Crunch time for property scheme

2010-07-25 13:29

The Reserve Bank is set to decide whether it will force South

Africa’s largest property syndication scheme to repay billions of rands to

thousands of investors.

Financial experts feared that investors – many of them pensioners –

were in danger of losing their money if the Reserve Bank cracked down.

The Reserve Bank recently found that over a period of six years,

­Sharemax Investments received more than R5 billion from 40 000 investors in an

illegal manner.

It said Sharemax operated as a bank without being ­registered as


Sharemax, the largest syndication scheme in South Africa by a long

­margin, has been operating for more than a decade and canvasses investments for

property developments.

Sharemax offers fixed monthly ­interest far higher than bank rates.

It admits in its prospectus that it dabbles in “high-risk investments”.

This week Sharemax assured investors that their money was safe and

­disputed the Reserve Bank’s findings.

But forensic auditor and chartered accountant André Prakke said the

­findings were “far-reaching” and ­investors could lose their money.

“Investors may be ordered to pay back all interest and dividends

­received from their investments.

They have invested in an illegal scheme,”

Prakke said Sharemax is one of the only property syndication companies in South

Africa that is still standing after the recent global recession.

In recent years, at least six other property syndicates have either

been declared bankrupt or been placed ­under ­judicial management.

Thousands of investors – many of whom had ploughed their life

savings into the schemes – are now stripped of an income and are likely to

recover ­little (if any) of their original ­investments.

Sharemax’s investors include pensioners, businesspeople and

sporting ­celebrities who, in most cases, have ­invested R100 000 or more into

­shopping centres or property ­developments.

One of Sharemax’s most prominent investors is Springbok flyhalf and

Blue Bulls hero Morné Steyn.

Sharemax ­recently announced on its website that

Steyn was not only an investor but had offered his services to Sharemax

­Investments to attract investors.

The Reserve Bank said the case against Sharemax was still “pending”

and various aspects still needed to be “worked out”.

Sharemax has been given until Wednesday to make representations to

the Reserve Bank about how it plans to run its business in future.

Deputy registrar of the Reserve Bank advocate Michael Blackbeard

told City Press this week: “When an investigation has found that a person has

been ­operating the business of a bank without being registered accordingly, the

­Reserve Bank has the powers to stop the business, to repay the deposits or a

pro rata portion thereof to investors and to hand the case over to the police

for ­criminal prosecution.”

Prakke said this would have catastrophic consequences for

Sharemax’s investors.

Prakke, a long-standing critic of Sharemax’s financial

model, warned as far back as 2007 that Sharemax was acting in contravention of

­banking laws and that investors’ money was unsafe.

Property syndicates have been in the spotlight in recent years

because of promises of unusually high interest rates to investors, and

suggestions that they contravene banking ­regulations and laws.

Critics like Prakke argued that they could be construed as pyramid

schemes because existing investors receive interest from new investors’


One of the syndicates that was ­recently liquidated is Bluezone.

The 6 000 people who invested R800 million in the scheme are expected to ­only

recoup between 12% and 20% of their original investments.

Prakke said the financial models employed by Bluezone and Sharemax

had striking similarities. He believed that Sharemax could now also find ­itself

in trouble and that the Reserve Bank’s finding could lead to court ­applications

to have the company ­liquidated.

“I would be very worried if I was an investor in one of Sharemax’s

­companies,” Prakke said.

“If Sharemax is forced to pay back investors’ money, there is no

way they will all get their money back.”

But the managing director of Sharemax, Willie Botha, assured

investors this week that their money was “100% safe”.

He claimed that the Reserve Bank’s findings were “technical” and

did not involve an “intentional transgression” of banking laws.

He had asked the Reserve Bank to reconsider its findings.

If the

Reserve Bank stood by its findings, Sharemax planned to approach the courts for

a declaratory order on the matter.

Prakke said: “If a court agrees with the Reserve Bank, the bank

will have to act against Sharemax because the investments were obtained in an

illegal manner. Then the investors will come second and lose money.”

Lardo Stander, an independent ­financial analyst, said if Sharemax

was forced to repay investors it would have to sell about 30 of its shopping

centres across the country.

“Sharemax buys or develops a shopping centre for R100 million, but

syndicates it for R130 million,” said Stander.

“If they are now forced to sell,

they will, as a result of the fall in the property market, get a lot less than

the original sales price. Then investors will lose.”

Botha told City Press this week that following the Reserve Bank’s

findings, Sharemax had altered its financial model to bring it in line with the

Banks Act.

Botha said that Sharemax had ­always attempted to do business in

line with banking and financial laws, and that investors had received their

­returns punctually for the past 11 years.

Join the conversation! encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.