Super 14 blues and Bok advice

03/03/2008 09:49

Gary Boshoff

Apart from the Sharks, the South African Super 14 franchises experienced another terrible weekend. I guess many of us are already eating our words after daring to make predictions before the start of this year's competition!

Though we're only at round three, things are looking ominous for the Bulls, Cheetahs, Stormers and the Lions, all of whom are lingering in the bottom half of the log.

What makes the situation worse is that all of our teams still have to go on the four- and in some cases, five-match tours down under. The overseas leg of the competition will also be the part that makes or breaks the Sharks. Apart from the Blues all their tough games are overseas.

I predicted that the Sharks would lose at Loftus (they then smashed the Bulls) and against the Blues next week. If they can beat the Blues, they will still be in with a shot at the semis, even if they lose all their overseas games. Let's hope they can pull this one through as well.

Top flight

I guess the Springbok coach (It is safe to call him that at last after it was announced that he reached an agreement with Saru on the terms of his contract) is already regretting his statement that three South African sides could make it to the Super 14 playoffs.

That's Peter de Villiers for you; never afraid to speak his mind and as always, positive about South African rugby. I have as of late consistently maintained that De Villiers deserves a shot at the national coaching position because he has proved that he has what it takes to be successful at the top flight of South African rugby.

That opportunity has now come his way, not because someone has done him a favour, but simply because he has proved himself at the highest competitive levels of the game internationally and is one of a few coaches that genuinely understand the plight of black players, coaches and administrators in South Africa.

He faces a huge challenge though, a challenge I am sure he is up for and which he will grab with both hands. Notwithstanding this, he would do well to keep the following in mind as he embarks on his project to build another winning Springbok side:

Modesty - while De Villiers is not someone that minces his words when it comes to transformation and all the controversial aspects of the South African game, he would do well to keep in mind that ultimately he will be measured by the results of the national team (read win as opposed to lose).

It is important that he comes to learn and understand the limitations of his position and how far he as the coach will be able to push the envelope.

It always looks easier from the outside looking in! I certainly would like De Villiers to succeed - talking will however not make him a successful Springbok coach. Perhaps the time has now come for him to retreat from the media and start working on the tough job of putting a winning team together.

Power - with the position of Springbok coach comes a lot of power - power to decide which players are going to get a chance to play for South Africa and yes, which players are going to get a second chance!

Jake White resurrected the careers of Percy Montgomery, Jaco van der Westhuyzen and Os du Randt. He even gave Kobus Visagie and Andre Snyman another shot at the Springbok jersey! De Villiers will also have the final say on the match 22, a huge responsibility - the same power that White had.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that as the national coach De Villiers will have the power to influence the future of talented youngsters, black and white; transformation and opportunity; and a lot of other aspects of the game. However, he must accept that how he does that will be scrutinised, analysed and criticised by the rugby public - by friends and foes alike.

The important thing is not the fact that he'll have power, the important aspect for us would be to see how he uses that power to produce the desired results.

Reason - this has become something that South African rugby supporters more often than not, tend to avoid. We are passionately emotional about our teams and players, ignoring the facts and even reality at times.

As coach of the Springboks, De Villiers cannot allow his passion to succeed and his passion for South African rugby to derail his integrity as our number one authority on the game.

Making statements that three South African sides could make it to the Super 14 semis was ill-informed and my guess is it came from his belief that the teams can actually make it. However, beliefs must be supported by logic and clarity of reason and at the time various rugby pundits could not find any justification for that statement. The recent performances of our teams has borne that out.

De Villiers is a great coach and the right appointment at the right time for Saru. However, he has to realise that he carries the hopes of thousands of black and white, but especially black, rugby players, as he embarks on this epic journey.

I for one certainly hope that De Villiers rises to the challenge and delivers a winning Springbok team that all South Africans can be proud of.

  • Gary Boshoff is a former Saru player and well-known rugby administrator.

  • Send Gary your thoughts

    Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

    Sport24

    COMMENTS

    padkos says: De Villiers
    03/03/2008 10:19
    You are not the only one hopping that he gets it right, every Springbok Supporter hopes so to. Even those that bitch and moan the whole time also. i believe in givving someone a change, after a year then I will judge him, not before.

