Recent photos of shot Giffords released

2011-06-13 13:00
A recent photo of US Representative Gabrielle Giffords who was shot in the head in January 2011. (, P.K. Weis, AP)

A recent photo of US Representative Gabrielle Giffords who was shot in the head in January 2011. (, P.K. Weis, AP)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

Houston - Two portraits of a smiling Representative Gabrielle Giffords gave the world its closest look yet at the congresswoman's remarkable recovery less than six months after she was shot in the head at point-blank range outside a supermarket.

The pictures posted on Sunday on Facebook were the first clear photos of the Arizona congresswoman who rose to national prominence after a gunman opened fire on her in January as she met with constituents in Tucson. Six people were killed and 13 others wounded.

But the images left unanswered many questions about her cognitive abilities and when - or even if - she will be able to resume her job in Congress.

"The image doesn't tell us the inner mental state or the brain itself, how it's functioning," said Jordan Grafman, director of the Traumatic Brain Injury Research Laboratory at the Kessler Foundation Research Centre in West Orange, New Jersey, explaining that many brain-injury patients look good within months of being hurt.

"What's their social skills? Do they have a nuanced sense of humour? Can they participate in activities? All that is what's important," asked Grafman, who has not treated Giffords.

In one of the images, Giffords smiles broadly and looks straight at the camera like a high school student posing for a yearbook. In another, more candid shot, she is grinning alongside her mother. In both, her smile is largely unchanged, though her hair is shorter and darker. The pictures give few indications she has been hurt, let alone shot in the forehead.

Images not altered

Giffords' aides say she could be ready to be released from a rehabilitation centre later this month or in early July. The idea was to discourage a "paparazzi-like frenzy" of photography when she attends outpatient therapy in a more public setting, they said.

The congresswoman's staff said the images had not been altered or touched up in any way. But other than saying the pictures were taken May 17 at the Houston rehabilitation hospital where Giffords has been undergoing treatment, her staff offered no further insight into her recovery.

For months, they have closely guarded Giffords and information about her condition. Her doctors, in the absence of permission from the family to speak publicly, remain mum. So the release of the photos attracted intense interest.

Giffords was shot in the left side of the head, the part of the brain that controls speech and communication. Doctors, friends and families have said she can speak, sing some of her favourite songs and engage in some conversation.

Representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz told NBC's Meet the Press she had a "wonderful conversation" on Wednesday with Giffords on the phone, and that this time her colleague even initiated some of the topics they discussed.

Since she was wounded, the public's only other glance of Giffords came in grainy images from late April that showed her slowly walking up the steps of a Nasa jet that flew her to Cape Canaveral, Florida, to watch her husband, astronaut Mark Kelly, rocket into space.

Subtle inequities

The launch was delayed, forcing Giffords to make a second trip to Florida in May, when she watched the blastoff from a wheelchair.

Giffords spokesperson CJ Karamargin acknowledged that the congresswoman looks different now than in the photos. Her hair is shorter because her head was shaved ahead of surgery to repair a gap in her skull that had initially been left open to allow her brain to swell. Doctors also fixed what appear to be subtle inequities between her eyes seen in the pictures, he said.

The photos were released to help satisfy "intense interest in the congresswoman's appearance". And they seemed to please the public and her admirers.

Hundreds of people commented under the images, which were posted on countless web sites. More than 3 000 people clicked "like" on Giffords' Facebook page.

Some of the comments also mentioned Jared Lee Loughner, aged 22, the shooting suspect who has pleaded not guilty to charges stemming from the shooting. He is being held at a Missouri facility where prosecutors hope his competency can be restored after a judge declared him unfit to stand trial.

Others raised questions about the actual extent of Giffords' progress.

A shadow of herself

"It would be nice to get a truly honest assessment of her internal cognitive experience," wrote Alex Hakkinen, who told the AP he works with brain injury patients at a rehab centre in Lawrenceville, New Jersey.

Hakkinen said Giffords' staff has an obligation to bring her out in public at some point so constituents can assess her abilities, maybe in a "fireside chat" of sorts. Or they should acknowledge that she's incapable of doing so right now, he said.

Chief of Staff Pia Carusone indicated in an interview published on Thursday in the Arizona Republic that, despite reports that Giffords is talking and walking, she remains a shadow of her bubbly self. The congresswoman, she said, can verbalise her basic needs, but struggles to string together more complex thoughts.

If her recovery "plateaued" now, Carusone said, Giffords' quality of life would be far less than what she had known before the shooting.

Carusone stopped short of answering the most critical questions: Will Giffords' resume her post in the House of Representatives and will she run for the Senate?

Until the January 8 shooting, some Arizona Democrats viewed Giffords as one of their best hopes for gaining votes in the Senate.

Slightly distorted and swollen

The shooting has created something of a vacuum, with few candidates willing to declare their interest until Giffords' situation is clarified. Carusone has only said that the congresswoman has until May 2012 to decide.

In the short-term, the photos focused attention on Giffords' appearance.

Of the two pictures, one is more clearly posed, that of a smiling Giffords looking directly at the camera. The left side of her head appears slightly distorted and swollen, and a healed scar from a breathing tube can be seen in her neck. A second photo shows Giffords in a more casual light - smiling while sitting alongside her mother, Gloria Giffords, with the hospital's greenery behind them.

The pictures were taken by Tucson photographer PK Weis, who said he has known the congresswoman for at least 10 years.

But brain expert Grafman noted the camera is angled toward Giffords' right side, her better half since the bullet struck her on the left.

Delight and surprise

For some, simply seeing the congresswoman smiling and radiant was encouraging.

Susan Hileman, who survived three gunshot wounds in the rampage, said she spent Sunday morning smiling while looking at photos of Giffords.

"I am delighted and pleasantly surprised," said Hileman, who was holding the hand of 9-year-old shooting victim Christina-Taylor Green when the gunfire erupted. "Look at that smile. How could you not be happy looking at that smile?"

The pictures, Hileman said, gave her hope as she endures her own painful rehabilitation.

"It's a miracle she's alive ... It's going to be a long road, but if anybody is well-positioned to do it, it's Gabby," she said. "She's physically fit. She's smart. She's driven. She's young ... She has all the pieces in place."

Those elements will ultimately help her long-term recovery, experts say. A person's education, intelligence, environment and life experience affect recovery from a brain injury.

Cognitive abilities

"It's striking. She does look great," said Dr Richard Riggs, chairperson of physical medicine and rehabilitation at Cedars-Sinai Medical Centre in Los Angeles.

Still, Riggs, who has not been involved in Giffords' treatment but has been tracking her progress, said the months after her release will be critical.

Patients who have suffered traumatic brain injury can become easily disoriented, have trouble prioritising, suffer memory loss and have difficulty recognising people. Some struggle to do several tasks at the same time.

Most cognitive recovery occurs in the first six months to a year after an injury, though it becomes less noticeable as time progresses. In the second year, progress sharply drops.

"The picture tells us that physically she's having what would appear to be a strong recovery from that standpoint," Riggs said. "But it does not tell us anything about the cognitive capabilities or where she is on the path of independent living much less going back to a job."

- AP
Read more on:    gabrielle giffords  |  us


Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
1 comment
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Inside News24


Extravagant toys for the rich

What do you get for the person who has everything? Buy them something completely over the top.


Luxury living

The Fast and Furious R40 million
This is the most expensive burger in the world!
Exclusive food items that WILL break the bank
Top 10 most expensive homes in the world

You may find yourself drawn into investigating, researching or digging below the surface to get to the bottom of something. more

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.