‘How the hell did Noakes paper get through peer review?’

2013-12-15 10:00

The brouhaha following the South African Medical Journal’s (SAMJ’s) publication of the Noakes paper is probably best captured by the angry Tweet of Mail & Guardian editor Nic Dawes: “How the hell did that thing get through peer review? Should be a scandal at the SAMJ.”

Others have said the journal would not have published such an anecdote-based paper if it weren’t authored by a scientist of Noakes’ standing.

The paper is based on a series of personal, self-reported case studies from 127 people who contacted Noakes with accounts of the successes they’d had with drastic weight loss, stabilising cholesterol and other positive health spin-offs by switching to a low carb/high fat (LCHF) diet.

Criticism of the paper was more about the process than the content: self-reporting by individuals is notoriously unreliable since it’s hard to eliminate personal biases in the recounting of these cases; this only reflects success stories, not the cases where the diet has failed people (where people have gained weight, their bad cholesterol has climbed or they haven’t been able to sustain the eating plan).

However, SAMJ deputy editor Dr Bridget Farham defended the decision to publish the paper, because Noakes clearly states the limitations of self-reported cases like this, and he lists peer-reviewed references which show that “these findings are congruent with what people have found in nutritional studies in the USA”.

“(The paper) was published in the Forum section of the journal,” explains Farham, which is a space that allows for ideas which provoke thinking, “one of the functions of an academic journal”.

Even though the “hierarchy of evidence” behind these self-reported cases is “questionable”, Farham points out that Noakes uses the paper as a platform to call for the very thing he is accused of not having: solid, evidence-based data from long-term clinical trials. This will give the kind of conclusions needed to redraft the problematic dietary guidelines that have dictated how we have been instructed to eat for the past three decades.

“These guidelines are being questioned globally, and he uses this article to do so.”

Meanwhile, health writer Mandi Smallhorne explains that an “occasional survey” of this nature is a valid and recognised way of presenting an emerging idea in a scientific journal. It’s a “trending” idea, where something is emerging but there hasn’t been of interest to science yet or still needs years of research to back it up.

“It’s saying ‘let’s think about this’ rather than ‘I claim this’,’ explains Smallhorne.

Noakes says he’s not making any scientific claims on the back of this paper, but merely saying it raises some questions which now need answering, and the next step is the clinical trials that will shed further light, either way.

Join the conversation!

24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

We reserve editorial discretion to decide what will be published.
Read our comments policy for guidelines on contributions.

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.


Location Settings

News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location. If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to take affect.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.