|
DNA match '99.999% certain'
01/08/2007 15:15 - (SA)
Scottburgh - DNA tests have positively linked two men with the rape of three Durban woman on the KwaZulu-Natal south coast, the Scottburgh High Court heard on Wednesday.
Forensics expert Huibrecht Botha told the court that DNA testing of blood samples taken from Sithembiso Shelembe, 23, and Wonder Mchunu, 26, had linked the two men to the rape victims, two cigarette butts and a semen stain on a piece of cloth.
Shelembe and Mchunu, along with Mthokozisi Mbambo, 29, are accused of raping three Durban woman at a beach-house in Pennington, south of Scottburgh, on December 29 last year.
The three are also accused of attacking and robbing a Gauteng couple later that night.
Botha explained that according to statistical analysis it was nearly impossible for the DNA profile of Shelembe and Mchunu to be linked to another person.
"If we go and test 25 trillion people, we can expect one person to have the same profile (as Shelembe)."
She pointed out that there "were only 6.5 billion people in the world". 99.999% certainty
DNA recovered from saliva on two cigarette butts, a cloth and that retrieved from two of the women, matched the DNA taken from Shelembe.
She said that it was a 99.999% certainty that the DNA was that of Shelembe. "There is a 99.999% exclusion."
The DNA from Mchunu was retrieved from one of the women.
However, Mbambo's DNA did not match any of the samples sent by investigating officers and the district surgeon to the police laboratory in Pretoria.
She said Shelembe's DNA that was also found on the cloth was mixed with another person's DNA. Suspect 'wiped himself down'
In testimony on Tuesday, one of the women testified that she had been raped twice by Shelembe and that after raping her he had wiped himself down.
"He rubbed himself off against it (the cloth) and also wiped me off with it," she said.
Earlier in the day the defence counsel for the three accused said their clients claimed that their alleged victims had seen pictures of their clients prior to the identification parade.
This emerged during cross-examination of the woman's testimony.
Advocate Abdul Khan said: "He (Mchunu) believes that you had sight of photographs taken of him by Inspector Basil Crouse and other policemen."
"I did not see such photographs before the line-up or after the line-up," the woman replied. Weapons On Tuesday she testified that each time she objected to being kissed by Shelembe while she was being raped for a second time, Shelembe pressed a silver Smith and Wesson revolver to her head.
Khan questioned how the woman was unable to remember what weapons Mbambo and Mchunu had in their possession.
"I was distracted by other things happening that evening," she replied.
Advocate Dean Govender questioned the procedures surrounding the identification parade.
The young woman described how she had "almost immediately" identified Shelembe at the identification parade held in early January.
Another of the three women was expected to testify on Wednesday afternoon.
|