Nuke fight could hurt Iran cancer patients

2010-11-18 14:20

Tehran - The human impact from the wrangling between Iran and the West over its nuclear programme could be felt first in nuclear medicine clinics around the country, where hundreds of cancer patients a week get treatment with radioactive isotopes.

Iran says fuel for the Tehran research reactor that produces the isotopes will run out in September next year, leaving it without the materials needed to diagnose and treat some 850 000 cancer patients across the country.

A deal for the West to provide fuel for the reactor has all but fallen apart in the deadlock over Iran's broader nuclear programme, and Iran's drive to produce the fuel on its own has brought condemnation from the US and Europe. They fear the programme could boost what they contend is the secret goal of Iran's nuclear ambitions: To produce a bomb.

Iran denies the claim, saying its programme is only for peaceful purposes and has touted the need for medical isotopes to justify its programme.

Negotiators from Iran and the United States and its allies are expected to meet soon - likely late this month or early next month - in their first direct nuclear talks in more than a year. A deal to provide Iran with fuel for the research reactor may be on the agenda - but US officials have already expressed pessimism that one can be reached.

At the nuclear medicine ward in Tehran's Shariati Hospital, Ghodratollah Ghalavand fears the standoff could eventually leave him without his lifeline. Every week, he comes in for treatment of his thyroid cancer with iodine-131 isotopes produced by the reactor.

Treating thyroid cancer

"I'm not familiar with politics. I'm a rural person. I only know that not giving fuel is wrong. It will endanger my life. Humanitarian issues are different from politics," said Ghalavand, a man in his 50s from a village in southwest Iran.

The Tehran reactor is fuelled by rods made from uranium that has been enriched to a level of 20%. It has been running on fuel rods that Iran imported from Argentina more than a decade ago to produce medical isotopes like iodine-131, used to treat thyroid cancer.

Iran imports some ready-made isotopes, but it has faced greater restrictions under UN sanctions and has to pay higher prices to get them. Sanctions do not directly ban the sale to Iran of medical equipment, but they make foreign producers more reluctant to provide it, and those who will sell it do so at inflated prices.

"We are paying twice the value of this product to import it from Turkey," said Mohammad Reza Ramezani, an official at Shariati Hospital, pointing to a cargo of technetium-99, the most common radioisotope used in diagnosis, that arrived from Turkey at day earlier.

Uranium enrichment lies at the heart of Iran's dispute with the West. Low-enriched uranium - at around 3.5% - can be used to fuel a reactor to generate electricity, which Iran says is the intention of its programme. But if uranium is further enriched to around 90% purity, it can be used to develop a nuclear warhead.

Iran has been producing low-enriched uranium for several years, but the United Nations has demanded that it stop enrichment for fear it will be increased to weapons-grade. The UN has imposed four rounds of financial sanctions on Iran for refusing the demands.

Not enough guarantees

Last year, the United States proposed a UN-backed deal that it hoped would provide a confidence building measure and leave Iran at least temporarily unable to produce a bomb. It proposed that Iran ship abroad most of its stocks of low-enriched uranium, which would be further purified to 20% and turned into fuel rods, which would then be sent back to Iran to power the Tehran medical reactor. Doing so would leave Tehran's stocks too low to produce enough high-enriched uranium for a bomb.

But Iran balked, arguing that the deal did not provide enough guarantees the West would follow through with the fuel rods. It proposed modifications that the West rejected.

This year, Iran reached a separate deal with Turkey and Brazil to ship 1 200kg of low-enriched uranium abroad in return for fuel rods. But since Iran had been continuing to produce low-enriched uranium in the meantime, the deal would still have left it enough in theory to build a bomb, so the West rejected the agreement.

At the same time, Iran began in February to further enrich uranium to 20%, aiming to produce fuel for the Tehran reactor on its own. But it still has to turn the material into fuel rods. Iran says it has the capability to do so, but Western nuclear experts are sceptical.

Iran's nuclear chief, Ali Akbar Salehi, said Iran would be able to fuel the reactor on its own by next September, when the imported fuel is due to run out.

The American ambassador to the UN nuclear watchdog, Glyn Davies, said the original fuel swap deal was "picture perfect" to ensure the Tehran reactor keeps running and producing isotopes. He said in March that after Iran's rejection "we can only assume they're enriching the material for other purposes".

200 patients a week

US officials have said Washington could agree to a new version of the fuel swap deal - but it would have to entail Iran shipping a larger amount of low-enriched uranium abroad and stopping its 20% enrichment. The Americans are sceptical Iran would agree, though Iranian officials have signalled they might halt the further enrichment if fuel rods are guaranteed.

Iran has 120 nuclear medicine centres around the country, with some 200 patients a week getting idione-131 treatments for thyroid cancer, according to Mohammad Ghannadi, a top nuclear official.

At the Shariati ward, 50-year-old Manijeh Shahri coughs as she describes the radiotherapy treatment for her thyroid cancer.

"I'm not familiar with politics nor with nuclear issues," she said. "But I need radioisotopes to remain alive."

- AP