Hlophe case: Judges wanted fairness

2012-03-31 07:31

Johannesburg - Judges of the Constitutional Court said they were preserving the "fairness" of the court's process when they denied Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe's application for leave to appeal a misconduct case between him and themselves.

"The applications raise issues fundamental to the integrity of our judicial process," the long-awaited unanimous judgment said.

It was the first time the court, the highest in the country, had had to hear a case in which some of its judges were involved, and faced a conflict of interest.

The judges made no order on Hlophe's actual complaint, but the effect of their judgment is that the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) must reopen the complaint.

As they covered their interpretation of the Constitution on whether the Constitution allowed their recusal and only pronounced on the application for leave to appeal to them, they also included their insight into some aspects of the case.

In November, a slew of lawyers had presented options to the court on the recusal issue, after Hlophe decided to appeal two Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) rulings that the JSC misconduct case against him be reopened.

He had not initially objected to the Constitutional Court judges hearing the case, but in court directions, the matter was raised, hence the November hearing on recusal.

The options presented to the judges in November included that they invoke a doctrine of necessity and hear the application for leave to appeal themselves; that they recuse themselves and let President Jacob Zuma appoint a new quorum (eight judges) for the case; or that the case be dismissed and the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) judgments be the last word on the matter.

Potential dangers

In Friday's judgment they said Section 175(1) of the Constitution allowed the appointment of an acting judge of the Constitutional court if there was a vacancy or if the judge was absent, or removed for gross misconduct or incapacitation. It did not mention recusal.

It had been argued that a recusal rendered a judge absent, but they said a recused judge was still required to perform the rest of their judicial duties and so could not be considered absent.

The judges said that in terms of the Constitution the president appointed acting judges on the recommendations of the minister of justice and the JSC.

But, there were "potential dangers" to judicial independence and the separation of powers in the appointment of individual judges to hear a specific case.

The judges said that even though the composition of the court had changed due to retirements and new appointments, potential conflict of interest remained.

Section 167(1) of the Constitution says the court must have 11 judges and Section 167(2) says a matter must be heard by eight judges, they explained. Six judges were already in the job when the Hlophe application was lodged and three had recused themselves from the hearing before it was argued, leaving the required eight.

But this included three who were parties to the complaint, and who had tried to mediate. If they were disqualified, then there would be no quorum.

Because the option of appointing acting judges was not available, they said, the applications must be dealt with in another way.

They said that in terms of the Constitution, everyone had the right to have any dispute resolved by law or in a fair public hearing. They also had the right to apply to the Constitutional Court for leave to appeal.

They did not have an automatic right of appeal, unless it was in the interests of justice.

They quoted Section 178 of the Constitution, which states that a premier of the High Court concerned should be appointed when considering matters relating to a specific High Court and said JSC decisions must be supported by a majority of its members.

This appeared to be a reference to Western Cape Premier Helen Zille's successful SCA challenge that she should have been part of the JSC preliminary inquiry, that the JSC was not properly constituted, and that there had not been a majority on the decision.

They wanted a balance between finality and possible injustice to Hlophe.

Fairness

The underlying right Hlophe wanted to protect was a procedural one, they said.

"...The rejection of that right will result in the continuance of a process only and will not result, without more, in a finding against him on the substance of the complaint.

"What is more, the applicant has had the benefit of an appeal. These considerations mitigate the threat of injustice."

"In addition, although the parties have consented to the conflicted judges' sitting in the present matter, regard must still be had to the fact that they would ordinarily have to recuse themselves.

"For this reason, this court should deny leave to appeal to preserve the fairness of its own process."

In 2008, the judges told the media they had laid a complaint against Hlophe with the JSC, saying he had made an improper attempt to influence a case related to President Jacob Zuma.

Hlophe had counter complained that his rights were violated when the judges sent the media statement.

In a preliminary inquiry the JSC found no misconduct against either party but Legal advocacy body Freedom Under Law and Zille had challenged this in court.

Friday's judgment noted that the two SCA judgments meant: on the premier's challenge, the JSC must reconsider both complaints, and regarding FUL's application, it only had to reconsider the judges' complaint.

Zille issued a statement saying she was pleased with the judgment and was waiting to hear from the JSC.

- SAPA

Read more on:    jsc  |  helen zille  |  jacob zuma  |  john hlophe
NEXT ON NEWS24X

Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
1 comment
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
 

Inside News24

 
 
Traffic
Lottery
 
  • Wednesday Paarl - 06:58 AM
    Road name: N1 Eastbound
    STATIONARY TRUCK in the left lane before the R101 Main Road exit
  • Wednesday Cape Town - 06:56 AM
    Road name: N2 Inbound
    DELAYS between Duinefontein Road and the M5 Highway Interchange
 
More traffic reports...
 

Jobs in Cape Town [change area]

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Escape winter, head to Mauritius

Escape winter by spending 7 nights in Mauritius' tropical bliss from R13 215 per person sharing. Includes return flights, airport transfers and accommodation. Book now!

Kalahari.com - shop online today

Get many eggs in one basket!

Gaming bundles: 2 Super Hits games for R99, 3 Disney games for R99 and more + exclusive accessory bundles only available on kalahari.com. While stocks last. Shop now!

25% off bestselling books!

The Real Meal Revolution by Tim Noakes, Jeffrey Archer’s Be Careful What You Wish for, Man’s Search for Meaning by Victor E. Frank and many more titles. Shop now!

Up to 25% off electronics

Buy top electronics and save up to 25%. Such as kalahari.com’s 1# selling product the gobii eReader, Patriot X Porter flash drive, Asus Nexus 7” 3G tablet, Samsung Galaxy SIII, Lenovo G580 Notebook and many more. Shop now!

DStv HD PVR Decoder now R949

The DStv HD PVR Decoder has further revolutionised the television experience with lifelike viewing, sharper images, more vibrant colours and precision picture quality. Now R949, save R550. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

Up to 30% off appliances & homeware

Save up to 30% on appliances and homeware this Easter! Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now.

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Samsung Galaxy s4

Mobile, Cell Phones in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 24

Best bargain in big bay

Real Estate, Houses - Apartments for Sale in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

VW Golf 6, 1.6 Trendline (Excellent condition)

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Western Cape, Cape Town. Date October 25

BlackBerry Torch 9810

The BlackBerry Torch 9810 gives you the powerful combination of...

From R2820.00

I'm shopping for:

Horoscopes
Aquarius
Aquarius

You may find yourself fascinated by something which could draw you in to obsessively exploring this subject in depth....read more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.
 
English
Afrikaans
isiZulu

Hello 

Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.


Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.

Settings

Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.








Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.