Cyprus savers foot the bill for bailout
2013-03-19 08:00
Paris - As savers in Cyprus rush to withdraw money in the light of a proposed bailout that requires hefty levies on their deposits, the plan raised concern across the eurozone as a possible precedent for other crisis-hit countries.
Although not unseen before - Italy imposed a one-off 0.6% bank account tax in 1992 - it is the first time it has been proposed since the eurozone debt crisis began.
Cyprus is the fourth eurozone nation to fall victim to the crisis, which has already resulted in enormous EU/IMF bailout packages for Greece, Ireland and Portugal.
Eurozone finance ministers have suggested changes to the bank levy terms to protect the smallest savers.
Here is rundown of the current Cyprus bailout terms:
What is the Cyprus bank deposit levy?
It is a one-time special tax on all savings accounts, but the size of the levies depends on how big the deposits are. Under the proposed plan, savings that fall below €100 000 will be hit with a 6.75% charge, but anything above that figure will be slapped with a 9.9% charge.
To compensate its depositors for their bailout contribution, Cyprus plans to hand deposit account holders bonds linked to potential future revenues from the country's natural gas reserves.
Cyprus's government needs to get parliament approval before going ahead with the tax.
Why do Cypriot savers have to help foot the bill?
When countries need help, they are often required to take unpopular measures.
In this case, the European Union (EU), the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the European Central Bank, did not want to lend more than €10bn, meaning Cyprus would have find itself the extra €5.8bn estimated to be needed.
Having already been heavily exposed to the Greek financial crisis, Cypriot banks were not perceived as having enough capital and senior unsecured debt left to wipe out in order to cover the amount of funds needed.
However the island's banks hold considerable deposits, including from foreign savers and companies. Hence the levy.
Of the estimated €67bn of deposits held by Cyprus banks, experts estimate that Russian deposits there amount to at least €15.4bn.
"The alternative was to offer Cyprus a type of solidarity that some of the biggest countries were not prepared to show," Bruegel institute researcher Nicolas Veron said.
The EU has been criticised by some for providing only loans and not grants to crisis-hit countries.
How did the market react?
Badly, but they did not succumb to panic.
In foreign exchange activity, the euro plunged below the $1.30 level to hit a 14-month low of $1.2882 at one point in Asian trading on Monday.
After an initial slide in Asia, Asian markets recovered in early trading on Tuesday, with Tokyo stocks jumping 2.02% in the morning.
Europe's main stock markets shed less than half a percentage point on Monday with banking stocks suffering the brunt of the drop.
The borrowing rates for some of Europe's weakest economies also climbed somewhat, but not to excessive levels.
What are the short-term effects?
Although many Cypriots have resorted to withdrawing their savings from local cash machines, the trend appears to be isolated to Cyprus so far.
UBS analyst John-Paul Crutchley said that outside of Cyprus, the short-term effects are likely to be limited, mainly thanks to the fact that other bailed out countries in Europe have already done much of the work to clean up their economies.
"We don't really see any reasons for savers in any of these countries to fear that they might have to contribute" in a similar manner, he said.
Giuseppe Vega, president of Italy's market watchdog Consob, said: "could this happen in Italy? I really don't think so".
What will happen to investor confidence?
While many agree that this may have been the only way out for Cyprus, most experts say it will deal a great blow to confidence in Europe's financial stability as a whole.
"If European policymakers were looking for a way to undermine the public trust that underpins the foundation of any banking system they could not have done a better job," said CMC Markets analyst Michael Hewson.
"The dawn raid on the previously sacrosanct savings of depositors will draw unwanted attention to the struggling peripheral banks throughout the eurozone," added analyst Mike McCudden at online brokerage Interactive Investor.
"To have bank clients contribute, as an exceptional measure, has to stay a unique case," Andreas Schmitz of Germany's BdB banking federation said.
Guido Ravoet, the head of the European Banking Federation, said "this decision could penalise small depositors and generate just that type of uncertainty that our economy doesn't need in the current circumstances".
- SAPA
