Soweto Derby has lost its sting

09/05/2008 10:31

Tumo Mokone

So it's Soweto derby time again... and we are supposed to be excited. But seriously, what's at stake in this match, apart from the solitary fact that it is a league fixture between Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates?

Okay, the winner may finish in the top eight in the standings at the end of the season. This shows the depths to which the biggest football fixture in South Africa has deteriorated. The Soweto Derby no longer has any bearing on the title chase and does not even represent the best of South African football because neither of the two teams are part of what is exciting right now about the game in this country.

There are far more better things happening in the PSL, like the three-horse title race between log-leaders Ajax Cape Town and chasers SuperSport United and Santos.

Slight advantage

This weekend the biggest soccer match for SA will be taking place in Cairo, where unheralded Platinum Stars will be looking to become the first club from southern Africa to eliminate Al Ahly from the African Champions League.

Stars, arguably the smallest club in the PSL, travel to Africa's biggest soccer club with a slight advantage after beating Ahly 2-1 in the first leg. They need all the support they can get back home. But their heroics notwithstanding, the hearts and minds of the SA soccer fraternity, including the media, would be focused on Mafikeng, where the Soweto Derby will be contested.

If Platinum Stars are on the brink of giving SA a historical victory over the mighty Egyptians, a feat which would also attract new respect for South African football, why is the country captivated by a tussle in which there would be no real winner? It appears we are hell-bent on supporting mediocrity over so much that is positive and urgent about our game, all because of the history of the Chiefs v Pirates derby.

Going flat out

When I put these points to my colleagues at work they say I am being a spoilsport. Some accused me of being bitter because Pirates are not winning. Of course it is a sore point that Pirates don't want to win - in fact they have not won anything for six seasons. Just to put the woeful performance of this club in perspective, Pirates did not score a single goal the entire month of April!

What makes me more sick is that, as reluctant as they are about achieving anything, the Pirates players will be going flat out on Saturday to beat Chiefs. They will also be prepared to put a few rules of the game to a test, just in case the referee is asleep so that they can win the game against all odds. Unfortunately all the hard work, the intelligence, mental sharpness, physical conditioning and the stamina the Bucs players will show on Saturday will be put to rest again until the next Soweto Derby.

Gets my vote

Chiefs on the other hand are not that impressive. They are ninth on the log, and they do not have strikers. Their top player last season, Kaizer Motaung jnr, appears like a spent force, while Mabhuti Khenyeza is blooming late in his first season with the club. Ironically, the saving grace for Amakhosi has been their young goalkeeper Itumeleng Khune who is having a super time in his first season as the team's No 1 goalkeeper.

So brilliant has Khune been between the posts that Chiefs have conceded the least number of goals so far in the championship. He is also the reason why Chiefs won a Cup title this season - the Telkom Knockout - in December. Realising their short supply in talent, Chiefs just dragged the matches to extra-time during the Cup, hoping Khune would do the business in the penalty shootout. He did exactly that, including in the final where he stopped three spot kicks by Mamelodi Sundowns. Khune gets my vote for PSL Player of the Season. It's a shame that a goalkeeper should outshine infield players like that.

His closest rival, ironically, is a Pirates player - midfielder Teko Modise. The nippy playmaker had a brilliant season for both Bucs and Bafana Bafana, winning several man of the match awards for both teams. These included the player of the tournament after the 2007 Cosafa Cup in which he led South Africa to a fantastic run and triumph in the southern championship.

Sucker for pain

Unfortunately all good things must come to an end, and so has the form of Modise in the past two months. In fact, his slump mirrors that of his team - which could mean Pirates are a one-man team. It is not clear if he will be available, as injuries and fatigue continue to take their toll.

It's either team's derby to take. I will put my money on Pirates to win, because I am a sucker for pain like that. However, if these two teams conspire to play another drawn match, it will be their loss because South African football will progress without them.

  • Tumo writes exclusively for Sport24.

