Gauntlett: Delays hurt justice

2010-04-13 19:24
Cape Town - Judges should be held to account if they delayed rulings for longer than a month, senior counsel Jeremy Gauntlett told the Judicial Service Commission on Tuesday.

He also called for a re-examination of an accused's right to silence, and defended himself against an African National Congress MP's suggestion that he was unpatriotic.

Gauntlett, one of four applicants for three posts in the Western Cape High Court, is a former chairperson of the General Council of the Bar who has served as an acting judge in the province and as a full member of the Lesotho appeal court.

He said in his application form that he had never taken longer than a week to hand down a reserved judgment.

Replying to questioning from Chief Justice Sandile Ngcobo, he said he was "enormously troubled" by the delays he had witnessed in delivery of reserved judgments.

Worst offenders

Acting judges drawn from the ranks of the bar and the attorneys' profession were often the worst offenders.

"Barring very complicated matters, judgments, in principle, should follow immediately or very shortly after the cessation of the hearing," he said.

"I personally believe that every judge should be accounting to his or her judge president as to why they haven't delivered a judgment within 30 days."

He said the "record" had been set by a Supreme Court judge in Namibia who at the end of last year delivered a ruling on a case he heard nine years earlier, as a high court judge.

In Harare a judgment was recently delivered three years after an application for postponement of a trial - ironically granting the application.

Commission member CP Fourie, a representative of the attorney's profession, asked Gauntlett whether repeatedly delaying judgments for years did not amount to impeachable gross misconduct or incompetence.

"I'm afraid it does," replied Gauntlett.

"Ultimately it's a betrayal of trust. You are there to give an answer."

Right to silence

Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe told Gauntlett that a problem in criminal cases was that when an accused relied on the right of silence, judges often for days or weeks had no idea what the defence was.

"This is one of the causes for delay in criminal proceedings," Hlophe said.

Judges and lawyers, Hlophe said, had argued that an accused should be obliged upfront to disclose the basis of his defence.

Gauntlett said even though he might be accused of being a neo-fascist, he supported a more inquisitorial approach.

The fundamental fairness of a criminal trial would not be destroyed by a requirement that an accused should, without elaboration, state a defence.

Dual citizenship

The right to silence should be retained, but it was not an unlimited licence.

"It's a hugely contentious issue. I believe no more than that it's something which could fruitfully be looked at," Gauntlett said.

"Whether I come out at the other end as still an enthusiast, I don't know.

"But it's certainly a matter for serious intellectual interrogation."

ANC MP Grace Boroto challenged Gauntlett over his dual British and South African citizenship.

She said she had no reason to question his abilities, "but I have a problem doubting your patriotism".

Gauntlett said the British citizenship was an accident of birth, and he had lived in South Africa and been committed to it since the age of 17 or 18.

"My understanding is that British citizenship, like dandruff, you have with you always," he said.

"That there is no legal step that you can take which would absolutely get rid of it.

"I'm a South African. Whether or not I suffer from a fatal defect together with George Bizos and Shadrack Gutto and others who have made contributions in this country, this body must decide."

Read more on:    jeremy gauntlett  |  cape town  |  judiciary


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Inside News24

Keep your bike (and yourself) safe with these tips 2015-03-23 09:16

Whether you’re a newbie pedaller or a seasoned cyclist, knowing how to stay safe is the best way to enjoy your time on your bike.


Your head may be up in the clouds today. Hopefully the wind will blow the clouds away and you will have a clear view. Keep more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.