Parliament to look into tribunal

2010-09-24 10:30
Durban - Parliament will be tasked with looking into the "desirability" of setting up a "statutory independent media appeals tribunal", the ANC's national general council said on Thursday.

"It should be Parliament that investigates its desirability and feasibility. That investigation could go either way," said ANC national executive committee member Pallo Jordan at a media briefing in Durban.

"The existing self-regulatory system with the press ombudsman and press council is ineffective and needs to be strengthened."

Some 2 200 delegates agreed that Parliament would decide on what form the tribunal would take - it could take the form of self-regulation, co-regulation or independent regulation.

No pre-publication censorship

If Parliament agrees that a media appeals tribunal is needed, the ANC recommends that it should be "independent of commercial and party political interference" and it should not be in the form of pre-publication censorship.

The ANC's suggestion of a media appeals tribunal sent shock waves through the media fraternity, who raised concern over its effect on press freedom.

Jordan said it was because of the ANC that South Africa could enjoy media freedom.

"South Africa’s media comes from very unfortunate past thanks to the government that preceded us and consequently are ultra-sensitive," he said.

"They have a tendency to think any criticism of the media as some form of censorship and oppression.

"I defy you to find a political party in our Parliament today that has a record that can step up to ours in defence and pursuance of freedom of expression and the freedom of the media."

Jordan said the issue of tribunal did not have as much prominence in the commission's discussions as many thought it might.

The paragraph on the tribunal, which was welcomed by most journalists at the press conference as being "as good as we are going to get it" and "watered down", took up just one paragraph of an eight page proposal document.

The proposals are that tribunal should not have the right to pre-publication censorship and that it be independent of commercial and party political interests.


Jordan said there had been no suggestions from any of delegates as to what form sanctions against the media might take.

"Something will be placed before Parliament at some point. It will be put on Parliament’s timetable."

Jordan called for a charter to oversee the transformation of the print media, which was dominated by four groups "Virtually every word printed in this country emanates from four huge print media conglomerates.

"We don’t think that is a reasonable state of affairs. We have been concerned about this for a number of years."

One journalist asked Jordan: "What do you expect us to do? Report on Zuma going to church and ANC members must sing hallelujah."

Jordan replied that there was nothing unusual about wanting to see 65% of views of electorate reflected.

"There is nothing sinister about that," he said. Jordan argued that in Britain there were four main line newspapers, such as The Telegraph who backed the Conservative Party and The Daily Mirror which supported the Labour Party, who took political standpoints.

"That is the pattern in most democracies. If you go to Italy there is even greater variety. You find people reading a communist newspaper, a clerical one. Diversity in society is reflected in the print media."

Protection of Information Bill

Jordan said not mention was made of the Protection of Information Bill, which has been widely decried as an attempt to return to apartheid-era repression. The bill in its current form will give government officials wide discretion to classify information and will impose harsh penalties on the press for publishing such information.

Lumko Mtimde, another member of the sub-committee, said the media had to be taken to task for its regular "inaccurate reporting".

"There is no discouragement against bad reporting," he said. "You see so many cases, so many apologies every time you open a newspaper."

Mtimde said the media diversity in broadcasting was "to some degree" on the right path.

It had more than 100 community stations, a private television stations and space in terms of broadcasting was given to different languages and diverse content.

"The space is open to a wide range of South Africans," he said.

The situation was different in the print media, he said, where there were challenges in terms of ownership and control in terms of publishing and printing.

"It was resolved that there should be an inquiry into the transformation of print media in SA," he said.

"We need to look into challenges and see what needs to be done."

Read more on:    anc  |  pallo jordan  |  anc ngc meeting  |  media


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Inside News24

6 ways to stay safe at home and on the road 2015-03-27 15:39

These Easter holidays, take these precautions to keep your home and family safe.


The Fast and Furious R40 million

With the Fast and the Furious 7 hitting South African cinema’s this April, all eyes are on the cars and we’re in for a treat!


Luxury living

This is the most expensive burger in the world!
Exclusive food items that WILL break the bank
Top 10 most expensive homes in the world
You can permanently live on a ship and sail the world!

You may find yourself drawn into investigating, researching or digging below the surface to get to the bottom of something. more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.