Bulls, Stormers poles apart

17/04/2008 10:52

JJ Harmse

What a huge weekend we have ahead of us in Super 14!

In Cape Town, the Stormers need to prove that they are indeed the real deal in 2008 and serious contenders for a change. In Pretoria, the Bulls need to find some face after the disgrace of last weekend and in Canberra, the Sharks will have to prove that they have not used all their 'get out of jail' cards and that they can actually score some tries.

It has been a very long couple of weeks for the Bulls supporters with their team not even a resemblance of the one that filled Loftus last year. I think they will be lucky if they draw 15 000 people on the weekend. The early kick-off may count in their favour, but it is hard to see how they can redeem themselves in the eyes of their supporters after such a shocking performance against the Hurricanes.

Make no mistake, the Wellington-based side can indeed be like their name suggests. That is when they get it right, as they did a couple of times this season, most notably against the Chiefs.

Spectacular demise

The lack of intensity in the Bulls effort though, cannot be ignored, but both Wikus van Heerden and Bryan Habana promised the media on Wednesday that it would not happen again. They are looking at a strong finish to the season and still believe they can finish in the top 10. Of course, that is a poor reflection on their abilities, but a number of things contributed to their spectacular demise this season.

As spectacular as the demise of the Bulls has been, so impressive the Stormers seem to be.

They have a huge weekend against the Hurricanes. The boys from Wellington have won their last two matches at Newlands and coach Colin Cooper hinted at his side finally getting some consistency.

The fact of the matter is that they are beatable. Their scrum has never been dominant, bar their demolition of the Bulls pack last week, but they will have to front up against a Stormers tight five that has not taken a step back against anybody this season.

Crossroads

The vibrant expectation in Cape Town with the style of rugby their side is playing will no doubt manifest itself into a packed stadium. Let us hope the Stormers will, for once, do justice to the expectations.

It will not be the first time in recent years that they started with too much hype and no results. They are at the crossroads of not only a Super 14 season, but also the way coach Rassie Erasmus wants his side to play. Despite the hype, the reality is that they have not really achieved anything,

Looking at their season, they are on the edge of going one way or the other. They have won four of their eight games and scored 168 points to the 147 conceded, giving them a +21 points differential. Their try tally (19) is also pretty average on the log as seven teams have scored more tries so far this season.

Therefore, despite all the good press and ticket sales generated, the Stormers must realise that the hard work is still to come. They can see the light at the end of the tunnel and it is up to them to push all the way. (The Bulls are also seeing the light in the tunnel, but for them, it is an oncoming train).

Winning ugly

It was interesting to note that John Mitchell says winning ugly is now acceptable to him, as long as the Force keep on doing just that. Mitchell used to be one of the coaches who in the past had a lot to say about the way a team plays in order to achieve results and for him to take a victory anyway it comes, shows how cut-throat things are in professional rugby.

Winning is everything at this level and hopefully the Stormers will keep that in mind over the next month or so. The Sharks are battling to score tries, but they remain unbeaten and are winning ugly. It is ironic that they probably have the most philosophical of coaches among the South Africans teams, but they are playing the most boring rugby.

Dick Muir has an almost romantic vision of how the game should be played and the Sharks played like that for most of last season. However, this year they are much more practical in their approach. Maybe the ELVs have had something to do with that

Heads down

The Bulls have finally acknowledged that their failure to embrace the ELVs has been part of their downfall. The Sharks have adapted much better to those changes, but at the cost of attacking rugby.

However, they are winning and that is all that counts. They are looking strong in the semi-final race and should make it. Let us hope the Stormers can keep their heads down and join them. They are not going to disappoint again, surely?

  • Read JJ every Sunday in Rapport.

  • Send JJ your thoughts

    Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

    Sport24

    COMMENTS

    Shark fan says: Pathetic Bulls
    17/04/2008 11:13
    JJ, you simply cannot stand the fact that the Stormers are on a superb roll, and the Bulls are totally pathetic. Was it not you that recently wrote in the Rapport that "the Bulls will surely not lose again this season"? So which Bull chearleader are you??

    PC says: achievements
    17/04/2008 11:19
    The Bulls (defending chumpions)have won two of their nine games and scored 173 points to the 280 conceded, giving them a -106 points difference. The Bulls also have a try tally of 16 for and 36 against. In comparison to that I would say the Stormers have indeed achieved something already. Just look at the difference in attendance this coming weekend.

    Realist2 says: Real Failures
    17/04/2008 11:23
    The Bulls failure to embrace the ELV's is indicative of the fact that they fail to be a true rugby team and has no debt. If it was not for Habana you would never have won the Super14 and surely do not deserve to be Super 14 champs. You being second last on the log is a true reflection of your rugby playing ability and Ludeke must go - start calling for his HEAD.

