Hello 

Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.


Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.

Settings

Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.









Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.

 
 

White cop 'not against AA'

2009-11-19 23:36
line

Johannesburg - She's not on a crusade or trying to attack affirmative action - she's merely asking for compensation for a post which, strictly speaking, should have been hers.

This was the argument delivered on Thursday in the Johannesburg Labour Court by Captain Renate Barnard's legal team. Barnard is arguing that she should have been promoted to the level of superintendent, after allegedly being overlooked due to her skin colour.

Barnard, with the support of Solidarity, claims that even though she wasn't awarded the post, it was left vacant because no other suitable candidate could be found.

The police's defence on Monday was that promoting Barnard would have made their affirmative action targets even more difficult to meet.

Johannes Ramathoka, head of the Saps's employment equity unit in Pretoria, then testified that her appointment would have hampered their goal of reaching employment equity targets for post level nine, the level of superintendents.

Compensation

On Thursday John Grogan, Barnard's legal representative, told Judge Paul Pretorius that they're not asking for Barnard to be appointed to another position, nor are they asking that she be promoted to superintendent.

"She's simply asking for the compensation which she would have received had she been appointed to the position for which she had applied."

Grogan suspects that Barnard didn't get the position simply because that would have "messed " with the police's affirmative action figures.

"But affirmative action is not the only aspect which should be kept in mind when filling a position, especially if no other candidate is then appointed to that position."

He said Barnard has no problem with affirmative action.

"But then it must be executed in the right way. Nobody benefited from the fact that she wasn't appointed. The position remained vacant and no-one else was suitable for the position."

Prevent imbalance

William Mokhare, the Saps's legal representative, said the fact that Barnard was not appointed was not intended to target her as an individual or to penalise her.

"It was to prevent an imbalance, since there had already been too many white women appointed on her post level.

"One can't look at this matter in a vacuum, but should see it as part of the bigger picture of affirmative action."

Mokhare said furthermore that the other (black and coloured) candidates who were recommended for the post along with Barnard, were not appointed either.

"Therefore this is no longer a matter of unfair discrimination, but rather one of Barnard's dissatisfaction with the fact that a position was not filled."

Pretorius reserved judgement.

'More concerned about AA than delivery'

Dirk Hermann, deputy chief executive of Solidarity, said on Thursday they were especially concerned about the police's legal team's "racial tirades" during the court case.

According to Hermann, Solidarity will be documenting the court proceedings and will send this documentation to Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa.

"We want to know from him whether the government also has such harsh, rigid opinions regarding affirmative action. His reaction will then determine our future actions."

According to Hermann, Barnard has a "strong legal case", but they also want to explore the political aspects of affirmative action.

"Mokhare acted on behalf of the Saps, in other words his opinions represent those of the Saps.

"And it's troublesome that the police are apparently more concerned about race and affirmative action than they are about service delivery."
 
 

Read more on:    saps  |  racism  |  saps equity case

inside news24

 
1 of 10

140
1

Latest comment in South Africa

ingrid.webbe says... Nope Sihle, still not getting your explanation. Back to school for you. Read the article...

 
Traffic
Lottery
 
  • Friday Carletonville - 10:01 AM
    Road name: N14
    ROAD CLOSED due to a large sink-hole between the two Carletonville exits - traffic is diverted onto a local bypass route
  • Sunday Volksrust - 07:33 AM
    Road name: N11 Both Ways
    Stop / go controls for construction works at Majuba Pass - expect delays between Volksrust and Newcastle
  • Monday Centurion - 15:41 PM
    Road name: Jean Avenue
    ROAD CLOSED between Rabie Street and Gerhard Street for sink hole repair works
 
More traffic reports...
 

Jobs [change area]

Senior Oracle Developer

Gauteng Other
EOH Recruitment Solutions
R300000 - R400000

VAT Accountant

Centurion
Communicate Midrand Finance Specialist Resource
R330000 - R350000

VB Programmer

JHB - Northern Suburbs
Network IT Bruma
R20000 - R40000

Cars[change area]

CHEVROLET

Cruze 1.8 LT AT
2011
R 179,950.00

NISSAN

Micra 1.4 Comfort 5-dr
2005
R 75,000.00

HYUNDAI

i20 1.4 GL 5-dr
2011
R 126,900.00

Property [change area]

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Magical Massinga

Spend 5 nights at Mozambique's magical Massinga Beach Lodge. From 10 299 per person sharing. Includes return flights, taxes, transfers and accommodation. Book Now!

Kalahari.com - shop online today

Blooming love

We have a range of roses available for that someone special on Valentine's day. Order before 10 February to ensure delivery on 14 February 2012. Buy now.

Perfect pair Valentine's Day offer

Buy a classic male grooming shave brush set for R279 & get 15% off a selection of cologne. Buy now.

gobii eReader Valentine's Day offer

Get the gobii eReader + free R160 eBook voucher for only R899. Buy now.

Twilight

The Twilight Saga - Breaking Dawn part 1 coming 13 February. Available on DVD & blu-ray. Pre-order now.

gobii eReader now available

Buy the gobii eReader and gobii cover for someone special this Valentine’s Day. Free 24hr delivery. Buy now.

OLX Free Classifieds [change area]

Drain & Pipe Inspection System

For Sale, Garage Sale in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 21

2011 Mazda 2 1.5 Dynamic

Vehicles, Cars in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 22

Estimator

Jobs, Engineering Jobs - Architecture Jobs in South Africa, Gauteng, Johannesburg. Date January 21

Egreat R6B Full HD Media Player

Deal of the week

Get the Egreat Media player for only R499.95 plus 24hr delivery. While stocks last. Buy now.

Visit www.kalahari.com for millions of books, music, DVDs, games & more!

BlackBerry Bold Touch 9900

The Blackberry Bold Touch 9900 is as the name says...

From R5399.00

I'm shopping for:

A local community where you can meet people, upload photos, videos and loads more...
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.