Repeated IVF 'not always better'
2010-10-28 12:22
Los Angeles - More tries aren't necessarily better when it comes to in vitro fertilisation.
New research found that about one in three women had a baby the first time they tried a test tube embryo, and that improved to nearly one in two with a second try.
However, undergoing a third cycle boosted success rates very little and levelled off with subsequent attempts.
"Don't quit if the first cycle isn't successful. Your chances go up with the second cycle," said lead researcher Barbara Luke of Michigan State University. But "if you haven't gotten pregnant by the third, the chances are slim to continue".
In vitro fertilisation involves mixing egg and sperm in a laboratory dish. The resulting embryo is then transferred into the womb to grow into a baby. Earlier this month, British researcher Robert Edwards won the medicine Nobel Prize for pioneering the technique that has led to four million test tube babies.
Success rates
Infertility treatment is expensive. The average cost for an IVF cycle is about $12 400, according to the American Society of Reproductive Medicine. Some insurance companies cover it.
Desperate couples often try over and over to conceive, and there are no ethics standards on when doctors should stop helping them try. Fertility clinics report success rates based on the number of cycles attempted, but that doesn't indicate how likely an individual woman is to get pregnant with each IVF cycle she undergoes.
The new study is the first to examine that nationally. It looked at in vitro procedures around the country between 2004 and 2008.
Researchers were able to match IVF procedures to individuals based on their date of birth, Social Security and other information. This is important because this gives doctors and couples a better sense of how likely an IVF treatment is going to result in a baby.
Over the five-year period, some 300 000 women had more than half a million IVF cycles that resulted in 171 327 first-time deliveries. The live birth rate was 36% on the first IVF try, 48% with a second cycle and 53% with a third attempt.
Among those who tried seven or more times, the chance of success was 56% - hardly any better than the 53% after three tries.
The findings show "diminishing returns" after three IVF cycles, said lead researcher Luke. "The results are not going to be much better."
Options
That doesn't necessarily mean women should give up, she said. There are other options including using donor eggs or a surrogate mother.
The study, presented on Wednesday at a reproductive medicine meeting in Denver, did not look at success rates based on age or other factors that may influence the outcome. Luke said future studies will examine those other issues.
Advocates who help infertile couples say this will help them in their decision-making.
After repeated futile treatments, couples can use the data to keep on trying or consider other options such as adoption, said Barbara Collura, executive director of the non-profit Resolve: The National Infertility Association.
- AP