  • Send Tumo your thoughts

    Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

    Sport24

    COMMENTS

    T.I Mofokeng says: the chiefs- pirates derby
    09/05/2008 11:07
    i would like to cast my vote of concern over the chiefs- pirates derby, the mojo and the sparks the game between chiefs and pirates used to bring to the face of many soccer lovers in south africa is now a past thing, i mean the way in which supporters have lost intrest in watching the derby is a perfact sign that the derby is no longer the same. the reason behind these assumptions being the fact that both teams have become more predictable than ever, in recent games between chiefs and pirates, games ended in draws, very dramatic draws but the very same thing continues to happen then people started to doubt the value of the game because they know that the derby will ended up being a draw. trust me when i say tomorrow's game will be of no difference at all.

    Seun says: Derby outdated
    09/05/2008 11:45
    I will not even bother to watch the game on t.v.

    molefe says: Player of the year
    09/05/2008 11:47
    Just because khune stopped some penalities it gives him advantage over Teko thats unfair look Teko has played more games for Pirates and Bafana everytime he plays he play with his heart and soul he is the combination of Vilakazi and John Moeti not forgeting THabo Mngemeni Teko deserve to be the player of the yaer.

    Majozi says: Soweto Derby
    09/05/2008 12:01
    Thanks be given to Motimele Commision for the job well done.Since the commission`s appointment,KC was unable to win games that it previously did with the help of the third force,the referees and are now the club of the past.

    Ledombolo says: Can't agree more
    09/05/2008 12:08
    I have seen how the likes of Man U, Arsenal, Real Madrid Barcelona keep paying millions season in and out regardless of their good perfomances to up game and maintain momentum. I still cannot understand why top teams in the SA fail attract best talent in Africa from Nigeria,Cameroon, Ivory Coast and Ghana. We have the best league in Africa just bad players. Motaung and Khoza to learn a lolt from Motsepe. We deserve better.

    EDDIE says: Soweto Derby
    09/05/2008 12:22
    Tumo, you are quite correct in that note. I say this because I don't see anything exeptional in the so called derby of the best SA teams. What is only left in this encounter is history, nothing else my brother. Teams that need to be commended like you mentioned do not get that.

    Sean says: Re:
    09/05/2008 13:06
    Unfortunately this is indicative of the South African game. The sooner we can get people supporting their regional teams, instead of the obvious clamour for Cheifs and Pirates the sooner the game in SA can expand and become a better league.

    Thokozani says: The so called
    09/05/2008 13:42
    You very right TumO, i'm a proud orlando Pirates supporter, but the way thye have been playing of late live much to be desired. Going to this match i don't know what's gonna happen, but whatever it is , is going to be very embarrassing. But i will watch the game of course, they are still my boys . i guese it as they say..."once a pirate always a pirate"

    Vekondja says: Soweto "Who Really Cares" Derby
    09/05/2008 13:45
    Chiefs and Pirates have been dragging their feet for a while now, appointing coach after coach but never really strengthening their teams sufficiently. Instead choosing to believe wholly in their youth systems. Admirable. But folly. Sundowns bought and won while other teams with lesser resources worked hard. Now the tables have turned, no longer do teams like Chieps and Lierats win matches before even showing up for the game. Best of luck to platinum stars..

    Sundowns fan says: Derby
    09/05/2008 14:07
    i went to their derby and the atmosphere was electric & exciting.Better than this African championships that get our players tired & injured with Anti South Africa crowds & referees .U can't win everytime & the referees no longer award last minute penalties.

    Moripe says: Soweto Derby
    09/05/2008 14:07
    The derby surpasses any other game being played in Africa this month, this encounter shadows the AFCON final. Analysis of the match were never based on the log standings, and why does that point appear in the articles today, the derby has always and it will remain Impi yobukhaya, it has nothing to do with educational analysis. People travel from Cape Town and Eastern Cape to watch the face-of-african soccer and one writer deems that as lack of excitement, shoking! We who are lovers and felonies to soccer in the country are excited and making our way to Mafikeng for a treat of flair and pride

    Hlubi says: The Derby is still alive
    09/05/2008 14:37
    The fact that we are talking about the derby shuld tell you simething. The derby will never lose it's spark......the stadium will be fully packed and the buzz will be all overthe stadium again..that's the tradition we can't take away from the 2 teams. Journalists like to "Write what they Like" in their publications just to attract our attention or please thier bosses. Aluta Continua MaKhosi VS Pirates...Aluta.........!

    This comments facility is now closed.
  •