News24

Women and children first a 'myth'

2012-04-12 18:53

Stockholm - A hundred years after the Titanic sank, two Swedish researchers on Thursday said when it comes to sinking ships, male chivalry is "a myth" and more men generally survive such disasters than women and children.

Economists Mikael Elinder and Oscar Erixon of Uppsala University also showed in their 82-page study that captains and their crew are 18.7 percentage points more likely to survive a shipwreck than their passengers.

"Our findings show that behaviour in life-and-death situation is best captured by the expression 'every man for himself'," the authors wrote.

The researchers analysed 18 of the world's most famous maritime disasters, ranging from the HMS Birkenhead that grounded in the Indian Ocean in 1852 to the MV Bulgaria tourist ship that sank on Russia's Volga River last year.

Analysing passenger lists, logs and registers, Elinder and Erixon found that men actually have a distinct survival advantage.

Out of the 15 000 people who died in the 18 accidents, only 17.8% of the women survived compared with 34.5% of the men. In three of the shipwrecks, all the women died, Elinder said.

The report also referred to the Titanic, which sank in the North Atlantic in the early morning of April 15 1912. The researchers called the Titanic an exception to their findings, mainly because its captain, Edward Smith, threatened to shoot men unless they yielded to women for lifeboat seats. Captain Smith went down with his ship.

Of the 1 496 people that perished with the Titanic, 73.3% of the women and 50.4% of the children survived compared to only 20.7% of the men.

"Evidence from the Titanic is not representative of maritime disasters in general," the report said.

One in five

The role of the captain was crucial, they said, stressing that only in five of the 18 disasters studied had captains given an order to prioritise the rescue of women and children.

The researchers noted that men, thanks to their physical strength, have better chances of surviving than women barring self-sacrifice. They wrote "when helping substantially increases the risk of dying, it would be rational for most individuals to save themselves".

Captain Christer Lindvall, president of The International Federation of Shipmasters' Associations, said he was not surprised about the findings but stressed that there are no rules stating that women and children should be rescued first.

Regarding the Titanic, he said Captain Smith was likely forced to make a choice between men and women because he knew right away there were not enough lifeboats to save everyone.

"He had to make a quota there," he said.

When it comes to the statistical survival advantage of captains and their crew, Lindvall said it doesn't necessarily mean that they had abandoned passengers who were not yet rescued. He said it could mean that their training and experience likely played a significant role in their survival.

"I don't think a captain should go down with the ship for the sake of going down with it. But you shouldn't leave the ship until all passengers are safe, or you know that you have done everything you can to try to save them," Lindvall said.

Comments
  • Glenn - 2012-04-12 20:09

    They should have added the Wilhelm Gustav deaths - that would have tilted the statistics.

  • Davecamaro1994 - 2012-04-12 21:45

    I believe with womans sufferage came equal rights. Which also means woman and men can vie equally for that lifeboat spot. It should go children first, then passengers lastly crew

  • Horst - 2012-04-13 07:56

    Question! What is the value of this type of research?

  • Hugh - 2012-04-13 08:24

    From a purely a "Family" point of view, this approach to survival is Criminal! Why conduct a procedure that automatically destroys a family? I am single,but I think it should be "Families first".

  • thelittlegreenhouse - 2012-04-13 10:58

    Male chivalry will always be a worthy enterprise The alternative is male tyranny... ..."thanks to their physical strength" as mentioned in the article. Cowards and Dodgy Captains are not worthy of the priceless company of Women and Children.

  • pages:
  • 1