Hello 

Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.


Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.

Settings

Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.









Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.

 
 

Vagrants win case against V&A

2003-12-24 13:29
line

Cape Town - Two men accused of disruptive begging at the V&A Waterfront, have been given the High Court's permission to go back, but have been ordered to behave with the requisite decorum.

Judge Dennis Davis, who handed the judgment down on Tuesday, said the Waterfront's attempt to have Patrick Smith and Ganief Benjamin permanently excluded from the Waterfront could not succeed. This was because too many fundamental individual rights would be infringed by such a court order.

However, Davis had some strong words for the two men, who have upset patrons in the past.

He interdicted them both from "unlawfully causing harm to visitors and businesses" at the Waterfront, particularly remaining at a restaurant after having being asked to leave.

Smith was also interdicted from "unlawfully assaulting, intimidating or threatening any employee and/or official of (the Waterfront)".

Davis accepted evidence that for two years Smith had addressed "young visitors" to the 123ha complex of restaurants, elite shopping malls and tourist attractions in a vulgar and intimidating fashion, made rude sexual comments to a female security guard and grabbed her breasts and on several occasions disturbed clients eating at restaurants and became violent and abusive when asked to leave.

He had also threatened other security officers and is alleged to have shoplifted, although this was not proved.

Benjamin was acquitted of attacking a Waterfront patron with a broomstick, but is also accused of interfering with restaurant patrons while drunk.

"The conduct of (Smith and Benjamin) falls short of civilised behaviour and is clearly unacceptable. It invades the rights of (the Waterfront) and warrants prohibition," the judge said.

Earning their daily bread

Davis was quick to point out that he had not been asked to prohibit the men from begging at the Waterfront, and his order did not stop them from earning their daily bread thus.

He said he had "grave reservations" about the constitutional validity of such a prohibition, property rights in this case having to give way to the more important rights of life and dignity.

He said that an order against begging would also veer dangerously to the side of race discrimination because "three hundred years of racial oligarchy" meant that poverty was often "racially distributed".

Davis said that during court proceedings submissions made by the Waterfront showed that they "reluctantly" accepted that they did not have an unqualified right - on the basis that the Waterfront is private property - to exclude Smith and Benjamin from the premises.

This was because the complex's nature meant is was "fundamentally different" from another business, such as a restaurant or shopping mall.

Excluding the two men would limit their access to a SA Police Service charge office, a post office, hotels, residences, shops, parts of the coast and the ability to visit Robben Island.

- SAPA

inside news24

 
1 of 10

140
1

Latest comment in South Africa

Zak Avnon says... I bet you, this Rapist ANC MP will walk away free... Read the article...

 
Traffic
Lottery
 
  • Friday Carletonville - 10:01 AM
    Road name: N14
    ROAD CLOSED due to a large sink-hole between the two Carletonville exits - traffic is diverted onto a local bypass route
  • Sunday Volksrust - 07:33 AM
    Road name: N11 Both Ways
    Stop / go controls for construction works at Majuba Pass - expect delays between Volksrust and Newcastle
  • Monday Centurion - 15:41 PM
    Road name: Jean Avenue
    ROAD CLOSED between Rabie Street and Gerhard Street for sink hole repair works
 
More traffic reports...
 

Jobs [change area]

FINANCIAL ACCOUNTANT

Cape Town, South Africa
Strategy Recruitment Marketing
Market Related

Customer Engineer

Newcastle, South Africa
CEB Maintenance Africa (Pty) Ltd
R5000 - R8000

Clerk General II (Credit Notes)

Gauteng, South Africa
Hutech International Group
Market Related

Cars[change area]

LAND ROVER

Freelander 1.8 4x4 5-dr MY98
2007
R 309,900.00

FORD

Bantam 1.3i XL AC PU MY09
2010
R 106,500.00

CHEVROLET

Spark 1.2 5-dr
2010
R 84,990.00

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Romance at the President

Spend two nights at the Protea Hotel President in Cape Town from R2601 per person sharing. Includes return flights, taxes, car hire and accommodation. Book Now!

Kalahari.com - shop online today

The Big Mama Sale

The Big Mama Sale is now on. Get up to 80% off Books, Music, DVDs, Games, Electronics, Toys & Gifts. Shop now.

Electronics on Sale

Up to 80% off electronics + 24hr delivery. Shop now.

50% Off Educo toys

Join the Big Mama Sale madness at kalahari.com and get 50% off all Educo toys for your kids. Terms and conditions apply. Shop now.

Books on Sale

Up to 80% off books & 1000s Of books to choose from. First come, first served. While stocks last. Shop now.

Blu-ray special offer

Buy 10 blu-rays and get a free Sony blu-ray player. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now.

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Drain & Pipe Inspection System

For Sale, Garage Sale in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 21

2011 Mazda 2 1.5 Dynamic

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 22

Estimator

Jobs, Engineering Jobs - Architecture Jobs in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 21

The Big Mama Sale

The Big Mama Sale is now on. Get up to 80% off Books, Music, DVDs, Games, Electronics, Toys & Gifts. Shop now.

Visit www.kalahari.com for millions of books, music, DVDs, games & more!

Apple iPhone 4S 16GB

Dual-core A5 chip. The most powerful iPhone ever. Two cores in the...

From R7199.00

I'm shopping for:

A local community where you can meet people, upload photos, videos and loads more...
  • featuredprofile

    cassidy082
    Age: 30
    Sex: Female
    Location: Gauteng - Johannesburg
  • featuredevent

    Watershed
    when: 25 Feb 2012 - 25 Feb 2012
  • featuredgallery

    bonkers
    when: 06 Jan 2012
    Number of photos: 70
  • featuredvideo

    Coldplay - Charlie Brown
    Watched: 506
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.