News24

Info bill approval condemned

2011-11-22 22:32

Cape Town - The National Assembly's approval of the protection of state information bill on Tuesday has drawn widespread condemnation.

The House approved the bill by 229 votes to 107, with two abstentions, after a division called by the opposition.

Earlier, a Democratic Alliance motion to delay the vote failed.

The SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) said the bill could impact negatively on basic human rights. The commission had a constitutional and legislative responsibility for the right of access to information.

The bill had to be aligned with the Promotion of Access to Information Act, to avoid moving back towards a culture of secrecy which had the potential to undermine democracy, it said.

Concern


The commission expressed concern over the impact of the bill on the rights of journalists and whistleblowers, who released information in the public interest and faced the prospect of lengthy imprisonment sentences in the absence of a public interest defence in the bill.

Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) noted with "deep regret" the decision.

"We call on President [Jacob] Zuma and the African National Congress to follow through on their pledge of a fully public and consultative process on this bill."

A side effect of the bill was that it had seen a trend of national, provincial and local institutions tending towards a culture of secrecy, it said.

The Right2Know Campaign said it was disappointed that ANC MPs had accepted the bill.

"In doing so they have betrayed the principles of open government and transparency that the ANC once stood for.

Low point in SA

"We have won the argument, if not this battle. The Right2Know Campaign will continue to challenge the secrecy bill up to the Constitutional Court," it said.

The Helen Suzman Foundation also expressed outrage at the passing of the bill.

"This marks a low point in South Africa’s transition to democracy.

"It represents a significant step backwards in the long walk to freedom to which so many South Africans have devoted their lives," it said.

The Constitution enshrined and protected the free flow of information between citizens, and from government to citizens.

This access to information was essential for accountable, transparent, and responsive government.

"This bill cannot credibly be described as in South Africa’s best interests. Instead, it is a case of political expediency triumphing over constitutional rights."

Dwindling democracy

It marked the beginning of policy being driven by a secretive and self-serving security cluster, the foundation said.

The United Association of SA (Uasa) said the bill's "steamrolling" through Parliament heralded nothing positive for South Africa's democracy.

The bill's approval spelled huge dangers for what was left of the already dwindling democracy in South Africa.

"It will become impossible to make informed decisions on, for instance, political matters like elections.

"If we are no longer informed about corruption and other wrongdoing by the state and politicians up to the highest positions in our government, how will it be possible to make an informed choice between parties?"

It would also serve as a major deterrent for whistleblowers for fear of being prosecuted should they divulge sensitive information, Uasa said.

Comments
  • Bernard - 2011-11-23 00:07

    COMMI BASTARDS, I'll take as many as I can of you with me!!!

  • sonny.brilliant - 2011-11-23 00:40

    Democracy has it's ups and downs I guess, and please stop saying "Free media" (there is no such thing) oxymoron. If South Africans get actively involved in their communities,societies and thus the country - the corrupt will not prevail , but only in the absence of the righteous will corruption flourish.

  • TembaVJ - 2011-11-23 03:09

    Eish it iz so thet da govment cen steel mo from de white man. Like our bra Rob in Zimbabwe, tis a nice country thet one. 10 Years and SA will be begging the white man from the UK and USA to help the sick and hungry from the south of Africa. Just like Zim typical African mentality. The same media that exposed Apartheid is now being toung tied. viva banana republic.

  • pages:
  • 1