Analysis  >  Friday Briefing: Can André de Ruyter fix Eskom?

Andre de Ruyter Friday Briefing cover News24

Fixing Eskom isn't black and white

This week Cabinet and the ANC threw their weight behind the much-awaited appointment of André de Ruyter as the new CEO of Eskom. The markets reacted with a healthy dose of surprise and scepticism about whether De Ruyter will be able to address the debt-laden firm's short-term challenges given that he has no experience managing a state enterprise.

But no one was more surprised than the EFF, who labelled the appointment of a white man to the position as "anti-transformation".

"[Minister of Public Enterprises] Pravin [Gordhan] does not believe that Africans can manage and build complex institutions. The only time he is comfortable appointing Africans is when he puts them in a position of permanent juniority and treats them like his lap dogs," the party said in a statement.

The comment triggered a vigorous debate about race and the government's transformation agenda, but as analyst Mpumelelo Mkhabela argues in this week's briefing, missing from the debate has been a discussion about why black executives have failed at state enterprises in the past and are wary to put their hands up for the position now.

Business Insider's Helena Wasserman goes on a fact-finding mission about De Ruyter's past experience to find out whether he is up to the task, and columnist Howard Feldman leaves us with a cheeky reminder that no one will be able see race or colour in the dark when there is no electricity.

Enjoy the read.

Alet Law

News24 opinions editor

André de Ruyter and the corruption of transformation

Mpumelelo Mkhabela

Under ideal circumstances the race of a person appointed to a position of influence at a state-owned enterprise shouldn't matter. In this era of globalisation, where sought-after skilled people circulate globally, even the nationality of the appointee shouldn't be a big deal. It should only be about whether the appointee has the right skill, know-how and attitude to do the work. But we are not yet the ideal society envisaged in our Constitution. 


coal power station,eskom,electricity

Eskom's new boss is 'Mr Coal' and a natural-born CEO, former colleagues say

Helena Wasserman

André de Ruyter didn't have much of a honeymoon period following his appointment as Eskom's new CEO, amid union criticism and the utility's bond yields taking a hit in the wake of the news. Much of the criticism was centred on the struggling performance of Nampak during his tenure as CEO – with his track record at Sasol largely ignored.



Howard Feldman

André de Ruyter has a mammoth task ahead of him. It is vital that we allow him to focus on his mission and that we don't distract him with conversations that might be grounded in political expediency. It is vital that we keep remembering that in the dark, no one sees anything, let alone colour.


SIGN UP for the Friday Briefing newsletter, delivered to your inbox early every Friday morning, for insight and analysis on the big political story of the week.



Press Code We subscribe to the Press Code.

E-mail Newsletters You choose what you want

News24 on Android Get the latest from News24 on your Android device.

Terms and Conditions Terms and Conditions - Updated April 2012

Interactive Advertising Bureau
© 2019 All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.