Opposition leaders present united front after motion fails - As it happened

2016-04-05 17:48

Get the latest details as Members of Parliament debate a motion to remove President Jacob Zuma after last week's Constitutional Court ruling.

IN SUMMARY: - A motion brought by the DA to to remove President Jacob Zuma from office failed, with 233 MPs voting against it and 143 voting in favour.The vote came after hours of debate and speeches such as that of DA leader Mmusi Maimane who said corruption had infected the ANC "like a cancer".

- Opposition MPs and leaders then addressing the media outside the House said they will write to the speaker that there must be disciplinary process against Zuma. He says they will working together.

- Meanwhile, it also emerged that former finance minister Trevor Manuel, one of the ANC's top members, also wants Zuma to resign.

- Just as proceedings began, opposition MPs demanded that National Speaker Baleka Mbete not chair the session. The House broke while party chief whips discussed the matter and it was decided to allow Mbete to continue in the seat.


Jump to

Last Updated at 09:47
05 Apr 18:28
It's quite a thing to see all opposition leaders presenting such a united front on this.

05 Apr 18:24
Maimane: as we told Mbete today we are far from finished on this matter.

05 Apr 18:24
Maimane says they will write the speaker that there must be disciplinary process against Zuma. He says they will working together. Malema nods his head as Maimane speaks.

05 Apr 18:23
Maimane, Malema standing side by side, alongside other oppositions MPs such as Bantu Holomisa. This united front is holding.

05 Apr 18:21
House now dealing with a motion brought by the ANC's chief whip. Opposition MPs staged a walkout.

05 Apr 18:20
Be ready for what's coming, Malema has warned as he stomped out of the House.

05 Apr 18:19
We are not going to be part of this useless mess of Parliament, says Malema. You are traitors, someone shouts. 

05 Apr 18:17

Yes votes - 143; No votes - 233

The motion to impeach Zuma fails

05 Apr 18:15
Gardee calls for a secret vote because his machine isn't working, he claims.

05 Apr 18:14
MPs will vote from their seats pressing the buttons on their monitors. These votes are recorded. Members have a yes/ no option.

05 Apr 18:08
Proceedings will restart in five minutes.

05 Apr 18:08
Lechesa Tsenoli says the nos have it. DA calls for a division.

05 Apr 18:07
That's it for the debate. MPs now voting.

05 Apr 18:06
Former finance minister, Trevor Manuel, has joined in the call for President Jacob Zuma to resign, saying he violated his oath of office.

05 Apr 18:05

Ndlozi: Is that the best sweep the ANC could do on a motion? Is that the best? That’s terrible man! It’s poor.

05 Apr 18:04
Tsenoli was closing up when the opposition shouted that Maimane had another few minutes to speak.

05 Apr 18:03
DA MPs shouting "rubbish" during ANC Khubayi's speech.

05 Apr 18:02
Nothing historical about this motion, it's a PR exercise, says Kubayi.

05 Apr 18:01
Kubayi says they were trained in the revolutionary movement.

05 Apr 18:01
Kubayi who served on the Nkandla ad hoc committee also hit back at those who say she was caught painting her finger nails in a meeting.

05 Apr 17:59
Kubayi: The issue of impeachment doesn't exist in our language, it's a colonialist language.

05 Apr 17:58
Kubayi now appears to refer to the New York Times weekend editorial which called for Zuma to resign. She appeals to people not to allow international interference in SA.

05 Apr 17:57
eNCA has published a clip showing the tussle between MPs outside National Assembly. Click the link to see more.

05 Apr 17:54
Kubayi: The ANC is capable of introspecting and self-reflecting. We are a democratic organisation.

05 Apr 17:54

05 Apr 17:52

05 Apr 17:51
We are democrats, we follow processes of democracy, says the ANC's Kubayi.

05 Apr 17:48
Kubayi says Zuma humbled himself - many MPs disagreeing.

05 Apr 17:48
Kubayi to Maimane, saying he was in a race to outshine Malema - they barely waited for judgment before filing motion.

05 Apr 17:47
ANC's Kubayi up now.

05 Apr 17:46
APC's Themba Godi is also chairperson of Scopa, which is an accounts oversight committee in Parliament.

05 Apr 17:45
Godi interrupted by several points of order.

05 Apr 17:45
I have found this to be true.

05 Apr 17:44
APC's Themba Godi stressing importance of Constitution.

05 Apr 17:43
APC's Themba Godi now on the podium. Apparently he wasn't invited to the meeting of Opposition Leaders this morning.

05 Apr 17:43

05 Apr 17:40

He asks ANC MPs: Are you telling SA you will vote against the ConCourt's judgment?

One MP is heard yelling "YES!"

05 Apr 17:40
Honourable members of the ANC are drowning me, Mbinda complains of the ruling party's MPs shouting over him.

05 Apr 17:38
Now it's the PAC's Luthando Mbinda. I stand here very embarrassed, he says.

05 Apr 17:36
Tlouamma says Zuma has to be removed - if not it will lead to SA being ungovernable.

05 Apr 17:35

Tsenoli orders Tlouamma is unparliamentary for calling Zuma a "traitor". He withdraws.

Steenhuisen wants clarity. Members have been called traitors on many occasions. Is it now unparliamentary, Steenhuisen asks. Absolutely, says Tsenoli.

05 Apr 17:33
Again the Bible gets a mention. Again. This time it's Agang's Andries Tlouamma. References to Sodom and Gomorrah.

05 Apr 17:31

Galo, from the AIC, thanks ConCourt on behalf of people of SA, and thanking Mogoeng for protecting democracy.

He calls for fresh elections. And that's him done.

05 Apr 17:27

05 Apr 17:26
Mabe has said 'Desperate Alliance' many times during his short speech. It wasn't really funny the first time.

05 Apr 17:25
Mabe speaking against the removal of the president, says it should be considered carefully & not emotionally.

05 Apr 17:24
Mabe saying the ANC is now ready to demonstrate that it understands the ConCourt ruling.

05 Apr 17:23
Mabe: Removal of the president has the potential of jeopardising the well-being of SA.

05 Apr 17:22
Much is now being made of quotes from the Bible. Much.

05 Apr 17:18

Mabe: We must all be faithful to the Constitution and not just sections of it. There's no basis for this desperate motion.

He's repeatedly called the DA the 'Desperate Alliance'.

Jump to


Inside News24

How much food do you need to concentrate?

We have been taught that we need three meals a day in order to make it through the day and while most of us indulge in more than our fair share there is a large portion of South Africans who are living off barely enough to sustain them.


Book flights

Compare, Book, Fly

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.