News24

Facebook investors ponder next move

2012-05-27 13:23

Los Angeles - The response from small-time investors to Facebook's debut as a public company has been equal parts frustration, confusion and bitterness. Fed up, some are dumping their shares and accepting the losses. Others, while miffed, are holding on and hoping to ride the stock's eventual success.

Some blame themselves for embracing the hype over a company whose underlying value likely didn't merit the price at which it went public. But many accuse Facebook and its underwriting banks of setting the price too high and for trying to sell too many shares.

Others are pointing fingers at the Nasdaq stock exchange for botching buy and sell orders on opening day. Or they're angry over brokers who pushed them to buy.

And others are irked over reports that Morgan Stanley, which guided Facebook through its public debut, told only some select clients of an analyst's negative report about Facebook before its stock began trading on 18 May.

Michael Hines had felt uneasy about Facebook. He thought the shares were priced too high, and the excitement overblown - especially once the company raised its target price for the opening two days beforehand. Yet when the chance arose to buy into the company's $38-a-share initial public offering, he seized it.

Nothing ventured, nothing gained

"I figured: Nothing ventured, nothing gained," said Hines, 61, a retiree and private investor in Boston.

Now, he wishes he'd listened to his misgivings. Instead, Hines watched with dismay as the stock languished on its first day, then slid on its second. On Tuesday, determined to unburden himself of a nagging headache, he sold his shares at $32.76, taking a loss on his investment. He declined to say how many shares he'd bought.

"I was upset with myself for having been drawn into it," Hines said. "I knew it was grossly overpriced. I could feel it a couple of days before."

His son, Brad, also bought shares on the first day, at about $40.50, and was also irritated - with himself and with the investment banks that priced the shares.

As the lead underwriter for Facebook's IPO, Morgan Stanley was expected to set shares at the highest price it thinks the market will bear. But investors have also come to expect that an initial share price will be low enough so the stock can climb on the first day, when interest typically peaks.

Too lofty

"With a good IPO, the investment banks leave room for the pop," said Hines, a social media consultant. "They didn't do that in this case."

US companies that have gone public this year have returned an average of 16% on their first day, according to Renaissance Capital. And since going public, those companies are up an average 13%.

Looking back, some individual investors say they recognise that Facebook's initial $38 stock price was too lofty. It was more than 80 times the company's 2011 earnings per share. The average for companies in the Standard & Poor's 500 index is far cheaper, about 19 times earnings.

Brad Hines said he was concerned about the price. He admits to "the classic, amateurish mistake."

"I was so worried about missing out on the big first-day movement," he said. "Emotions got the better of me."

Unlike his father, the younger Hines is keeping his shares. He says he might even buy more if the stock keeps falling. 

Slow climb

Before Facebook's public debut, some investors were considering what to do if the stock price doubled the first day. Instead, it closed a paltry 23 cents higher. It tumbled $7.23 the next two days. A week later, it still hasn't begun to recover. It closed Friday at 31.91, down 3.4% on the day and 16% below its initial price.

One problem was that first-day trading glitches on the Nasdaq stock exchange botched some investors' trades. And in lawsuits, Morgan Stanley is accused of sharing negative analyst reports about the company with a few favoured clients.

Such allegations reinforce suspicions that Wall Street is stacked against the small investor. Investors have filed lawsuits, and lawmakers are opening inquiries.

By week's end, investors were shorting nearly 9% of Facebook shares available to the public, according to Data Explorers, which tracks stock lending. In shorting the stock, they're betting that the price will fall.

Comments
  • wesleywt - 2012-05-27 15:39

    People with money are stupid. You don't buy shares in company because you think its going through the roof in the first week. If it did then FB sold their shares too cheaply. You buy it because you believe the business will succeed in the future and give you returns on your investment of the long term.

      spookhuis - 2012-05-28 17:59

      FB didn't get where they are by being a stupid company. Most of the others have fallen by the wayside. Google is trying to get into the same market.

  • pages:
  • 1