Deputy chief justice 'overlooked'

2011-08-17 16:01

  • Zuma Exposed
    This book exposes Jacob Zuma, in such a way that he would not want you or anyone else to read it. Now R189.00
    buy now

Cape Town - Pretoria University law faculty's Centre for Human Rights has seriously questioned President Jacob Zuma's nomination of Constitutional Court Judge Mogoeng Mogoeng to be the new chief justice.

"Compared to his predecessors in the post-1994 era - chief justices [Arthur] Chaskalson, [Pius] Langa, and [Sandile] Ngcobo, whose appointments reflected their considerable academic and intellectual stature established by illustrious careers prior to or as members of the court - the basis for Justice Mogoeng's nomination is startlingly unclear," the centre said on Wednesday.

"There is in our view a lack of evidence to assure South Africans that the best possible candidate has been nominated to serve as our chief justice - a position that he will hold, if appointed, for the next decade," it said.

It was not clear what weight, if any, had been attached to Mogoeng's ability to play an intellectual leadership role as far as the court's adjudicatory role was concerned.

Mogoeng was appointed to the Constitutional Court only in October 2009, making him one of the four most junior members of the court.


His elevation to the position as head of the judiciary came above that of sitting Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and more experienced members of the Constitutional Court and other courts.

Overlooking the deputy chief justice could arguably have been acceptable if an equally senior judge or a female judge was nominated. Failure to do so at the very least deserved an explanation, the centre said.

Overlooking the most senior judge on the highest court for the position of chief justice had an unfortunate precedent in South Africa's less illustrious past.

Both in 1957 and 1959, Justice Oliver Schreiner, the deputy chief justice at the time, was overlooked in favour of more junior candidates more closely aligned to the government of the day.

"The available evidence leaves one pondering why Justice Mogoeng has been selected above other candidates with better credentials to serve as the country's chief justice."

At the time of Mogoeng's appointment in 2009 concerns were raised about his lack of experience in constitutional matters.

Since his appointment he had done little to ameliorate these concerns. In almost two years he had only written the court's majority judgment in four, relatively uncontroversial, cases.

His first judgment was delivered about ten months after taking his seat as Constitutional Court judge.

Constitutional experience

Even if this load was similar to that of other judges on the court, the point was that Mogoeng lacked constitutional experience as demonstrated in reasoned judgments.

He had also written dissenting judgments in three cases. In his most notable dissent (Le Roux v Dey) Mogoeng disagreed with the majority but did not disclose the basis of his disagreement, deviating from a long-standing tradition of articulating disagreement in a separate opinion.

Mogoeng also wrote minority opinions in the Glenister case, upholding legislation abolishing the Scorpions, and in the McBride case (The Citizen v McBride), finding that The Citizen, acting maliciously, impaired Robert McBride's dignity.

"Surprise and lack of persuasive substantiation breed suspicion," the centre said.

"The obvious question is: Why was the obvious or any of the other more experienced candidates not selected?"

If he was appointed, it would be up to Mogoeng to dispel any perception or suggestion that his unexpected appointment signalled "an attempt at executive corrosion of the independence of the judiciary".

"The president need not heed any misgivings expressed about the basis and lack of convincing reasons for his choice.

"However, he should at least seriously consider the views of opposition leaders and especially the Judicial Service Commission (JSC).

"We therefore encourage the JSC to consider the gravity of its role, conscious that the appointment of a chief justice should not, in the first place, serve the interest of an incumbent government (or President), but that of the state as a whole," the centre said.


Read more on:    mogoeng mogoeng  |  jacob zuma  |  judiciary

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Inside News24


Land reform process lawful - Zuma

The land reform process is being done according to the law and the Constitution, says President Jacob Zuma.


Latest elections multimedia

11 Julius Malema quotes you'll never forget
DA won't get 30% - Zille
The EFF's ad was banned, see why
Why Jack Parow wants you to vote on 7 May
  • Tuesday Century City - 05:58 AM
    Road name: Ratanga Road Southbound
    ROADWORKS - lane closure between Ocean Spirit Avenue and Century Boulevard (until mid April)
  • Tuesday Mitchells Plain - 05:58 AM
    Road name: Spine Road
    ROAD CLOSED between Weltevreden Drive and Seafarer Drive due to roadworks (until mid April)
More traffic reports...

Jobs in Cape Town [change area]

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Escape winter, head to Mauritius

Escape winter by spending 7 nights in Mauritius' tropical bliss from R13 215 per person sharing. Includes return flights, airport transfers and accommodation. Book now! - shop online today

Get 50% off selected books!

Buy 2 books and get 50% off the second book. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

Mother’s Day special offers!

Spoil mom with these awesome specials that will warm her heart. Shop now!

Twisp – the smoking alternative

Buy any 2 refills for R250 and save R149. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

25% off bestselling books!

The Real Meal Revolution by Tim Noakes, Jeffrey Archer’s Be Careful What You Wish for, Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor E. Frank and many more titles. Shop now!

Mother’s Day specials on appliances

Browse our range of Mother’s Day appliances to spoil and pamper mom. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Samsung Galaxy s4

Mobile, Cell Phones in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 24

Best bargain in big bay

Real Estate, Houses - Apartments for Sale in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

VW Golf 6, 1.6 Trendline (Excellent condition)

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

BlackBerry Curve 3G 9300

Keep it together Text. Email. Social. With all the different ways to...

From R1399.00

I'm shopping for:


You may be more sensitive today and can be influenced easily by the energies around you. Try not to be swayed too much by more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.