Was Le Clos ‘robbed’ of top accolade?

2013-11-24 10:00

Multimedia   ·   User Galleries   ·   News in Pictures Send us your pictures  ·  Send us your stories

Votes do the talking for SA Sports Star of the Year

The awarding of the SA Sports Star of the Year to Kaizer Chiefs’ Itumeleng Khune has sparked a huge public debate.

Some believe swimming world champion Chad le Clos deserves the sports award over the Bafana captain. Khune walked away with a R1?million grand prize and a brand-new BMW.

The two were nominated in the same category with cricketer Hashim Amla, mid-distance runner Mapaseka Makhanya and Lucas Sithole, the wheelchair tennis star. But what came from the raging debate showed that some people were concerned about the criteria used to determine the winner.

According to the awards rule book: “Sports Star of the Year is voted for by the public via an SMS voting line. The candidate for the award must have competed in South Africa during the awards qualifying period and been the country’s most popular athlete during the qualifying period.”

The candidates were nominated by the awards voting panel based on their performances between October 2012 and August this year.

“I still don’t understand how Khune beat you [Le Clos]. I mean he only won two medals and you won 24 gold medals,” Clement Sono posted on Facebook.

Nkosinathi Shabalala added: “You [Le Clos] were absolutely robbed.”

And Jacinta Zinhle Ngobese added: “He [Khune] actually was nominated and it was open for the public to vote, which makes no sense at all. Unfortunately, they voted and a goalkeeper won because he’s popular. We all know Chad is the greatest sports star in the world, not just SA.”

However, Bheki Mtshali said: “People forget that Chiefs is a big family, bigger than any other families in South Africa. Unfortunately, only votes do the talking in this whole thing ... You guys must vote next time and stop complaining.”

Added Nduduzo Okagubhela Mkhize: “Hey people, Khune didn’t vote for himself.”

He added that the organisers should consider introducing the Most Popular Sports Star award in future and leave the judging panel with the task of choosing the winner on merit.

And if that was the case with the event at Sun City last Sunday, Le Clos would have been the ultimate winner.

Chad le Clos’s achievement

Chad le Clos. Picture: Felix Dlangamandla/Foto24


Chad’s achievements between October 2012  and August 2013

FINA Swimming World Cup

Eindhoven, the Netherlands

August 7-8: Gold – 100m butterfly (49.08); 200m butterfly (1:49.04 – world record); Bronze – 50m butterfly (22.62)

Berlin, Germany

August 10-11: Gold – 200m butterfly (1:49.90); Silver – 100m butterfly (49.48); 200m individual medley (IM) (1:52.11); Bronze – 50m butterfly (22.53)

August 30: Appointed the International Olympic Committee official ambassador to the 2014 Youth Olympic Games in Nanjing, China

World Championships

July-August: Gold – 100m butterfly (51.06); 200m butterfly (1:54.32)

National Order

April 23: Awarded the Order of Ikhamanga in silver

SA National Aquatic Championships

April 15-20: Gold – 100m butterfly (51.79); 200m butterfly (1:56.35); 100m freestyle (48.95); 200m freestyle (1:48.63); Silver – 50m butterfly (23.72)

FINA World Short Course Championships

December 2012: Gold?–?100m?butterfly?(48.82); Silver?–?50m butterfly (22.26)

Itumeleng Khune’s achievement

Itumeleng Khune. Picture: Trevor Kunene/Daily Sun

Age: 26

Achievements between October 2012 and August 2013

National team

January 12: Khune earns his 50th Bafana cap

League awards

May 26

Absa Premiership Footballer of the Season

Players’ Player of the Season

Goalkeeper of the Season

Nedbank Cup Player of the Tournament

Club awards (Kaizer Chiefs)

May 31

Player of the Season

Players’ Player of the Season

Online Player of the Season

Amakhosi Magazine Readers’ Choice

»?Talk to us: How should the Sa Sports Star of the Year Be chosen?

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Inside News24

Traffic Alerts
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.


Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.