Afcon offers exciting viewing

06/02/2008 09:41

George Dearnaley

My thanks to all those who provided feedback to last week's column. If anything it showed that there are a lot of people in this country who are passionate about SA football. Our challenge is always to try and balance our criticism of the negative with our appreciation of the positive.

Most of the feedback was fuelled by a disappointment in our national team's performance at the Afcon. But in general it seems most of us agree that fingers should not be pointed at the individual players or the coaching staff - the problems exist higher up in the boardrooms of our official structures. Lack of planning, lack of youth development programmes, lack of consistency in our coaching policies and in our focus on the game, and not the money in the game, have all contributed to this malaise.

There was some criticism of my opinion, and everyone is entitled to have a go, but one or two suggested that I go back and support my "beloved England"! I am speechless. I support Manchester United, AmaZulu and Bafana Bafana - I hate England! My dad is Scottish. Please keep the insults fair.

Minimum level of qualification

Lastly with regards last week's column, there were quite a few comments about the influence of cheap foreigners in our local league, and the impact they have had on the development and progress of our local youngsters.

I think it's fair to argue that there should be a minimum level of qualification for a foreign player to be signed by a local club. Foreign players should at least have a minimum number of international caps. There are too many clubs signing up cheap labour and hoping to sell them on in a few seasons to make some cash. But this does nothing for our youth development as our own youngsters are forced to sit on the sides watching our continental opposition gaining experience. There's a lot to be done if we hope to get ourselves back among the continents' elite.

Physical football is a joy

When Ghana's Junior Agogo ripped off his jersey after scoring against Nigeria in their Afcon quarter-final, there were more than a few heavyweight boxers who flinched in their boots. The man is built like a tank! John Mensah and Michael Essien are solid as well. The Nigerians, Ivorians, Angolans and Tunisians who have given their all, have combined great skill with brute force.

Cameroon and Egypt have not been as physical, but have got stuck in when needed. There has been a lot of brute force used to win tackles, shield the ball and create space in tight areas.

The hard fields and the high temperatures have also meant that players have had to rely a lot more on their physical conditioning, and that great technique is not enough at this level.

Excited

There were moments during the Egypt v Angola match that were breathless. Quick attacking movement with great touch and technique. The combination of pace and physical strength is definitely an asset of African football. The one obvious weakness has been the sometimes amateurish defending that has allowed soft goals. There have been some bad goalkeeping mistakes, but in general I have been very impressed with the goalkeepers.

I think there has been a lot to be excited about as an African football fan.

South Africa and Nigeria's poor performances aside, the standard has been very good. There have been some magnificent goals and some great performances by some of the biggest stars on the planet.

Champions of Africa

I'm still not convinced the Afcon should take place every two years. I think it should be every four years. But I think there should be an African tournament every two years but only for players based in Africa. This would give great exposure to the local based players and will also avoid the club v country conflict for the overseas-based players.

My money is still on Ivory Coast to win it, although Egypt are capable of surprising us all. Whoever wins it though, will thoroughly deserve the title of champions of Africa.

  • George is the associate publisher of Kick Off magazine and represented South Africa during the 1994 World Cup qualifiers.

  • Send George your thoughts

    Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

    Kickoff

    COMMENTS

    Ken says: Bafana
    06/02/2008 10:15
    The comments posted by one Johan stating that "drama is part of black culture" are both puzzling and illustrate a level of ignorance and/or maliciousness. The fact that certain soccer players tend to showboat has got little to do with their colour e.g. Maradona loved the extravagant as does Messi and even Beckham in his earlier days. Soccer is a show and the performers want to show their skills. When are these colour obsessed people, who got every advantage under the sun because of their skin colour in the past, going to show a semblence of maturity which tackles issues without resorting to a mindset which keeps them in the stone age?

    RS4fan says: AFCON and Chanpions League!
    06/02/2008 10:29
    well George i do think that physical approch of our african brothers is definitely an advantage but SA is also suffering from not taking the champions league or anyother african club competition serious. A team like Tunisia is gaining valuable insight and experience from these competitions as they are constantly arcitipating through their clubs!

    Enoch says: Soccer
    06/02/2008 10:29
    I think SAFA should stop changing coach everey season rather it should extend peirod of coaching from two to eight years.

    Benzo says: Afcon
    06/02/2008 10:31
    I watched the Cameroun - Tunisia game and enjoyed every minute. Fast, aggressive, will to win, technically OK and brilliant at times. As far as SA goes: sit back and regroup. Forget 2010. Use Carlos Perreira to train as many coaches and as many junior players through football academies. After he has left, use his salary to continue the work.

    Les-Maada says: Football & strength
    06/02/2008 10:46
    Our national coach once said that football is not all about physical strength but technique,determination peppered with skill as a bonus.Are u implying that our boys should look(way u put it)solid to conquer all or were u just impressed by Agogo & crew muscles..? just asking!

