:10
    Tim will simply say that the campaign was influenced by racists and, therefore, that it is statistically invalid... BTW, does ANYONE really believe that an SMS campaign is going to make ANY difference. Wake up and smell the coffee people...Oops! Sorry. The coffee was stolen in an armed robbery... - Senor Neek
     
      Statistically
    30/01/2007 09:21
    Looking at it from a statistical point of view... You cannot say you've reached X amount of people and Y amount chose to respond. BUT 400000 smss tell a tale, that no statistitian can ignore. So statistically the poll is not worth the airwaves it went through, but what interests me is how many people respond to these polls usually? 2 000? Maybe 4 000? The response is 100x bigger than that. With such a high number of people smssing you'll definately cross several racial divides. - Reenen
     
      Crime out of control
    30/01/2007 09:23
    It is emotional for any law-abiding citizen to see that their country is spiralling out of control where crime is concern. If it doesn't affect you emotionally then maybe you are not passionate enough to be a citizen of SA - FB (Midrand) - FB
     
         
    This comments facility is now closed.
     

     

    About us | Advertise | Contact us | Job opportunities | Press Releases | Site map

    Back to top
     Jobs
    Financial Accountant
    Gauteng - North/Sandton
    Engineering
    Financial Planner
    Gauteng - North/Sandton
    Engineering
    Senior Business Analyst
    Gauteng
    IT / Telecomms
    Senior IT Audit
    Gauteng
    Accounting / Finance / Auditing
     Sponsored links
    Life Insurance
    Car Insurance
    UK Lottery
    First for Women
    Your Homeloan
    Bid or Buy
    Medical Aid
    Education
    Loans & Credit Cards
    Compare Quotes
    Life Insurance for Women
    Audio, TV, GPS & PS3 etc
    Car Servicing & Repair
    Win up to R1000 free!