US defence chief an expert on nukes, but says little about them

2016-09-26 05:39
US Defence Secretary Ash Carter. (Jacquelyn Martin, AP File)

US Defence Secretary Ash Carter. (Jacquelyn Martin, AP File)

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

Washington - As defence secretary to a president who famously envisioned "a world without nuclear weapons", Ash Carter has said remarkably little about them.

He has been quiet on a range of nuclear issues, including the Pentagon's $8bn effort to correct an array of morale, training, discipline and resource problems in the Air Force nuclear missile corps, revealed by The Associated Press in the last three years. Nor has he publicly explained in detail the utility of nuclear weapons in an age of attacks by non-state actors like the Islamic State to build support for spending hundreds of billions on a new generation of them.

When asked, he has left no doubt that he sees nuclear weapons as the "bedrock" of US security. But he rarely reveals the underpinnings of his thinking.

This is all the more notable because Carter, a physicist by training and policy wonk by reputation, cut his professional teeth on nuclear weapons during the Cold War. He probably knows more about them than any defence secretary since William Perry, a longtime nuclear expert, led the Pentagon a generation ago.

Quiet approach expected to end

This quiet approach is expected to end when Carter visits Minot Air Force Base in North Dakota on Monday. There he plans to deliver a speech on nuclear deterrence, the notion that a robust and ready US nuclear force will make clear that the cost of hitting the US would outweigh any benefit. It will mark his first visit to a nuclear weapons base since becoming defence chief in February 2015.

Minot is home to Minuteman 3 intercontinental ballistic missiles that stand in underground silos, ready for nuclear war. A portion of the Air Force's B-52 bomber force, including a number equipped to carry nuclear bombs, also are at Minot.

Like the three other men who have run the Pentagon for President Barack Obama, Carter has plenty of other high-priority issues to consume his time and attention, including the war against the Islamic State group. Carter also has chosen to focus on what he calls the "force of the future" - a set of policy initiatives meant to modernise the way the defence establishment recruits and develops members of the armed services. And he has given a great deal of attention to Silicon Valley and other technology hotbeds that he sees as potential keys to translating civilian innovation into US military advantage.

Nuclear weapons issues have taken a back seat, at least publicly.

"Secretary Carter has not said much on nuclear weapons, but his actions speak volumes," says Joe Cirincione, president of the Ploughshares Fund, an advocacy group that argues for nuclear reductions and against the administration's plan to commit hundreds of billions to build a next-generation nuclear arsenal. "He has been the Dr No of nuclear reductions, defending every programme contract and resisting every cut in the nuclear force."

A spokesperson for Carter disputes that the Pentagon chief has been quiet about nuclear issues.

"He regularly speaks about the importance of the nuclear triad to our security, its importance in reassuring our allies and deterring potential adversaries, and the need to ensure that we maintain and modernise that capability," said Gordon Trowbridge, the Pentagon's deputy press secretary.

'Sabre rattling'

Carter has talked quite a lot about the nuclear weapons of other countries. He chastised Russia for nuclear "sabre rattling", endorsed the US nuclear deal with Iran and criticised what he has called North Korea's nuclear "pursuit and provocations". But when it comes to America's own weapons, he has mostly limited himself to broad references to their importance.

Before this week, Carter had not given a speech about nuclear weapons nor visited a nuclear weapons base. His immediate predecessor, Chuck Hagel, visited two of the three Air Force bases that operate Minuteman 3 missiles, plus one of the two Navy bases for Trident nuclear submarines. Hagel also visited a B-2 bomber base to highlight his support for an Air Force plan to build a new nuclear bomber.

Among Carter's most substantial remarks about nuclear weapons was his response earlier this month to a question from a student at the University of Oxford in England after Carter spoke about the American defence relationship with Britain. Carter was asked whether he worries that important nuclear issues are being ignored or neglected.

"Well, it's a blessing to be able to take the public's mind off the nuclear question," Carter began. He said he was thankful that nuclear issues are "not in the headlines".

He called deterrence the cornerstone of US strategic defence policy because "we've never found another way to manage the unprecedented risk inherently posed by the technology of nuclear weapons". He added, "we're going to have nuclear weapons as far into the future as I can see. And they need to be safe, they need to be secure, they need to be reliable."

"Fortunately you don't see us using" nuclear weapons, Carter said in response to a question last week from a sailor at the Pentagon. "And that's a good thing." Nuclear weapons, he said, are "there in the background as a guarantor of our security".

During his long career as a national security specialist, Carter has written extensively about nuclear weapons issues. In a 1985 article titled The Command and Control of Nuclear War he dissected the intricate issue of how wartime decisions would be communicated to and executed by the nuclear force. He was the lead author of a report, Crisis Stability and Nuclear War, in 1987, again examining nuclear command and control issues.

During Bill Clinton's first term in the White House, Carter served as assistant secretary of defence for nuclear security and counter-proliferation.

Read more on:    ash carter  |  us  |  nuclear

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

Inside News24


Book flights

Compare, Book, Fly

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.