Experts debate heat, climate

2010-07-20 17:26

Paris - The first six months of 2010 brought a string of warmest-ever global temperatures, but connecting these dots to long-term climate change patterns remains frustratingly difficult, experts say.

Not only was last month the hottest June ever recorded, it was the fourth consecutive month in which the standing high mark was topped, according to the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

Indeed, 2010 has already surpassed 1998 for the most record-breaking months in a calendar year.

As a block, the January-to-June period registered the warmest combined global land and ocean surface temperatures since 1880, when reliable temperature readings began, NOAA said.

Arctic ice cover - another critical yardstick of global warming - had also retreated more than ever before by July 1, putting it on track to shrink beyond its smallest area to date, in 2007.

Steep cuts

On the face of it, these numbers would seem to be alarming confirmation of climate models that put Earth on a path toward potentially catastrophic impacts.

Without steep cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, the global thermometer could rise by 6°C compared to pre-industrial levels, making large swathes of the planet unliveable for humans, the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has warned.

Voluntary national pledges made after the Copenhagen climate summit in December would likely cap that increase at 3.5°C to 4°C, still fall far short of the 2°C limit that most scientists agree is the threshold for dangerous warming.

But making a direct link between year-on-year variations in the weather and changes in climate - best measured in centuries - is simply not possible, scientists said.

"When we are looking at the scale of a season or a few months, we can't talk about trends related to climate change," said Herve Le Treut, head of France's Laboratory of Dynamical Meteorology.

"The problem is knowing whether these numbers fit into a long-term evolution, and that only becomes apparent over at least two or three decades."

For scientists, he said, it would be like trying to figure out which way the tide is moving by watching only a few waves lapping at the shoreline.

Evidence

A hotter-than-average 2010 is due at least in part to the influence of periodic El Niños, which disrupt weather patterns in the equatorial Pacific, Le Treut and other experts point out.

"We now know that the year following an El Niño will be globally unusually warm," said Andrew Watson, a professor at the University of East Anglia in Britain.

"1998 was such a year. It's clear that 2010 will be very close to 1998 and quite possibly it will beat it," he said.

At the same time, the long-term trend of warming is unmistakable, and at least one figure from last month can be said to add to the mounting evidence that climate change is firmly upon us.

June was the 304th consecutive month with a global surface temperature above the 20th-century average, the NOAA reported.

The most recent month to dip below that average was February 1985, more than a quarter century ago.

Climate trends

"Taken in isolation these figures say nothing about climate change," said Barry Gromett, spokesperson for Britain's national weather and climate centre, the Met Office.

"But if taken in the context of 2000 - 2010 being the warmest decade on record, and this set be another near record or record warm year, then this is further evidence that the climate is warming," he said.

The Met Office uses different methods than the NOAA to calculate climate trends, and has not yet calculated data for June, he explained.

All of the ten warmest average annual global temperatures recorded since the end of the 19th century have occurred in the last 15 years.

- SAPA

Add your view to this conversation - comment below