News24

Lesbian, 83, seeks gay marriage ban review

2012-07-17 10:02

Washington - An ailing 83-year-old lesbian asked the Supreme Court on Monday to hear her legal challenge against a federal law that defines marriage as a union between a man and woman, attempting to place her case on a fast-track to the top court.

The suit, filed by Edith Schlain Windsor in 2010, targets the Defence of Marriage Act, a law passed by the US Congress in 1996 that denies federal benefits to lawfully married same-sex couples.

Windsor's petition attempts to bypass the US Court of Appeals, which is slated to hear the case in September.

With Windsor's filing, there are three petitions pending before the Supreme Court over the constitutionality of the Defence of Marriage Act, an issue the high court could take up in oral arguments as early as next spring, said Windsor's lawyer Roberta Kaplan, of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP.

"This case presents a question of exceptional national importance: The constitutionality of a statute, the Defence of Marriage Act [Doma], that daily affects the lives of thousands of Americans," the petition said.

In June, a New York district court ruled in Windsor's favour, finding that a central provision of the law discriminates against married same-sex couples. The case is now on expedited appeal before the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals.

Inheritance laws

But Windsor's lawyers argue that premature review of her case by the Supreme Court is warranted since the issue is already before the court. Also, Windsor suffers from a heart condition that could end her life before the case is resolved.

The American Civil Liberties Union originally filed the suit in New York on behalf of Windsor, a former computer programmer who married Thea Clara Spyer in Toronto, Canada, in 2007. The two were engaged in 1967.

Spyer died in 2009 after a long battle with multiple sclerosis, leaving her property to Windsor. Because the marriage was not recognised under federal law, Windsor had to pay more than $363 000 in federal estate taxes, according to the suit.

Six states have legalised same-sex marriage since Doma went into effect, including New York in 2011. But federal law and programmes do not recognise those marriages because of Doma.

Windsor's attorneys argue that the federal law violates the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution which prohibits states from denying people equal protection under the laws.

Federal courts in New York, California and Massachusetts all found the law unconstitutional for different reasons, applying varying standards of legal analysis.

The Republican-controlled House of Representatives, through its Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group (Blag), is defending the law, which the Obama administration has largely abandoned.

President Barack Obama in 2011 instructed the Justice Department to stop defending the law in courts, finding it unconstitutional.

Paul Clement, a lawyer for Blag, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Windsor's petition.

Comments
  • erich.goosen - 2012-07-17 11:05

    Oh dear, is this poor old lass still capable of distinguishing between male and female?

  • colin.langley - 2012-07-17 11:31

    This is so sad. Funny how we kill people in the name of power and oil. Funny how we destroy our planet. Funny how we still have poverty. Funny how we still have dictators. Funny that when a man loves another man and a woman loves another woman all hell breaks loose!

      Moi - 2012-07-17 14:38

      So true. Of all the things in this world that we have to protest about, love between two consenting adults is something that should never make it onto the "list".

  • pages:
  • 1