    Foxie says: Sharks rugby
    17/04/2008 11:24
    I agree with most of what you say, but do not share your optimism about the Sharks. We are for ever reading in the media thing like - "If the can lie 2nd on the log without having played a single good game, imagine what will happen when they really peak!" Rubbish! They have not played a single good match for the simple reason that I believe that this is the best they have to offer. Bad refereeing decisions and the luck of the devil got them to where they are. I really hope that I will swallow these words, but I don't see them getting much further in the S14. My guess is that their bubble will burst, starting this weekend.

    jannie-die-rugbyguru says: JJ Harmse
    17/04/2008 11:36
    JJ, I saw in Sundays Rapport that half the dream Super 14 team you picked, was from the Bulls. I thought you were suppose to pick the current weekends stars!

    aj says: Stormers need to prove they belong in the Semi's
    17/04/2008 11:37
    I absolutely agree. The fact is that if the Cannes, Highlanders, Brumbies or Tahs beat the Stormers at home on Newlands they dont deserve a semi spot. This weekend, with rain predicted, will show us whether the forwards can really take the step and win matches at home when it counts. I for one will be at Newlands screaming them on. Looking forward to some good, hard forward rugby.

    Francois says: Thanks but no thanks
    17/04/2008 11:57
    JJ, we don`t need your advice, nor do we care for what you have to say. If you think Rassie or any of the Stormers give a hoot for what you have to say, you are dreaming bud. Rather worry about your hopeless Bulls or go work on your next article for Rapport where you try your utmost to get Pierre Spies into the Bok side.

    Francois says: Weak journalism
    17/04/2008 12:01
    In Cape Town, the Stormers need to prove that they are indeed the real deal in 2008 and serious contenders FOR A CHANGE. You are so pathetic. There is no reason to add those 3 words. Just shows that you will never be a proper journalist.

    John Smit says: Sharks
    17/04/2008 12:01
    That comment is exactly why Foxy does not write this collumn. Can you imagine putting a winning team down. It doesn't matter how they win, a win is a win and they've done it wher the other teams from SA have been unable to. Get a life Foxy.

    Mike says: To Foxie
    17/04/2008 12:06
    Foxie, don't you think that the play ing conditions have a major influence in the way the game is played... It is going to be interesting to see how the Stormers do if it rains... No more fancy rugby and back to basics...

    VinChainSaw says: Ludeke
    17/04/2008 12:10
    Ludeke has 4 wins from 34 Super Rugby starts as coach. Enoguh said.

    Sarel says: bulls and stormers
    17/04/2008 12:11
    It is actually an embarresment for the Stormers to have them compared to the Bulls. Also the idea of winning a game is to score more points than your opponent even if it is one point more. So all your comments about the Sharks try scoring abbilities are a lot of Bull.

    Bloubuffel says: To Sharks Fan and PC
    17/04/2008 12:12
    Blah blah blah blah,when last did the sharks win ANY trophies???Stop worrying about the bulls and focus on your own team and your sour grape excuses for end of may,again.......

    Juan says: JJ - Spot on
    17/04/2008 12:40
    Dear JJ, I believe there is merrit in your article. The Stormers have achieved nothing, they are at most a middle of the log team. I could not help to notice how Rassie is using players of the ball to protect the ball carrier, if this part of his game plan is exposed by a competent referee, they will have problems & I still believe that they do not have the beef up front to dominate. This netbal/elv's kind of rugby has always suited the boys down south.

    Foxie says: To John Smit
    17/04/2008 12:41
    I say the Sharks will be exposed for what they are no later than THIS weekend. Wanna bet...?

    LM says: Die blou bul eet toe van die vloer af
    17/04/2008 12:45
    JJ never disappoints looking at everything with "blue" goggles on, why not be happy for the stormers and sharks, we dont need to prove anything to you JJ

    ANTHONY ABRAHAMS says: rugby
    17/04/2008 12:46
    THE REALITY IS THAT STORMERS STRUCTURES,PLANS ARE ALL IN PLACE&IT WAS THIS A MATTER OF TIME BEFORE THEY WOULD CHALLENGE FOR A SEMIFINAL PLACE

    Werner says: I just hope ...
    17/04/2008 12:55
    All our teams win this weekend. GO LIONS!

    Stormer says: Super14 final on Saturday
    17/04/2008 12:56
    The Bulls needs to get rid of their useless excuse of a coach. It seems as if the players are making a statement by not playing to their potential. I believe this weekend's match will, in 6 weeks time, be the final as the crusaders are beatable when they play against an in form team..

    Larry says: Clueless "Foxie"
    17/04/2008 12:57
    Foxie u either a Stomers/Bulls fan or have know understanding of rugby. The Sharks are winning ugly yes but who is no.2 on the log? where are the rest of SA sides? Top sides win matches even on their off days and thats exactly what the Sharks do and when they get it right they will blow their opponents & "U" away.