    RugbyStudent says: Still looks good...
    03/03/2008 10:29
    A team of: 15.) Frans Steyn 14.) JP Pietersen 13.) Jacque Fourie 12.) Jean de Villiers 11.) Bryan Habana 10.) Butch James 9.) Fourie du Preez 8.) Danie Rossouw 7.) Juan Smith 6.) Schalk Burger 5.) Victor Matfield/Johan Muller 4.) Bakkies Botha 3.) CJ van der Linde 2.) John Smit 1.) Guthro Steenkamp still looks good to me and a team I will put up against the best in the world.

    The Truth says: Peter de Villiers "our number one authority on the game"?!
    03/03/2008 10:30
    With all due respect to the man,I think a few people in South Africa would beg to differ with you on that one.

    Realist2 says: Fact
    03/03/2008 10:32
    De Villiers made this statement based on the talent which was presented pre Super14. Now we have Dollie sidelined to WP, after all said that he was the best support to Grant. Grant now suddenly being the best flyhalf in SA, yet he failed to use the backline in all his games. Rose being brought on intermiddently being trown into the deep end. I still say give the black players a better chance, the same you are giving to kleinbaas Steyn, who suddenly plays FullBack, is this to get rid of Conrad Jantjies as Bok back?

    Denzil says: SA teams in Super 14.
    03/03/2008 10:47
    Hi Gary, Do you know of any bookmakers that will give me decent odds for 3 South African teams propping up the Super 14 log?

    Benzo says: performance
    03/03/2008 10:54
    I thought loosing matches was all part of the transformation plan that top administrators and government have approved. Give it a few years and things will be all black and right!

    Ron says: Spectators lost
    03/03/2008 11:12
    Yes, it's only 3 rounds of S14 and ELV's and already I'm rather having a braai then watching. Never mind the players or colour, what is the Coach going to look like with players not even knowing which rules to use next in 'the heat of battle'! Fell sorry for the poor oke, but don't think I'll be watching. There must be golf on somewhere!

    Skiballas says: The great...
    03/03/2008 11:18
    The great black hope succeeds the great White hope. At the end of the day, lets just hope for a winning Bok team. They can have 15 blacks players on the pitch, as long as they win, or at least play attractive and competitive rugby. I would like to see de Villiers stand up and support the Bok emblem. That will win him alot of support from the so called white public and players, not to mention respect.

    lee says: Sa teams swak!
    03/03/2008 11:19
    Sa teams do not have the skills 2 make it in the s14. Their handling has always been poor, cant pass good to either side. Most passes(which should have been tries) this weekend proves my statement.Why does it take 3/4 people to takle 1 player? Obviously that creates space/gaps for the opposition. This happens week in and week out, but nobody sees this.Murray was coverd by Demas, so what does Kircner do? easy try for Sharks.SA teams have a talent to make NZ teams look good.Why does Sa teams work their way to the oppositions 22, only to kick it away?? NZ, AUS teams keeps the ball in hand untilll penalty or a try comes, but not us.Why run into a player if u could just run in the space next 2 him? Gives u more momentum to get over advantage line.Our players cant think. No SA team in the last 4 i am afraid.

    Mveleli says: Peter de Villiers
    03/03/2008 11:32
    Well said Gary moreso on the issues of reason and modesty. I fully agree with you on the timing of his appoinment. We as the public of South Africa, the Rainbow nation, we need to support him and also give him a chance to succeed, something I am sure of he will succeed.

    CVM says: what do you expect???
    03/03/2008 11:34
    SARFU already stuffed up everything - making SA rugby a joke after all the Jake White games. Not to mention that half our players are seeking "propper" fortune overseas, they are obviously tired of all the nonsense thats going on here - MAYBE this is the wakeup call (sign again) that is needed-The real question is - how many wakeup call are needed?? Good luck Pieter de Villiers - We are Still loyal and passionate -and behind you every step of the way

    Jeremy van Zyl says: What are you on about?
    03/03/2008 11:47
    That opportunity has now come his way, not because someone has done him a favour, but simply because he has proved himself at the highest competitive levels of the game internationally and is one of a few coaches that genuinely understand the plight of black players, coaches and administrators in South Africa. He has not proven himself at the highest level. Heyneke Meyer should have been named coach, he just gothe job because he is black. Everybody knows that. You're an idiot Gary.

