Expert slams chief justice selection process

2011-09-05 15:51

Cape Town - The Judicial Service Commission (JSC) may have "misconstrued" its powers in approving Mogoeng Mogoeng as nominee for chief justice, an expert said on Monday.

Constitutional law professor Pierre de Vos said the JSC's decision not to entertain any other people for the top job two weeks ago could have caused the body to be pushed "into a legal corner".

"The legal challenge would be the decision taken by JSC two weeks ago that it was not permissible to entertain any other possible people for the top job," he said.

"There is a strong argument that the JSC misconstrued its powers. They interpreted it quite extraordinarily."

De Vos said it was clear during the weekend's interview that most JSC members were not interested in assessing whether Mogoeng was suitable to be the next chief justice.

"How shall I put it nicely... It is clear the majority of the JSC were not interested in doing their job and assessing the quality of the nominee.

Checks and balances

"There are two problems with the process. The majority of the members of the JSC decided long before that they would support the nominee. It is clear from the questions they asked that they would support him."

The second problem was that there was supposed to be consultation between the president of the country and the JSC - an exchange of ideas.

"It is not clear in this case if there was an exchange of ideas."

De Vos said the system needed more "checks and balances", where the president really consulted with the bodies he was constitutionally obliged to.

"There really needs to be an exchange of views about who is the best candidate. It is clear that has not happened in this case."

A suggestion that judges on the Constitutional Court select the chief justice themselves was also flawed.

"If we have judges selecting their own leader that could lead to other problems. We could end up with a 'judocracy'."


De Vos said the jury was out on whether Mogoeng, nominated for the job by President Jacob Zuma after the retirement of former chief justice Sandile Ngcobo, would be "executive minded".

"It might be unfair to say it is clear he will be pro-government, no matter what," said De Vos.

"The problem with the way things have transpired now is that the nominee is tainted in the eyes of majority of the people."

This was bad for the legitimacy of the Constitutional Court and the judicial system.

"The hope is that this process was a learning process for the nominee, and that he would be extra careful in future not to repeat the same mistakes he has made in the past," De Vos said.

A JSC commissioner, speaking on condition of anonymity, said on Sunday JSC members had voted in Mogoeng's favour.

Mogoeng drew gasps and laughter from the audience watching his interview as he defended his attitude on rape, his belief in God, his stance on homosexuality and on whether he had sufficient experience for the job.

He said he had dealt with many rape cases and that there were "people who are so brutal to women and children, they literally tear them apart mercilessly.

"I have seen worst you can imagine in many cases," he said after being asked about a reference he had made to "minor injuries" suffered by a young girl when she was raped.

Inconsistent with the Constitution

He defended his intellectual depth after being asked why he had not written any legal articles as other judges had.

He said he did not have a "passion for writing" and that he had always had a problem with colleagues who used words "you had to look up in a dictionary to understand".

At one point during the interview he snapped at Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke, telling him there was "no need for sarcasm".

He later apologised for the remark.

The Women And Men Against Child Abuse (WMACA) NGO said it was against Mogoeng's nomination.

"His lack of understanding of the psychological impact and injury and harm caused by rape, as he clearly expressed in his responses to questioning at JSC is frightening," WMACA spokesperson Germaine Vogel said.

"Justice Mogoeng is not the right person for chief justice. His patriarchal attitude towards gender based violence reflects a mindset and values that are inconsistent with the Constitution and the crucial role of the courts in protecting women and children."


Read more on:    jsc  |  mogoeng mogoeng  |  jacob zuma  |  dikgang moseneke  |  judiciary

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Inside News24


ANCYL: Not voting would be blasphemy

Not voting in the forthcoming elections would be blasphemy, the ANCYL says in a statement commemorating the 50th anniversary of struggle icon Nelson Mandela's Rivonia trial speech.


Latest elections multimedia

Why Jack Parow wants you to vote on 7 May
The ad the SABC doesn't want to air
Elections 2014 in one cartoon
This year's election posters
  • Thursday Sir Lowry's Pass - 05:35 AM
    Road name: Old Sir Lowrys Pass Road
    TRAFFIC LIGHTS not working at Bezweni Road
  • Thursday Cape Town - 05:35 AM
    Road name: Buitengracht Street
    TRAFFIC LIGHTS not working at Waterkant Street
More traffic reports...

Jobs in Cape Town [change area]

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Escape winter, head to Mauritius

Escape winter by spending 7 nights in Mauritius' tropical bliss from R13 215 per person sharing. Includes return flights, airport transfers and accommodation. Book now! - shop online today

Get many eggs in one basket!

Gaming bundles: 2 Super Hits games for R99, 3 Disney games for R99 and more + exclusive accessory bundles only available on While stocks last. Shop now!

25% off bestselling books!

The Real Meal Revolution by Tim Noakes, Jeffrey Archer’s Be Careful What You Wish for, Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor E. Frank and many more titles. Shop now!

Up to 25% off electronics

Buy top electronics and save up to 25%. Such as’s 1# selling product the gobii eReader, Patriot X Porter flash drive, Asus Nexus 7” 3G tablet, Samsung Galaxy SIII, Lenovo G580 Notebook and many more. Shop now!

DStv HD PVR Decoder now R949

The DStv HD PVR Decoder has further revolutionised the television experience with lifelike viewing, sharper images, more vibrant colours and precision picture quality. Now R949, save R550. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

Up to 30% off appliances & homeware

Save up to 30% on appliances and homeware this Easter! Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now.

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Samsung Galaxy s4

Mobile, Cell Phones in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 24

Best bargain in big bay

Real Estate, Houses - Apartments for Sale in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

VW Golf 6, 1.6 Trendline (Excellent condition)

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

Canon EOS 600D

The Canon EOS 600D Digital Camera puts the widely respected...

From R5389.95

I'm shopping for:


There may be a break through, either through quiet contemplative time to connect to your deep side or forced on you more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.