    Mark says: They get paid to play
    17/04/2008 13:06
    JJ, how can a team like the Bulls get paid to play rugby and then use an excuse like "we have not adapted to the ELVs"? It is a professional sport as you say, yet one of our biggest unions use an excuse like that. Come on. That's all the boys do day in day out. Surely that excuse is a load of Bull.

    Shark Supprter says: Respect the Sharks
    17/04/2008 13:15
    Why does everyone criticise the Sharks. You say they are playing boring rugby, Guess what they are still unbeaten.They are better than any other SA rugby team by miles. Atleast one SA team is not an embarrasment.Even if the Sharks field a third string team under Dick Muir, they would still do better than the other SA franchises.People need to stop being sour grapes&start acknowledging that the sharks are SA only hope of winning the Super 14.

    Shark fan says: Sad, Bloubuffel
    17/04/2008 13:17
    It surely is a sign of grappling at straws when one repeatedly has to refer back to a time when your team did relatively well, in an attempt to gain some sort of psychological ascendancy. Truth hurts, doesn't it?

    wp says: To JJ
    17/04/2008 13:18
    your conclusion that the stormers are average is flawed. what you dont take into account with your lovely stats is that of the 8 games played, 5 was away! winning 3 on the road isnt average just ask any of the the new zealand teams (except saders)

    Jack Struwich says: Big mouth wannabe's
    17/04/2008 13:36
    Yeah sure, JJ Harmse normally talks rubbish. But al this abuse at the Bulls is Unnecessary. Yes they have played dismal rugby this year, and heads must roll. But the stormers fans should shut the hell up, you've played good rugby for 2 months but atrocious rugby the last 5 years, and the bulls was vice versa for that period. Good luck to the Sharks and Stormers and lets hope the Bulls will do much better next year. From a South African and Bulls rugby supporter

    Stuart says: Ludek(rous)???
    17/04/2008 13:48
    I find it incredibly frustrating as a South African (and specifically a Sharks) rugby fan to see one of the top sides in the country appoint a coach who has already proven that he can't make it at the top level of the provincial game. That is the very simple explanation for the Bull's failure to adapt to the ELV's. It is a coaching issue and one all Bulls supporters should be questioning. Perhaps, as a friend of mine suggested, Ludeke should be selling cars. Because if he could sell his services to the Bulls management team with his record, then he could sell anything!

    Kevin says: Pathetic JJ
    17/04/2008 13:49
    JJ are you looking for attention with this article? Sort out your own Bulls problems and btw how the .... can you still consider Hougaard as rugby player not even to mention you picking him as our Bok flyhalf. What are you using?

    Mike says: Foxie
    17/04/2008 13:57
    They showed promising signs in their first dry match of some unstoppable backline moves! I think Dick and the Boys are fired up enough to start bringing their A-game so watch the game on Sat if you dare...

    colin says: Sour Grapes JJ
    17/04/2008 14:02
    Sour grapes or what JJ - the Stormers will make the top 4 and the Bulls the bottom 4 of the S14 log 2008. Stormers have proven themselves and play better rugby that the previous years - the Stormers have the ability to win there remaining 5 games, the Hurricanes and the Wharatahs game will be pivotal if they want to advance to the next stage of the tournament.

    TheStormer says: Living in the past
    17/04/2008 14:03
    Come on guys, we all live in the present, and presently the Stormers are hot and the Bulls are not

    Sharkie says: Cancel matches
    17/04/2008 14:10
    Maybe SA Rugby should just cancel all the remaining Bulls games and save South Africa the embarrassment

    Tinus says: jj
    17/04/2008 14:14
    contenders for a change the Stormers seem to be Let us hope the Stormers will, for once Please just write about the Bulls

    Debbie Bohm says: sharks vs blue bulls
    17/04/2008 15:15
    Justice, my friends, justice. The true winners of the Super 14 in 2007 are now showing who the REAL losers were - GO SHARKS!!

    Sick says: S14
    17/04/2008 15:26
    Ai, you know guys. This is most likely the main reason why SA Rugby is in the state it is. You get guys like, JJ, who works for a COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER who is supposed to be IMPARTIAL, and give reports that truly reflects the events but who keeps dishing up excuses why the Bulls are not performing, why the Sharks keep winning and why the Stormers had hit form. Can't we for once forget about all these childish comments and start support SA Rugby. Maybe then things will also be better. And Yes, I am a STORMER!!

    warren says: super 14
    19/04/2008 08:58
    I am a Stormer supporter and I say when the fat lady sings then we will know who was really the best team this year. There might yet be a few surprises. Look what happened to the Crusaders yesterday

    This comments facility is now closed.
  •