    Realist2 says: FACT
    03/03/2008 12:27
    Not all the talent are presented at Sup14 level, giving P DeVilliers a tough choice as to who to select for the Bok team. All the forwards play so kak and the backline do not get a chance to get the ball. The fact is that this display is a good measure as to how the Boks will perform immaterial of who gets Bok Colours. The only way to safe face is to give the blacks a chance and play the ELV's use it in your favour and drop KleinBaas Steyn.

    LJB says: Gary
    03/03/2008 12:29
    Why shoudn't De Villiers have been confident of SA teams doing well in the Super 14. After all 2 SA teams were in the last finals and the Boks won the world cup. Of course someone did De Villiers a favour. Did you not hear and see Oregon Hoskins media staement when De Villiers's appointment was announced. As for the hopes of thousands of black and white rugby players ..... They shoudn't be hoping to play. If they're the best they should/Will play. All being equal.

    archie says: Well stated Jeremy
    03/03/2008 12:40
    Well stated Jeremy, i couldnt agree more. Both with the new coach getting the job and the fact that Gary is an idiot. It seems he bends his words to support his "transformation" coach. Changing things quotes from 3 SA teams would be in the final to "should" be in the final.

    Mavericks says: Cant understand why
    03/03/2008 12:54
    You say "but especially black, rugby players". Why the hell. You don't see white people in the USA basketball team. Why do we have to force transformation? If the player is the best in the position then he must play there. South Africa is a free country aren't we. So just because black are ruling everything now the rugby team must also be black. You fools look at the bigger picture. George Bush doesn't want a white basketball team. He wants a winning one. Wake up and open your God dam eyes and stop showing everybody around the world how pathetic our government is. The wheels is coming off slowely but surely and we wont be able to put it back. Sorry but its true. You know it

    Doorboot says: Shark revenge
    03/03/2008 13:21
    As a Shark supporter the revenge over the weekend was very sweet. So I am happy that you were once again wrong Gary. As to De Villiers and favours, stop smoking pot and realise that he was given a job he is ill quilified for. Lets hope he proves most of us sceptics wrong. I would gladly eat my words. But allas I fear that he will ruin our game. By the way where is the representation in our National coaching staff? All of the national coaches are black.

    RugbyStudent says: Stunned
    03/03/2008 13:47
    I'm a bit stunned at most of you people. If Heyneke Meyer wanted the job so much, why did he withdrew, the last time he applied? He didn't even want to apply and was asked to for the current one. Now suddenly he is a torn up man? You idiots and couch coaches are the same ones who gave Jake White a vote of no confidence, so excuse me if I don't hold your opinions in high regard.

    Realist2 says: Cant Understand Why-Maverick
    03/03/2008 14:21
    Let me tell you why-Dollie has been sidelined to teh WP team and will not be performing on Super 14 level and you tell me why. Now how the hell can the statement still be made that Grant is the best when he clearly did not perform in all three games. He is the key to get the ball to the backline and get the ELV rules to work for the team yet the Stormers lost, why because he is not the best. Is Dollie equal or better, well we will not know because he has been sidelined for Goodness Know Why or maybe we should ask Bush.

    HEar Hear says: corne
    03/03/2008 14:21
    By the way where is the representation in our National coaching staff? All of the national coaches are black. Well said!!!

    Transfom says: Why all the noise
    03/03/2008 15:18
    Undoing what coloniast and apartheid did to sport in SA over decades will take decades also. De Villiers deserves the position as much as White did when he became coach. Why not use the rule changes to introduce transformation at large at least then the S14 teams have reason(excuses) to lose, because these predominantly white S14 teams are losing everyweek in any case. Mind you a predominantly black team may even win more often then these premadonnas would, these "groot manne" are inflexible in more ways than one and cant adapt to nothing. the way white played and meyer played their teams would also struggle with the ELV's.

    This comments facility is now closed.
  •