News24

Durban businesswoman's bid for info denied

2012-06-12 20:42

Durban - A Durban businesswoman's bid for more information on 118 counts of fraud against her was denied, the Durban Magistrate's Court was told on Tuesday.

Prosecutor Meera Naidu said this was a ploy to get the State to reveal its entire case before Shauwn Mpisane stood trial.

If Mpisane and her legal team "merely read" the charge sheet they would get the information they were demanding.

Naidu said Mpisane's application to force the prosecution to disclose more information was an attempt "to tie the State's case in knots".

On Monday, Wim Trengove SC, for Mpisane, argued that the prosecution had failed to say when exactly she had committed the offences, and where and to whom she had made misrepresentations.

Mpisane is accused of having understated the 2010 VAT returns of her company.

She is also accused of submitting revised financial statements to the SA Revenue Service (Sars) for her company, with inflated purchases that ultimately resulted in the company's profit being understated in 2008.

According to the State, Zikhulise Cleaning, Maintenance, and Transport CC's bookkeeper Kishal Reddy allegedly forged four invoices to the amount of R5 053 035 on Mpisane's orders.

"The accused must know whether she was party to any fraud or not," said Naidu.

However, Trengove said there was no information in the police docket and the charge sheet clearly showing when Mpisane had misrepresented the financial affairs of Zikhulise.

Magistrate Blessing Msane was expected to hand down his ruling on Mpisane's application on Wednesday.

Comments
  • MallyGold - 2012-06-12 21:06

    The Access to Information is now law, which the ANC promulgated and which was accepted into law at their insistence; now also applies to the very state that made the law in the first place. Access to Information has been demanded by Wim Trengove SC for Mpisane, and the state is compelled to honour its obligation.

      SaleƩ - 2012-06-12 23:11

      MallyGold - you really have no idea what you are delving into. Mpisane's demand for information could only have been in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act - a relatively old piece of legislation. It has nothing to do with whatever you are referring to.

  • Erna - 2012-06-12 21:42

    Justice prevails no matter who your contacts are!

  • prakash.singh.169 - 2012-06-12 22:10

    MPISANE GETS PAID 17 MILLION RANDS PER MONTH FROM THE E-THEKWINI MUNICIPALITY. CAN WIM TRENGROVE SC FOR MPISANE CONFIRM SHE WON THE TENDERS ON MERIT. OH YES HOW MANY OF THE HOMES WERE CONDEMNED. YET THE PEOPLE THAT WERE AFFECTED AND INCONVENIENCED DID NOT MARCH OR HOLD A DEMONSTRATION.

  • Matthew - 2012-06-12 22:38

    Oops, you just got caught with your hand in the cookie jar! What a fool!! Sounds like you had a successful business, wasn't that enough for you? Greed strikes again!!

  • Keith - 2012-06-13 06:32

    Why, oh why do you newspaper people keep showing an auctioneers hammer as a symbol of our law? Do you mean to suggest the the law is a lottery and justice goes to the highest bidder? That may be so in the Unites States but not yet in South Africa.

  • pages:
  • 1