    VLS says: AFCON 2008
    06/02/2008 11:24
    Georgie to be honest the truth is that the rest of the continent has quite simply improved in leaps and bounds since 1996. South Africans can never physically compete with the size of the West Africans. Over the years they have added speed, skill and technique to the equation and we now find ourselves outmatched. Its not that Bafana have gone backwards, frankly some of the players we have today are essentially better than the 1996 generation, but the rest of the continent has finally started to live up to their potential. I suggest we import a Brazilian or two like Portugal and Tunisia did.

    Freddy Ngobe - Nelspruit says: Bafana Bafana
    06/02/2008 11:33
    Hi George. Its true, size and skills count in Africa. Let me, however, mention what i feel are things which are very critical to our success. Look, we cannot help it, msot guys in the SADC region are physically weak. Fact, this is our built, there's nothing we can do about it. I'm told Benedict Vilakazi is straggling in Denmark. But, listern to this. Fabrecas, Robinho, Kaka, Wright Phillips, Ronaldo (United), Messi are not physical giants. Secret, they use techtical discipline and skills combined to achieve the best in football. Most Europeans like most Arab nations in Africa are tactically discipline. It works for them. Out of the three games we played, I think the goal by the Angolan striker (United signing) was brilliant, not all the others. It was pure immaturity by the players. If you cant's score some, then do not give some away. As for the level, Ivory Cost, Ghana, Egypt, Camerron, mostly West African countries make it on top. Mali, Gunie, Angola, Zambia, Tunisia are second best. South ASfrica, Zim, and partners are not convincing. Fine there's worse in the likes of Botswana, Swaziland etc. Please SA work on your techtical discipline and use your skills. Sharp.

    Tletle says: european leagues
    06/02/2008 11:50
    you must feel strange writing about african football instead of your favourite, English football. I was hoping they would get someone with passion for African football than reducing the African footbal to size and strength. There is much more to African football even at this current tornament than size. Is that all you can do: size size size size?

    themba says: Bafana
    06/02/2008 12:21
    George the reduction of foreign players in the PSL is a matter of urgency. where do we expect our youngters to get experience if we dont create oppotunities for them to get it. I disagree with people who say that we dont have big physical players in South Africa, just look at the squad of 1996 and look at the way Kagisho Dikgacoi handled/matched the big players of Senegal in Ghana. We have the resources and the funds to make Bafana Bafana the number one team in AFrica, but because of greediness and power struggle among our administrators it will only remain a dream. We need SAFA to be run by people who are firstly passionate about soccer and not business

    Les says: AFCON 2008
    06/02/2008 12:30
    Hi George, This is not one of your best columns, after reading it i'm not sure what it was trying to highlight that we haven't read about in all the papers and heard on all TV and Radio shows...so cliche! I have always loved your insightful columns. I however trust that your next one will be much better. Regards, Les'.

    Miyoba says: Afcon
    06/02/2008 12:42
    Rightly said, afcon has a good vibe, physical and tactical.Generally, the game on the continent has improved.Secondly, I do not agree hosting afcon every 4 yrs.Reason, if we follow that euro route will not have infrastructure on the continent.Look this pushes new stadia every 2 yrs and is good for the game.Forget following euro plans, this is africa and we do it african.Though, the afcon can move to later in the year not beginning to appease the stakeholder No.1 - players.

    Mpume says: Size Matters
    06/02/2008 12:43
    Off course size matters, even women know that!

    Dumisani Tafeni says: Maintain Our style Of Play
    06/02/2008 13:08
    For me if we can go back and access from our past heros u can absolutly see that we fell behind our standard of the we had.The game we played and our South african game style has vanished long ago.Lets go back and do it right for our Pride and for Our Country.

    Funnybones says: Physical
    06/02/2008 13:21
    George i am still not sold on your argument of physical strength. We should just accept we are naturally build like our fellow africans and try to find things that work for us. Secondly, i have noticed that there is a general lack of maturity from my fellow white commentators when it comes to soccer. Comparing soccer to rugby, or jake white shows a diappointing lack of common sense. Also asking for a whte represantation in soccer demostrates childishness and lack of knowledge of the history of our football.

    Abdul says: Local is not lekker
    06/02/2008 13:28
    Bafana Bafana will not be world class unless the PSL (Supersport and SABC thinks is the best league in the world) is jacked-up. What a load of crap! PS: No comment from Red George about how f.... lucky your team was against the Mighty Tottenham Hotspur on Saturday. The Ramos revolution has truly began!!

    L'vovo says: Afcon
    06/02/2008 13:31
    We start playing afcon every four I think it might have negative impact on FIFA world cup and that it wont do africa any favour. The format of every two years is very good ? until people start taking our tournaments serious the better. Any South Africans have lost touch maybe in twenty years time or when Zuma becomes a president of the country we will perform better. I'm made to belive that SAFA is polotic organization. Was the selection of players participated in Ghana fair? I don?t think so?

    This comments facility is now closed.
  •