Mobile medical app explosion haywire

2014-06-05 19:03
The Jolla smartphone powered by Sailfish is aimed at taking on Google Android operating system. (Duncan Alfreds, News24)

The Jolla smartphone powered by Sailfish is aimed at taking on Google Android operating system. (Duncan Alfreds, News24)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

San Francisco - A smartphone app that rids you of acne. Another that monitors your heart rate 24-7. One that detects skin cancer by looking at your birthmarks. If they sound too good to be true, they may be.

Patients today use a number of apps that purport to track and treat a panoply of ailments, a headache for regulators and patient safety advocates. Now, the advent of wearable devices bristling with sophisticated biotracking sensors is stirring concern in the medical community about misdiagnoses that could have serious consequences for consumers.

Some are asking whether Apple and Google should do more to police their fast-growing app marketplaces.

"Most of the health apps out there are built by people with zero medical experience," said Paris Wallace, chief executive officer of Ovuline, a popular fertility app. Worse, many developers don't have the resources for legal counsel, Wallace said, and are more likely to make false claims to patients without seeking FDA clearance.

The Food and Drug Administration last year published guidelines on the kinds of mobile apps it will supervise. But industry insiders fear the agency may get overwhelmed as apps mushroom.

Last week Samsung Electronics launched a health platform for third-party developers, SAMI.

This week Apple introduced "Healthkit," a repository of data for medical apps that opens up new realms for developers to explore. It may also make it easier for those with scant understanding of regulatory protocols to dive into the market.

Health apps are big business for Apple and Google, the two leading app marketplaces. The iPhone maker is the preferred choice for developers. Analytics firm AppAnnie found that Apple generates five times more revenue from downloads of health and fitness apps than Google.

How the two companies, who both declined to comment for this story, will handle the proliferation of medical apps is unclear. One source familiar with the matter said Apple is looking to add a regulatory expert to its growing digital health team, who will be tasked with oversight of the App Store.

Research has shown that many existing medical apps may be useless. Seventy-five percent of smartphone apps that claim to assess malignancy are wrongly diagnosing at least 30% of melanomas as "unconcerning," researchers from the American Medical Association's JAMA Dermatology found.

Faulty results

A 2012 study by the New England Center for Investigative Reporting revealed that of 1 500 health apps it evaluated, 20% claimed to treat or cure medical problems, but only a small percentage of them had been clinically tested.

Medical professionals fear patients may defer an in-person check up because of faulty results. By the time they see a doctor it may be too late. A false negative for cancer, for instance, may prompt a user to put off professional consultation.

"If patients perceive a mobile app as a cheaper alternative to a trip to my office, that's worrying," said Molly Maloof, a physician who has spoken about such matters and is a consultant for digital-health startups like Sano Intelligence and GeneSolve.

Echoing a familiar Silicon Valley stance, developers argue that increased federal oversight will only stifle innovation.

Mike Lee, cofounder of MyFitnessPal, a weight-loss app that claims 50 million users, said his company wouldn't exist today if it been required to seek regulatory approval: "We wouldn't have been able to afford the tremendous time and expense."

Patient safety advocates counter that the FDA's concern shouldn't be to appease Silicon Valley's entrepreneurs but to protect consumers. Moreover, apps like MyFitnessPal are focused on wellness and would not require FDA approval.

Policymakers are struggling to keep up. The FDA lacks the resources to monitor each and every one of these apps.

According to an IMSHealth report from October 2013, more than 43 000 health-related apps are available on the US iTunes store, and 33 500 on Google Play. Bradley Merrill Thompson, a health-care-focused attorney with Washington DC-based Epstein, Becker and Green, speculates that hundreds of unregulated mobile "medical devices" - anything with a specific medical application - populate Apple's store.

Reuters found several dozen applications on the App Store and Google Play that fall into the FDA's definition of a medical device. Examples include a heart-rate monitor targeted to patients with chronic conditions and an app for diabetics to detect early signs of vision loss.

Those products have not been cleared by the feds, and offer little or no clinical evidence to back up their claims.


"Most of these [apps] carry minimal risks to patients and consumers. However, others can carry significant risks if they do not function properly," an FDA spokeswoman said on Wednesday.

"FDA intends to exercise enforcement discretion for the majority of mobile apps that meet the definition of device."

The FDA has cracked down on a small number of mobile medical apps in recent years. In 2013, the agency admonished Biosense Technologies, maker of the "uChek" urine analysis system, for failing to seek regulatory clearance.

Some say Apple and Google should give them a hand. Apple, for instance, has no qualms about banning apps with explicit or illegal content. Malay Gandhi, strategy officer at digital health venture firm Rock Health, recommends they use flags to better indicate which apps are certified, or provide a way to report dodgy apps to the FDA.

If these companies are not more proactive, "nothing will be remedied until bodies start piling up," said Christopher Dolan, a personal injury lawyer with the Dolan Law Firm in San Francisco.

To avoid liability, developers typically include disclaimers in their terms of use. But these are often buried in the fine print, or may be missed by nonnative English speakers.

Dolan points to Cardiograph, an app from Macropinch that sells for $1.99 on the App Store. It claims to monitor people's heart rate with "the same approach used by professional medical equipment."


The app's description contains anonymous reviews advising patients to ignore the disclaimer: "Warning: The instrument, although accurate, is not an actual medical equipment. Consult your physician."

"Judging by the feedback we've received over the years, our users are well-informed about the purpose and limitations of the app," said Vladimir Georgiev, a spokesperson for Macropinch.

Thompson, who runs the mHealth Regulatory Coalition, an organization that counts Samsung and Qualcomm among its members, is pushing the FDA to distinguish between products it will not regulate and those it considers mobile medical devices.

In September 2013, the FDA clarified that it will focus on apps that seek to replace a doctor's visit or perform clinical tests, though it gave no examples.

"The FDA wasn't designed for post-market surveillance," said Jason Brooke, chief executive officer and general counsel at Vasoptic Medical, maker of a mobile diagnostic that competes with a number of unregulated apps. The FDA needs to act soon to ensure that developers will "comply on their own."

Read more on:    google  |  samsung  |  apple  |  us  |  apps  |  health

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.
NEXT ON NEWS24X publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24


Book flights

Compare, Book, Fly

Traffic Alerts

You may need to consciously create clear structures today to help you anchor your ideas and goals to accomplish things today. more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.