AS IT HAPPENED: SA appears before ICC over failure to arrest Sudan’s Bashir

2017-04-07 14:00

Get the latest details as South Africa appears before the ICC to defend its failure to arrest Sudanese President Oma al-Bashir who is wanted on charged of genocide.

Omar al-Bashir

Jump to

Last Updated at 16:40
07 Apr 15:55

The hearing concludes.

The chamber to present its conclusions in "due course".

07 Apr 15:54
President #bashir notified us after he landed in SA, very last minute, we were aware of the concern, "govt wheels turn slow"

07 Apr 14:47

07 Apr 14:08
Hearing adjourns. It will resume at 15:00

07 Apr 14:04

07 Apr 14:01
Nicholls wraps up. #ICC needs state parties to comply in order to prevent impunity. Acts of non-compliance (like SA) are severe

07 Apr 14:00
Rastan: Instead of preventing al-#Bashir leaving (SA in 2015), SA assisted him in leaving. Never intended to arrest him in 1st place #ICC

07 Apr 13:59

Rastan: SA triggered article 97 consultations.

ICC said SA must arrest al-#Bashir, SA wanted futher consultations. SA should have prevented him leaving

07 Apr 13:43
Rastan: SA agreed to article 72 which clearly states domestic law on immunities should not impede surrendering charged people to

07 Apr 13:42
Rastan: ICC has no police as enforcement so relies on cooperation of states (to arrest those charged). Otherwise can't end impunity

07 Apr 13:38

07 Apr 13:35
ICC representative Rod Rastan shoots down SA argument that it couldn't arrest al-#Bashir because Sudan not Rome Statute signatory. UNSC referral sufficient

07 Apr 13:31

07 Apr 13:12
Prosecutor:SA failed legal obligation and now searching for legal impediment to rely on

07 Apr 13:11
#ICC prosecutor: SA is (wrongly) arguing that this court is not competent to interpret laws on its own jurisdiction

07 Apr 13:11
Next #ICC prosecutor is concluding court's case. He too struggles to speak slowly. "I have SLOW DOWN written on top of every page

07 Apr 13:11

07 Apr 12:59

07 Apr 12:58
Prosecutor: There would have been no confusion if SA approached the court sooner

07 Apr 12:57

07 Apr 12:57
Prosection: if duty to arrest Al-Bashir (which SA agreed it had) was such complex matter, why did S-Africa ask so late for #ICC consultation

07 Apr 12:35
Nicholls presents affidavit by DG of Presidency to prove cabinet received confirmation from al-#Bashir beginning June 2015 of AU summit

07 Apr 12:35
Nicholls: Consultations (#ICC & SA govt) 12/6/2015, day before al-#Bashir landed) done correctly. Even if SA objects, still had to arrest

07 Apr 12:26
Nicholls: we acknowledge SA's contribution to #ICC in the past but it cannot excuse non-compliance (to arrest al-Bashir)

07 Apr 12:25
ICC prosecutor Julian Nicholls: SA simply disregarded obligation to co-operate with arresting al-#Bashir simply because they disagreed with law

07 Apr 12:22
ICC prosecutor is now making the court's case on SA's failure to arrest al-#Bashir. Says yes, SA failed, and yes must go to ASP/UNSC

07 Apr 12:09
Arguments at the ICC have started again after a 30-minute tea break. ICC representatives will now present their case on SA failing to arrest

07 Apr 11:48
The hearing takes a 30min break

07 Apr 11:46
Tladi is also asking the ICC chamber that it looks at the interpretation of the relevant UNSC resolutions relevant to this matter

07 Apr 11:45
Tladi: SA can't disengage from AU or obligations to host summit. But political and diplomatic complexities in legal labyrinth

07 Apr 11:39
Take note: South Africa is insisting to International Criminal Court judges that it did not have to arrest Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir when he visited Johannesburg in 2015.

07 Apr 11:24
Tladi: Some context- should not reduce this case or criminal justice project to a single individual

07 Apr 11:24

07 Apr 11:23

07 Apr 11:20
Tladi: Nothing in law to show SA excused from obligation under domestic law (of immunity) because Sudan not in Rome Statute

07 Apr 11:19

07 Apr 11:19
Here is the link to South Africa's submission to the ICC from which Prof Dire Tladi is currently arguing:

07 Apr 11:06
Tladi: Presence of jurisdiction of an international court or tribunal is not equal to immunity of national jurisdiction (Malawi, Chad)

07 Apr 11:03
Tladi: Duty to arrest al-#Bashir is not as clear as the prosecutor of the #ICC is making it out to be

07 Apr 10:53
Tladi: SA had no obligation under Rome Statute to arrest sitting head of state like al-#Bashir, who is not signatory to RS #ICC

07 Apr 10:45
Tladi:Case has far-reaching legal consequences beyond al-#Bashir. It's about immunity of many heads of state, integrity of Rome Statute

07 Apr 10:41
Tladi: It's not true that SA provided for unimpeded travel for al-#Bashir in particular. Provisions were for AU summit as a whole

07 Apr 10:40
Tladi: issue is not whether SA violated obligations under SA law, but whether transgressions under Rome Statute/int law

07 Apr 10:39
Prof Dire Tladi now has the floor. He is also told to speak more slowly. He admits it is difficult for him

07 Apr 10:39
De Wet: Article 97 consultations, the meeting held btwn #ICC-SA June 2015 day before #Bashir landed-was quasi-judicial, but should be diplomatic

07 Apr 10:38
De Wet: South Africa is not an accused (in this hearing) and sovereign states governed by rules and procedure

07 Apr 10:38
Message from the interpreters on the system again. Could De Wet please slow down? She does so with some effort ..

07 Apr 10:32
Tarfusser interrupts De Wet. Could she speak more slowly for the interpreters? She slows down marginally

07 Apr 10:31
State legal representative Sandia de Wet now making SA case at #ICC. First time such a public hearing held, she says

07 Apr 10:31
SA's legal counsellor in The Hague, Andre Stemmet, it also here to represent South Africa's case. - Carien du Plessis 

Jump to


Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.